This week’s conversation is with Natasha DeJarnett, an assistant professor at the University of Louisville in Kentucky who previously was deputy director for environmental justice data and evaluation in the Biden White House’s Council on Environmental Quality.
After the 2026 midterm elections it’s safe to say data centers are the new political punching bag – but an irony in this is how fights over these projects closely resemble the very same environmental justice conversations that were front and center under Biden. Like many of us in energy and environment professions, DeJarnett didn’t expect to be working on data centers, until she started being invited to communities fighting these projects to provide her perspective and public health expertise. She’s since become one of the go-to voices from the previous administration when it comes to data center conflicts and community relationships.
I wanted to talk to Natasha about her time in the previous government and how it shapes her perspective on data centers. The following conversation was lightly edited for clarity.
How would you distill the problem in the relationship between data center developers and the communities they’re in conflict with?
The lack of community engagement, involvement or its voice being reflected in what’s coming into their communities.
It’s not this way across the board but from our experience in rural Kentucky, the community wasn’t involved in the decision on where to site the data center. They weren’t asked for their opinion or given a chance for public comment. They deserve to have that chance because it’ll impact their environment and their health – that’s the definition of environmental justice.
I firmly believe communities should have that say and we all share that value. Some people have not been able to voice their concerns. That’s one of the things people need to know.
Another thing is, this has potential health impacts we don’t appreciate. This is vitally important for people to consider when it comes to where projects are located. You should decide siting based on the health impacts. You have to consider the factors that might render communities to be more vulnerable too, like whether there are a lot of children or elderly people being around them.
The Kapor Foundation out of Oakland, California did a study of data center locations across California and they found location was the single strongest predictor of how a data center actually impacted the community around them. We need to be more informed about individual community health risks and what burdens a community may also be dealing with.
I worked on the Climate and Economic Justice Screening Tool under the Biden administration, and there was also the EJScreen – those may not be available in the federal government but they’re still available elsewhere, and those health impacts should be more utilized to determine the locations of sites. Health impact assessments would be a good tool to help pick the locations for these too.
What are those health impacts you’re talking about?
Air pollution concerns rise quickly to the top in my mind. Not saying they’re more important than others but my area of expertise is air pollution and cardiovascular disease risk.
In addition to that, we have water use. I think there’s a couple ways to consider water. On the one hand you have the use of the water itself, pulling from the resources, which could contribute to water scarcity and insecurity – that’s associated with adverse health impacts. There’s also the water that comes out of the data center, wastewater that comes out. Who is responsible for treating that water? That’s potential contamination associated with gastrointestinal outcomes and other health issues.
There’s noise pollution which is an underdiscussed part of health writ large. The things inside of many data centers are noisy. The mechanics for cooling data centers are noisy. Construction of data centers is noisy. The interesting thing about data center noise is that it can be 24/7 so that means there’s even nighttime noise. All noise can be linked to health impacts but nighttime noise can especially be connected because it impacts sleep quality which can be linked to heart disease and adverse impacts to mental health. There’s also light pollution, which can impact sleep and thus health.
We have to consider the cumulative impacts. We already have a number of exposures in certain communities and then this is added on top of that. It further impacts communities already experiencing different exposures that have adverse impacts on health.
The data center issue came at all of us pretty fast. You were working on environmental justice issues in the Biden administration. Do you feel like we may have missed something coming?
No. I don’t want to say we missed something.
But your point is well-taken. This is coming at us very quickly. I spent time in that administration looking at maps of communities across the U.S. in addition to other responsibilities. I became quite sensitive to communities long overburdened and continue to experience under-investment.
We were invited into one community [in Kentucky]. When I went to the climate and economic justice tool, I found the county was one of the wealthiest counties in Kentucky. I immediately concluded that if they don’t want the data center it won’t move forward because they have the social capital to be able to say what they want or don’t want. And that’s largely how that turned out – they invited experts into their community, they were very well-prepared for their hearings. And so that experience made me think, okay, where are there communities that are industrial centers? Where are communities with known environmental injustices?
I then thought of West Louisville which is home to about 11 rubber manufacturers. It is a community with a large number of people of color. There are hazardous waste sites, Superfund sites, and what I am describing is classic environmental injustice. And I thought, there’s probably going to be a data center there. I found out, yes, and the data center had already been approved months before I looked at this. There was barely any media coverage of it and I’m guessing a lot of people were unaware of it.
Now, what I’ll say is this: data centers are not always linked with environmental injustice. What is happening in Data Center Alley in Virginia is not environmental injustice. That’s a relatively affluent area. I’m not saying it’s not an unfortunate situation. But when I’m talking about environmental injustice, I’m talking about communities that have long been overburdened and long experienced underinvestment.
When it comes to lessons learned from the Biden administration, what do you think could be gleaned from the successes and challenges you and others faced when it came to community relations in the energy sector and industrial development? Are there any lessons from your time there that can be brought to the data center conversation?
We can prioritize disadvantaged communities and we can all benefit.
For years, people have been aware of communities overburdened by pollution and underinvestment. People have long been aware of the need to prioritize these communities. And it's always, we can’t just prioritize these communities and when we do it, it doesn’t help everyone. They always say, you’ve got to prioritize everybody.
What we learned [under Biden] is that it can benefit everybody. We set a goal that 40% of certain investments – like those in climate change and workforce development as well as legacy pollution and transportation – should benefit disadvantaged communities. That was the goal, that was what Justice40 was.
At the end of the administration the analysis found 71% of those benefits reached disadvantaged communities and the thing is, all benefited. When we’re thinking about things like where to site hazardous polluters or have a considerable amount of different burdens, we have tools to better understand the location of these [projects] and working in close connection with communities benefits all communities. It’s not foreign to what we already know.
What do you think the best practices should be for data center developers?
Engaging communities meaningfully.
I find it very difficult to say what impacts a community if we’re not able to access water data and other materials – transparency is something communities are asking for that are impacted by trade secrets and NDAs. This makes it more challenging to truly know what is coming or already there, as well as understand how it may be impacting them right now.
It’s vitally important for this engagement to be meaningful – give people a voice as to what’s coming regardless as to what is zoned or how it is zoned.
Now, I don’t have a developer’s mind. But this is what I want them to know.