The Fight

Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Hotspots

Far-Right Wind Foes Call It Quits Against Coastal Virginia

And more of the week’s top news around project fights.

The United States.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

1. Virginia Beach, Virginia – The right-wing interest group lawsuit against Dominion Energy’s Coastal Virginia offshore wind is now dead, concluding one of the wackier tales of the Trump 2.0 energy era.

  • In case you may have forgotten, conservative activists – including climate denial organization the Heartland Institute – sued the federal government in 2024 to strike down the permits for the Virginia offshore wind project arguing that it didn’t take into account impacts on North Atlantic right whales. The lawsuit played into misinformed public fears that offshore wind was killing lots of endangered whales.
  • After Trump re-entered office last year, there were glimmers this lawsuit would become a sue-and-settle case. But the feds ultimately let that idea go amidst heavy lobbying. In May, the presiding judge ruled against the conservatives and last week their lawyers dismissed the appeal.
  • This outcome removes one of the more ridiculous hypotheticals possible here – that Trump would forcibly deconstruct Coastal Virginia. The project is nearing completion and began delivering power to the coastline in March. I’d consider this one as good as done.

2. Box Elder County, Utah – Call it the Box Elder County massacre.

  • On Tuesday, voters in Kevin O’Leary’s data center development jurisdiction soundly rejected incumbent candidates in an election result that ousted two sitting commissioners who voted for the Shark Tank judge’s controversial hyperscale proposal. They also ousted the county sheriff.
  • Elsewhere in the state Utahns took out state Senate President Stuart Adams, which local political pundits attributed to his role chairing the state entity involved in the O’Leary project known as Stratos.
  • It’s unclear how these election results will impact the Stratos project. At the same time, voters usually remember if a clear statement like this is ignored. Box Elder County only two weeks ago issued a 180-day moratorium, but that didn’t impact Stratos.
  • As an aside: on Thursday, O’Leary posted to social media recanting a claim he’d made for months about Chinese entities funding Utah-based opponents of his project, stating he has “no evidence” any of the people or groups he’d previously named “are funded by China or the Chinese Communist Party.” Maybe somebody was afraid of a defamation threat? Who’s to say.

3. Davidson County, Tennessee – We have the latest updates in the Nashville Zoo data center drama and they’re a doozy and a half.

  • Nashville mayor Freddie O’Connell claimed Thursday that developer DC Blox failed to meet with the owner of the Nashville Zoo despite instructions to do so before advancing their project next to the site. This led the zoo to learn about the project from media reporting – talk about a community engagement failure!
  • The Nashville city council, which is quickly becoming quite hostile to the data center will meet after the July 4th holiday to consider whether to enact a comprehensive zoning measure and a temporary moratorium on data center development. Nashville’s metro council sent both proposals to the city council earlier this week. A moratorium would block the DC Blox project. Company leaders claim they’ll move forward as planned because they do have permits.
  • Conversations with nearby landowners are crucial for community engagement.

4. Clark County, Ohio – Yet another utility-scale solar farm is in the Ohio state permitting graveyard.

  • The Ohio Power Siting Board rejected Invenergy’s Sloopy Solar project, pointing to “unanimous” opposition from municipal and county officials at and surrounding the project site. I predicted this would happen back in January. This would’ve been the county’s first utility-scale solar project.
  • The board also gave permission for Hillclimber Solar to withdraw its proposal to build a contested solar farm in Knox County, where anti-solar sentiments run so hot they determine who runs the county commission. So that makes two more down.
Yellow

This article is exclusively
for Heatmap Plus subscribers.

Go deeper inside the politics, projects, and personalities
shaping the energy transition.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Q&A

What Solar Developers Can Teach Data Centers About Making Friends at the Local Level

A conversation with Hanson Wood of RWE

Hanson Wood.
Heatmap Illustration

This week’s conversation is with Hanson Wood, chief development officer for solar developer RWE. Wood’s perspective felt crucial at a moment when the data center boom is leading to so much deal volume – even after the repeal of the Inflation Reduction Act. So I reached out to his team to see if we could talk about how he’s evaluating all things Fight-related, including the impacts of the data center backlash on solar itself. The following conversation was lightly edited for clarity.

How is solar finding opportunities in the data center development space? I know there’s conversations about speed-to-power and some deal volume, but help us get a better sense of the level of capacity being sought versus fossil or other forms of energy.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow
Spotlight

Wind Industry Goes for Broke Against Trump

Senior executives at EDP, Apex, Pattern, and other large renewables companies did something remarkable in a recent court filing: They publicly criticized the administration.

Donald Trump and a wind turbine.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Major energy developers are going all in against the Trump administration in court, in what appears to be the first time many are publicly challenging the president in spite of any potential risk of retaliation.

As I chronicled, Trump is now effectively blocking any new wind projects in the U.S., utilizing federal authority over American aerospace to stop what was once a run-of-the-mill approval process for the height of turbines through the Federal Aviation Administration. They’ve done this by using the Defense Department to gum up the interagency review process, with the Pentagon holding up bureaucratic machinations citing vague, alleged national security concerns. Earlier this month, regional renewable energy trade groups filed a lawsuit against the Pentagon and FAA seeking a judicial order akin to what they’ve already won against the Interior Department’s anti-renewables permitting freeze. The case argues Trump can’t hold these routine processes up because, well, they’re mandated by law to ultimately clear things if they meet basic specifications. It arrives as the Trump administration appeals a separate lawsuit against the Interior Department’s de facto permitting freeze, which was formally filed today.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow
Hotspots

The Renewables Battle Underway in Arizona

And more of the week’s top fights around development.

The United States.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

1. Apache County, Arizona – Renewables developers are trying to head off restrictions in a coveted region of the sun-swept Arizona desert.

  • I’ve detailed how this county is a crucial battleground in the fight over local restrictions on renewable energy. So profound the conflict has been over renewables in Apache County that it helped spur a failed campaign to enact a statewide pause on wind development.
  • Well, the next engagement is underway: On June 3, the Apache County Planning and Zoning Commission recommended a temporary moratorium on future solar and wind development, responding to resident-run campaigns against specific projects.
  • I’ve noticed large advocacy non-profits have begun running hyperlocal letter campaigns to the Apache County Board of Supervisors asking pro-renewables voices to weigh in against the moratorium. Arizonans for a Clean Economy is running a sponsored ad on Google, resulting in a letter campaign popping up if you search renewable energy and the name of the state. “Send a letter today and ask your Supervisor to support policies that unleash Arizona’s energy potential while keeping costs low, conserving our water, and creating energy independence for Apache County,” their letter-writing website states.
  • Meanwhile, Veterans Power America, a national organization, is asking people to tell the board: “Clean energy projects can bring new revenue and economic opportunity to Apache County for Veterans like us. Don’t shut the door on progress.” (For what it's worth, I learned of this ad from anti-wind activists complaining about it on Facebook.)
  • What happens now is a procedural waiting game. The county will now go through a public notice and comment process ahead of formal consideration of the planning and zoning commission’s recommendations. While a decision isn’t imminent, I will be watching this one like the area’s sharp-shinned hawk.

2. Montgomery County, Alabama – A so-called “AI watchman” has won the GOP nomination for Alabama Public Service Commission, indicating how deeply frustrations run in red states against the nascent infrastructure buildout for artificial intelligence.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow