The Fight

Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Hotspots

Why Virginia Forced Google to Spill Its Data Center Secrets

Plus more of the week’s biggest development fights.

The United States.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Botetourt County, Virginia – Google has released its water use plans for a major data center in Virginia after a local news outlet argued regulators couldn’t withhold that information under public records laws.

  • Google’s planned data center campus in Botetourt County has been wrapped in secrecy. Many details about the project have been exposed by the Roanoke Rambler, a local investigative media publication founded by Henri Gendreau, who has previously contributed to Wired, Bloomberg News, and other media outlets.
  • The Rambler sued the Western Virginia Water Authority, a quasi-public water regulator, to compel it to disclose how much water the data center complex planned to use. After a protracted legal battle, the authority released Google’s water contracts, confirming it would use 2 million gallons of water per day. That’s almost 10 times the amount used by the authority’s largest water customer, a Coca-Cola plant. The amount would increase to 8 million gallons daily if the data center campus expands.
  • Per the Rambler, this records release is the first time a data center deal has been ruled subject to public records requests in Virginia, i.e. exempt from trade secret protections. It could have sweeping implications for future efforts to hold data center developers accountable for their environmental impacts.

Montana – Ladies, gentlemen, and everyone in between, we have a freshly dead wind farm.

  • NextEra pulled the plug on the Glendive wind farm across McCone, Prairie, and Dawson counties in Montana this week after failing to secure customer agreements for the electricity it would produce. The energy giant clarified to local media the project was not impeded by any federal legislation (such as the repeal of tax credits). But it’s noteworthy a wind farm out in this part of the country failed to get any buyers.
  • Glendive’s nosedive happens amidst a broader pushback from locals. It used to be that property rights reigned supreme out here, similar to the Dakotas and Wyoming, and so far there are only five wind projects in our opposition database. Yet restrictive ordinances have cropped up at the county level within the past few months, including in the counties where Glendive was proposed.

Oklahoma County, Oklahoma – A huge rally is scheduled in Oklahoma City this weekend in support of ending wind and solar farm construction in the state.

  • The March 7 rally, entitled “Protect Our Land: No Green Scam,” includes the president of CFACT, a conservative organization we’ve covered closely that is on the front lines of the battle to quash renewable energy permits. The event also features prominent voices I’ve covered before, like State Representative Jim Shaw and activist Saundra Traywick.
  • Curiously, the logo for the Oil & Gas Workers Association is on the event flyer. OGWA is headquartered in Texas and is an advocacy group dead set on slowing the decline in oil and gas jobs from the energy transition.

Mingo County, West Virginia – Coal country is rebelling against data centers.

  • Per local media, a closed door meeting between TransGas Development Systems and local elected officials was interrupted by residents protesting the construction of a new data center that would have its own power plant and access to water typically used for mines.
  • Residents have also filed a federal lawsuit to block construction of the TransGas data center campus, one of the first federal cases against a single data center I’ve ever seen. That case is still pending.
  • Mingo County is one of the nation’s most historic coal mining areas and demonstrates how painful the fuel’s decline has been for regions previously reliant on mining the black rock. This is also a county with a higher risk of opposing data centers than renewable energy, according to Heatmap Pro’s database, a characteristic likely defined by an older population more accustomed to energy development than technology infrastructure.

Mesa County, Colorado – This county’s government is implementing a new legal standard for energy storage – and it is causing problems.

  • At issue is Mesa County’s attorney’s implementation of existing fire code, which is stirring up angst amongst anti-battery activists on social media who claim – without clear evidence – that it wouldn’t be protective enough. They’re organizing to oppose current fire protection standards at a county commission on March 10 that I’ll be watching closely.
  • Part of the local push against battery (and solar) has been driven by an outgrowth of Mesa County Concerned Residents, an ad hoc local organization also organizing rallies against the incarceration of ex-county clerk Tina Peters on election data tampering charges related to the 2020 Stop the Steal campaign.
Yellow

This article is exclusively
for Heatmap Plus subscribers.

Go deeper inside the politics, projects, and personalities
shaping the energy transition.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Q&A

How to Talk to Climate-Minded Investors About Data Centers

A chat with Colette Lamontagne, senior director for electric power at Ceres.

Colette Lamontagne.
Heatmap Illustration

This week’s conversation is with Colette Lamontagne, senior director for electric power at the sustainability finance advocacy group Ceres. Her team just released a shareholder engagement guide for the utility space around data center development. I’ve been wondering when the ESG crowd would enter into the AI infrastructure fray, so I asked if I could chat with Colette about what the guide could teach my lovely readers and whether the data center backlash portends a new wave of boardroom fights between electric companies and institutional investors.

Our conversation was lightly edited for clarity.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow
Hotspots

The Most Important Data Center Vote You Haven’t Heard About

Plus more on this week’s biggest development fights.

The United States.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

1. Washtenaw County, Michigan — The Mitten State made itself the center of the data center backlash this week, as multiple AI skeptics won key Democratic congressional primaries. Yet the most significant election result wasn’t a primary vote, but rather a quiet referendum in a small town outside Ann Arbor.

  • On Tuesday, the town of Augusta voted by a nearly 9-1 margin to overturn a land use ordinance enacted by the township government the previous year allowing a data center on agricultural land. This means developer Thor Equities will either have to find a way around clear local rejection or abandon Augusta for its proposed data center.
  • Augusta sits on the border of Michigan’s 7th congressional district, where Sunrise Movement cofounder Will Lawrence pulled off a surprise upset against a moderate establishment-backed candidate. Lawrence’s victorious primary campaign was rooted almost entirely in advertising against data center development and tying his opposition to supporting the industry.
  • I believe the Augusta result proves the case made by Lawrence’s candidacy — voters will resoundingly back ways to fight data centers. A Lawrence campaign memo published by Politico after the primary makes the argument he will defeat incumbent Republican Tom Barrett almost entirely on this issue, too, calling it “the hyperscale elephant in the room.” The memo also claims there are “data center voters” who have “not traditionally been available to Democrats [but] have been highly motivated by hyperscale development in mid-Michigan.”
  • “Will’s strong stance on this issue and his consistency in showing up and standing alongside residents in data center fights expands his potential voter base in the general,” the memo states.

2. Travis County, Texas — I’ve been getting a lot of texts from sources about Texas Governor Greg Abbott issuing a stop to data center permitting. Let’s get into what really is happening here.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow
Spotlight

How the National Park Service Wound Up in a Data Center Deal

The agency is reportedly considering a land swap that would allow AI infrastructure in one of northern Virginia’s largest green spaces.

The Prince William Forest Park entrance.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

A national park site and Civil War conflict area in Virginia is now a battleground in the fight over data center development on federal real estate — and Congress is starting to get involved.

On July 23, the Prince William Times reported that Trump’s National Park Service is “considering a land swap” to allow “at least four data centers” on land within the boundaries of Prince William Forest Park in northern Virginia, one of the largest green spaces in the Washington D.C. metro area and a flashpoint during the Civil War. Since then, my colleagues and I have confirmed based on interviews with sources familiar with the plan, public lobbying disclosures, and previously unreported correspondence from Congress to the Park Service that, indeed, there has been a concerted behind-the-scenes effort to make this swap happen, going back more than a year. Many of those concerned about the idea of this exchange told me they’ve been unable to get clear answers from the Park Service on the likelihood of the swap.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow