Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Daily Briefing

How Different Is Anyone’s Data Center Plan, Really?

There‘s a striking amount of agreement across the political system about what the big issues are.

•
Trump, Hochul, and Abbott.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

This is an edition of Heatmap Daily, an evening review of the day’s news written by our executive editor. Sign up for it here.

The country's fastest-growing market for data centers is, for now, frozen. Governor Greg Abbott of Texas announced on Monday that the state’s grid authority should not allow any more data centers to hook up until state regulatory agencies complete an audit of existing projects.

As part of this audit, data center developers will have to disclose the following, according to the governor:

  • any tax incentives they benefit from,
  • their water and energy use,
  • their physical footprint on the land,
  • their plans for future energy use, and
  • their ownership structure.

“Any data center project that fails to comply” with the audit “must be denied,” Abbott wrote in a letter to the agencies.

Abbott's freeze isn't quite broad enough to be called a full-on moratorium. As The Texas Tribune noted, data centers that aren’t asking to connect to Texas’ power grid can proceed as planned. But the announcement does mean New York is no longer the only state where the governor is trying to slow down data center development. As my colleague Alexander Kaufman wrote today in Heatmap AM, Texas’s governor has more than a little in common with New York’s chief executive, Kathy Hochul — above all, they’re both running for re-election in November.

Now, as far as data center regulation goes, Abbott's disclosure requirements are pretty weak tea. That’s chiefly because they are, well, disclosure requirements — they don't require that any developer actually changes their behavior, just that they publish data saying what they were going to do in the first place.

Yet his announcement put me in mind of something I've been thinking about for a while: There might be more agreement about data center regulation than we think.

Take Michigan, for instance. The progressive Senate candidate in that state, Abdul El-Sayed (who could very likely win the Democratic primary tonight), has become prominent partly by speaking out about data centers. He was early to the topic, publishing mandatory “terms of engagement” for data center developers back in January, and his own rise has tracked the issue’s rising salience in American politics.

Some of El-Sayed’s recent remarks about data centers have an undertone of surprise, as if he is a little astounded by how prominent the issue has become. “There’s literally not a conversation that I have, not a stop that I make, where data centers and AI don’t come up,” he said last month. As he recently marveled on a campaign stop last week: “People really effing hate data centers.”

He hasn't called for a national data center moratorium, though, as his allies and endorsers Senator Bernie Sanders or Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez have. Instead, his blessedly short document says Michiganders should have a few “rights” when a data center wants to build in their community:

  • “No rate hikes,” meaning data centers have to pay for their own energy demand and not pass costs onto ratepayers.
  • Data centers should adopt “binding,” “enforceable” and “transparent” community benefits agreements, which can include a developer paying for new water or electricity infrastructure, burying power lines, or making other upgrades.
  • Communities must have a “meaningful say” in permit approvals, too.
  • Blackouts can’t get worse because of a new data center, and utilities should face “enforceable commitments” to invest in reliability projects “funded by data center revenues.”
  • Companies can’t use data centers to “weaken or sidestep clean energy laws.”
  • Data centers have to create the jobs they promise and must hire Michigan contractors with state-registered apprenticeship programs.
  • Data centers have to use closed-loop water systems.

He’s also called for an end to tax breaks for data centers.

El-Sayed is on the Democratic Party's left. Earlier today, a candidate seen as in the party’s center — Iowa gubernatorial candidate Rob Sand — released his own data center plan. It demands the following, at somewhat greater length:

  • Data centers should cover 100% of their own costs “so that Iowans’ bills don’t go up one cent.”
  • Towns or counties should have “open public hearings” on data center permit approvals, end the use of nondisclosure agreements, and make sure communities have “local control of the ultimate decision” to build a project.
  • The state should adopt new mandatory transparency rules requiring data centers to report their water and energy use, their building size and acreage, and other statistics.
  • Data centers should be built by "Iowa union workers” and “make investments in local workforce development.”
  • The state should end sales tax incentives for data centers.

Look — it’s pretty similar to El-Sayed’s list! Sand might be a moderate, and El-Sayed might be a progressive, but it’s hard to see too much daylight between their data center policies.

What’s notable about these policies is what’s not in them. Neither El-Sayed nor Sand would require that data centers be powered by clean energy, as, say, the Wisconsin DSA gubernatorial candidate Francesca Hong has proposed. Neither El-Sayed nor Sand moots a statewide moratorium on data centers, either. And while their proposals would have more teeth, in theory, than Abbott’s audit, the three proposals are interested in the same questions — energy use, water use, physical footprint, and tax incentives.

As we’ve frequently noted at Heatmap, the data center backlash is strikingly bipartisan. Americans of many backgrounds, belief systems, and byways of life agree that the data center boom is becoming a problem. I wonder if there’s more agreement about the solution, too, than we might think.

Blue

You’re out of free articles.

Subscribe to access Heatmap's exclusive climate and energy polling, award-winning journalism, and subscriber-only events. Save $57 on an annual subscription, just $156 $99/year.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Politics

How Social Media Became a Permitting Reform Battleground

Influencers are getting paid thousands of dollars to post about one of the wonkiest policy debates in Washington.

Instagram money.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

If you occupy the same corner of the internet as I do (hello over there), you may have noticed a lot of posts about the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act — not just from Hill-watchers and energy wonks, but by creators and influencers on Instagram.

“I’ve watched the same anti-BAAJA video at least 16 times,” Kaitlyn Hennessy, a creator who tracks influence campaigns, posted on Instagram on Wednesday, referring to a wave of substantially similar videos attacking the bill. These videos typically include a detailed critical description of one or several of the bill’s provisions followed by a “call to action,” such as contacting a congressional representative.

Keep reading...Show less
AM Briefing

Lake Need

On Fermi’s lifeline, Turkish CANDUs, and China’s electric plane

A dry Lake Mead.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Current conditions: The Pacific’s highly active hurricane season just came to an end with a record 25 named storms and 11 major hurricanes • Following a wet, wintry weekend, the U.S. Northeast is poised for a dry, sunny rest of the week • Hong Kong is under a severe fire warning.


THE TOP FIVE

1. Hydropower is drying up in the American West

Evaporating. Chart: EIA Evaporating. Chart: EIA

Keep reading...Show less
Blue
Climate Tech

Bedrock Energy Raises $24 Million to Mainstream Small-Scale Geothermal

The startup’s technology drills deeper, cheaper wells for ground source geothermal temperature control.

Bedrock technology and money.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images, Bedrock Energy

Geothermal energy has been one of the clearest bipartisan winners of the second Trump administration’s energy policy. But the attention has largely centered on companies like Fervo Energy and Sage Geosystems, which aim to generate electricity from hot rocks often miles beneath the surface. Now, a less-heralded corner of the geothermal industry is attracting notice: ground source heat pumps, which use the stable underground temperature of the Earth to heat and cool buildings.

Texas-based startup Bedrock Energy is trying to modernize geothermal HVAC, a technology that dates back to the 1940s but still only serves about 1% of single-family homes and roughly 0.3% to 0.5% of large commercial buildings. High upfront drilling costs and space constraints have hampered adoption, as conventional systems typically require dozens or even hundreds of shallow wells spread across a sizable footprint. Bedrock just raised $24 million to scale a different approach, using AI and an array of sensors to drill fewer, deeper, and cheaper wells more quickly than ever before.

Keep reading...Show less
Green