The Fight

Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Spotlight

The Freakout Over the Data Center Loophole That Wasn’t

How a last minute proposal to amend the permitting bill set off panic in Washington

•
The Capitol.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Call it the data center loophole that wasn’t – and the beginning of a new kind of whiplash in energy and tech.

For roughly 48 hours, many souls in Washington D.C. were quietly panicking that the Senate permitting bill’s strongest policy against data centers was about to be weakened. On Tuesday, senators released new changes to the manager’s amendment to the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act addressing issues holdouts on the bill raised about tribal consultation. Included in those modifications however was another change: Senators added language to the bill’s landmark ratepayer protection provision we’ve written about exempting new classes of facilities providing “Internet access” or “information services” as defined under two of the few federal tech statutes on the books.

The apparent intention of this addition was to try and stop the new provisions from becoming a burden on small data centers involved in critical infrastructure, broadband and basic Internet services – the people making sure you have WiFi and cable. But critics of the bill said the specific language senators chose was potentially going much further than that.

As written, the bill applied the ratepayer protection requirements to “computational load sites” which it defines as those that “primarily contain information technology infrastructure involved in” one of four activities: 1) “creating, executing, and delivering software applications and services,” 2) “artificial intelligence training,” 3) “cryptocurrency mining,” or 4) “other computational activities at a data center.” The bill previously exempted from this provision “computing” or “data storage equipment” that is “ancillary” to facilities where their commercial or industrial activity is outside the scope of those four categories. That remains in the bill today.

However, a new change on Tuesday created a separate exemption for “a facility or any equipment that is primarily used to provide” a list of business services, including “Internet access” as defined under the Internet Tax Freedom Act and “information services” as defined under the Telecommunications Act.

The “information services” piece was fairly straightforward as to why it would be problematic – artificial intelligence can be arguably interpreted to be an “information service.” The “Internet access” definition was also a real issue, thanks to precedent going back to the early Internet age. Under the law this language cited to define “Internet access,” tax courts have exempted cloud services and email programs from state taxes.

I became obsessed with trying to figure out what this meant, speaking with lawyers and tech policy experts while researching prior case law. Kevin Chen, an attorney with the law firm Foley Hoag focused on the ratepayer protections, told me the initial addition and its reliance on these laws meant the exempted class of facilities was much closer to the exact types of data centers that were supposed to face these new requirements. Even Aiden Mackenzie, an infrastructure fellow with the D.C.-based Institute for Progress and supporter of the bill, acknowledged the change was “directionally convoluted” and would add “ambiguity that would make it more challenging for FERC to issue a rule they would want to issue.”

Then amidst my interviews about this language, as well as public criticism of it, senators changed the language they were adding to accommodate concerns. They ditched relying on other laws to define Internet access, simply literally describing it as “a service that enables users to connect to the Internet,” and cut the reference to “information services.” A Democratic Hill staffer told the media this change would eliminate “any ambiguity that could allow data centers to avoid paying their fair share of the costs they impose on the grid.”

This new language was released hours before the Senate’s final vote on the bill. I wanted to find out if they actually fixed the problem, because I am not sure they did with “Internet access.” The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission would still have to further define the term because the new language simply nixed the reference to the previous statute and just said it’s “a service that enables users to connect to the Internet.” What that means under the law has been defined and interpreted in various ways over the years, and that was always going to be the problem.

Under this new language, FERC would instead have to proceed with implementing the ratepayer protection program and have to define it themselves through rulemaking. Then, if someone wanted to litigate what that meant, they could do so. It’s also noting that, as Mackenzie explained to me, it stands to reason both FERC and the courts would look at other parts of the bill too to define “Internet access,” including the bill’s definition of “computational load sites” and statements of intent.

Except now, it’s unclear if the non-AI data center operators wishing to get clarity under this program will ever get reprieve. We – the lobbyists, congressional staff, and myself – all kind of wasted our energy.

During debate on the permitting bill, as a form of protest against its sheer existence, Sens. Jeff Merkley and Ron Wyden refused to grant consent to let senators add this language to the bill before final passage. You can read the back and forth here. So now, instead of a speedy fix still clouded by my questions, these companies and I were all left exhausted.

The now-passed permitting bill will have to be considered in the House and the authors of the legislation still want to add this change, which they consider technical and clarifying. It’s also entirely the case that these data center operators could turn to FERC if they don’t get their fix and seek exemption through the rulemaking process instead. Otherwise, the sector legislators were trying to shield – Internet and cable providers – could be at risk of facing these new costs, or at least that’s what is implied by the addition.

In the end, the lesson for us all here is that the U.S. federal legislative process as it currently exists is too often untethered to regular order and the committee process. This renders it a morass for corporations and policy advocates alike. You may think you’re about to get the policy change you needed only to see ego, hubris, and backroom shenanigans easily win out when policy is moving at a racecar’s pace. And you might be able to make massive changes to the law, but it has to be done quickly, by the seat of your pants, and with the risk there’s cleanup to be done afterwards. This was as true of the Inflation Reduction Act as it is of BAAJA.

