Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Politics

Key House Democrat Calls for a National Data Center Moratorium

New Jersey’s Frank Pallone, ranking member on the House Energy and Commerce Committee, says “this simply cannot continue.”

Frank Pallone.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

It was just yesterday that I wrote about the Ratepayer Protection Act, a bill that would transform into law the voluntary pledge big tech companies signed with the White House to take on additional electric grid costs from their data centers. My argument was that it’s not so much an anti-artificial intelligence or anti-data center bill, but rather a move to insulate further data center development from political pressure stemming from rising electricity costs.

Well, at least one influential lawmaker seems to agree with me. The Democratic ranking member of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, New Jersey Representative Frank Pallone, called for a national data center moratorium before the Wednesday afternoon markup of a series of data center-related bills, the Ratepayer Protection Act among them.

Pallone described the proposals being discussed at the markup as a “useful first step,” but that “compared to the challenges the American power grid is facing, they are not nearly enough.” Instead, he called for “a national AI data center moratorium until we can find a way to ensure they don't harm our nation's air, water, and power bills.”

Pallone cited a slew of efforts in his home state to slow the rapid proliferation of data centers, including a resolution in Asbury Park calling for a statewide moratorium and the city of New Brunswick rejecting a planned data center project earlier this year.

“This simply cannot continue,” Pallone said of the pace of data center development. (When asked for comment, Pallone’s office pointed to his prepared remarks.)

Pallone is not the first Democrat to call for a data center moratorium, but he’s the moratorium supporter who is most closely involved in energy policy at the national level. Senator Bernie Sanders and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, two of Congress’ most prominent progressive Democrats, have called for a nationwide moratorium, sponsoring a bill that would enact “a reasonable pause to the development of AI to ensure the safety of humanity,” including a halt to data center construction until a laundry list of conditions were met related to both energy prices and AI safeguards.

The Democrat-controlled New York State legislature also passed a one-year data center moratorium earlier this month, although the bill is still sitting on the desk of Governor Kathy Hochul, a Democrat, awaiting her signature or veto.

Politicians calling for moratoria are trying to catch up with a public that has quickly soured on data centers. A majority of the American public supports a nationwide moratorium, according to polling done by Heatmap, with 40% of respondents giving the idea their strong support.

One reason why Americans increasingly oppose data centers is that they blame the developments for inflating their electricity bills. When Heatmap polled this question last August, 28% of respondents blamed “the construction of new data centers” for rising electricity prices. When we asked again last month, 53% did.

Analysts have looked at electricity price increases in the past five to 10 years and found little consistent relationship with data center construction, though that is not necessarily true everywhere and at all times.

In New Jersey, which is part of the PJM Interconnection electricity market, prices have likely risen based on current and planned data center construction within a grid area that has long had trouble bringing on new generation or building out sufficient transmission. PJM’s independent market monitor has attributed $23 billion in added costs to “existing and forecast data center load” in the system’s capacity auctions.

New Jersey Governor Mikie Sherrill implemented a rate freeze almost immediately following her inauguration earlier this year after years of price hikes and rising bills. Average electricity bills in the state have risen from around $91 per month to $140 per month, according to the Heatmap-MIT Electricity Price Hub, while electricity prices have risen almost 52% in the past five years.

Pallone was skeptical that any intermediate steps have or could work to protect ratepayers.

“Promises by the data center industry and Big Tech that these facilities will bring down costs have fallen flat,” Pallone said at Wednesday’s markup. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission’s efforts to prompt regional electricity markets to overhaul their interconnection policies “may have promise, but it will take months, if not years, to come to fruition,” he said. The Ratepayer Protection Pledge, meanwhile, has “no enforcement,” and constitutes a “toothless promise from Big Tech.”

“Americans across the country have expressed concern and opposition to the rampant construction of AI data centers, and Congress should take this political groundswell seriously with a data center moratorium,” Pallone concluded. “That's what we need.”

Blue

You’re out of free articles.

Subscribe to access Heatmap’s expert analysis of energy, climate change, and sustainability, including coverage of our regular survey research. Save $57 on an annual subscription, just $156 $99/year.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Electric Vehicles

Maybe Don’t Rent an EV in Europe

There are lots of reasons why that might seem like a good idea, but I urge you to learn from my mistakes.

A gas can with stickers on it.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

All I wanted was to drive an electric car to the solar eclipse. But after the third consecutive charging port RFID reader wouldn’t accept my credit card and finding that the employees inside the attached Spanish hotel restaurant mostly didn’t speak English, I began to feel as though, just maybe, this hadn’t been my best idea.

Opting for an EV as a rental car can be an attractive proposition. For a longtime electric driver like me, it’s the opportunity to avoid car emissions even when on holiday, and to try out the experience in another country. For others, it could be a way to save money while on vacation in countries with even more expensive gasoline than America’s, or perhaps to try out electric driving before taking the plunge on buying an EV back home.

Keep reading...Show less
AM Briefing

Thirst Trap

On steel, uranium, and roof tiles

Lake Powell.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Current conditions: Tropical Storm Moke sideswiped Hawaii yesterday just weeks after a weakened Hurricane Lala became the first major storm to hit the Big Island in decades • On the western fringe of the United States’ Pacific borders, Typhoon Saudel struck Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands over the weekend, bringing heavy rain and flooding • Temperatures in Khorramshahr, on Iran’s border with Iraq, are topping 118 degrees Fahrenheit, rendering the southwestern port city the hottest place on Earth.


THE TOP FIVE

1. Trump administration orders Arizona, California, and Nevada to cut water use

With water levels in reservoirs across the American West at record lows, the Trump administration has directed Arizona, California, and Nevada to cut back on how much water they use from the Colorado River over the next two years. On Friday, the Department of the Interior imposed the reductions via a series of documents detailing a two-year and a 10-year plan to salvage the supplies from the drought-stricken river fed by snowmelt from Colorado’s stretch of the Rocky Mountains. As climate change has shifted snow patterns, levels on the river have dropped. Yet the seven states that depend on the water — the aforementioned three in the Lower Basin, and Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming in the Upper Basin — could not come to agreement among themselves on how to divvy up the dwindling supply. Instead, the Interior Department came up with a proposal that forced the Lower Basin states to pare back first. As you may recall, Arizona’s Democratic governor called the cuts “draconian” when the administration released its proposal in early August. The plan, which imposes short-term cuts while leaving a larger split for later, sets the stage for what E&E News predicted would be “a behemoth legal fight.”

Keep reading...Show less
Red
Adaptation

A Chat With Massachusetts’ First Heat Resilience Officer

The only other U.S. state to have a chief heat officer? Arizona.

A Massachusetts thermostat.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

The past three months will go down in the books as the hottest meteorological summer on record in Boston — but that is not a record that’s likely to stand long. At 3.5 degrees Fahrenheit of warming since 1970, Massachusetts has outpaced the national average by half a degree; by 2050, researchers expect the state will see more than two-dozen 90-plus-degree days every year. According to a 2023 climate report, that could result in as many as 400 excess deaths in the Commonwealth annually.

Now it’s someone’s job to do something about it. In mid-August, Massachusetts Governor Maura Healey announced the appointment of the state’s first heat resilience officer, making the Commonwealth only the second state in the country to have such a position — after the much more obvious choice, Arizona. (Healey is up for reelection this year, but the race is largely expected to be uncompetitive.) The inaugural role has gone to Katie Schlick, who most recently headed the resilience portfolio at the U.S. Climate Alliance and previously served as a special assistant to Ali Zaidi, the White House’s national climate advisor under Joe Biden.

Keep reading...Show less