As the energy and data center sectors look ahead to a new Congress next year eager to conduct rigorous oversight of their interests, I am positive the whiplash will stick around. We’re seeing evidence of that in real time.

Yellow
Black Friday Sale

You’ve read your free article. Keep reading with a Heatmap membership

Take 25% off any plan with code THANKS.
Standard Plan
Member

Everything Heatmap publishes, plus a seat in the room.

$129
$97 /year
  • Unlimited access. Every story and newsletter, with no paywall.
  • Virtual briefings. Live sessions with our reporters.
  • Happy hours and events. Member gatherings throughout the year.
Premium Plan
Supporter

For readers who want to keep the journalism going

$349
$262 /year
  • Everything in Member, plus:
  • Exclusive polling access. Heatmap's climate comms polling.
  • VIP at Heatmap House. A reception ticket, plus a membership to gift.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Q&A

What a Biden Environmental Justice Official Wants Data Center Developers to Know

A conversation with Natasha DeJarnett

•
The Q&A subject.
Heatmap Illustration

This week’s conversation is with Natasha DeJarnett, an assistant professor at the University of Louisville in Kentucky who previously was deputy director for environmental justice data and evaluation in the Biden White House’s Council on Environmental Quality.

After the 2026 midterm elections it’s safe to say data centers are the new political punching bag – but an irony in this is how fights over these projects closely resemble the very same environmental justice conversations that were front and center under Biden. Like many of us in energy and environment professions, DeJarnett didn’t expect to be working on data centers, until she started being invited to communities fighting these projects to provide her perspective and public health expertise. She’s since become one of the go-to voices from the previous administration when it comes to data center conflicts and community relationships.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow
Hotspots

The Deadly Shipwreck Threatening Offshore Wind

And more of the week’s most important conflicts around energy and data centers.

•
The United States.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

1. Rhode Island – Anyone interested in the renewable energy sector needs to familiarize themselves with an obscure shipwreck off the coast of New England because it’s the newest ammo in the gunfight against offshore wind.

  • In September, anti-wind environmental group Green Oceans announced it discovered a lost fishing boat, the F/V Mistress, at the bottom of the sea within 50 feet from one of the five operating turbines at the Block Island offshore wind farm – the first offshore wind farm to operate in U.S. waters.
  • Green Oceans claimed they also discovered the remains of one of the two people who died in the wreck, which occurred in 2019, under the first Trump administration. They then asked the Interior Department and Coast Guard to open an investigation into whether the offshore wind farm played a role in the incident, claiming federal records from that time indicate the wind farm made it challenging to save those onboard.
  • Since this public request, the F/V Mistress is one of the primary points of discussion I’ve seen come up in anti-wind Facebook pages. The New England Fishermen’s Stewardship Association, an anti-wind fishing group, has also embraced the call for government action. Bonnie Brady, the group’s policy director, claimed the wind farm created “ghost images” that made it challenging to save the fishermen and that rescues are being delayed by the turbines.
  • “Why didn’t anyone tell President Trump that these two men died right next to a wind farm, whether it was state waters or not? Why? Because they knew that if someone knew that, it would’ve been canceled immediately,” Brady told local conservative talk radio host John Castimatidis in September. (Castimatidis is the Trump-supporting billionaire owner of Red Apple Group, a multi-sectoral conglomerate that includes oil interests.)
  • Brady has continued to beat this drum within the past few weeks as Congress advanced the permitting bill, which the Senate passed on Thursday. That’s likely because it could totally be legal for the federal government to target permitted – maybe even operating – wind farms on these grounds, because the legislation stipulates such actions are allowed in cases where “public health, interest, or safety” is in jeopardy. There is also a national security permission structure and given the Coast Guard’s role in shielding the nation, any intervention by that agency would have serious weight. Ultimately, the risk here is to all offshore wind farms, both permitted and operating.

2. Ozaukee County, Wisconsin – Construction on a Vantage and Oracle hyperscale data center in one of the hottest spots for development in the Badger State is allegedly making the local water… well, there’s little way to describe it other than cloudy.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow
Q&A

How to Channel Voters’ Anxieties About Data Centers

A conversation with the Guardrails Alliance’s Shaunna Thomas.

•
The Q&A subject.
Heatmap Illustration

This week’s Q&A is with Shaunna Thomas of the Democrat-allied super PAC Guardrails Alliance, which describes itself as “not anti-technology” but supportive of AI “rules, accountability, and a government that actually represents the public.” Part of that AI accountability they’re calling for is on data centers.

After the midterms, Guardrails Alliance sent a memorandum to all House and Senate Democratic offices arguing for AI and data center accountability to be a key part of their message and plans heading into the new Congress. Described as a “playbook for how to understand and channel anxieties about AI and data centers,” the document laid out “key narratives” that they said voters who care about these issues want to see reflected and echoed by their politics. They said the push against data centers could help Democrats build more lasting political power.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow