On Thursday night, the Senate passed the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, a controversial bill that would revise federal environmental and energy laws to enable faster permitting of power lines, power plants, and other infrastructure.
Now the bill heads to the House, where three questions will determine its fate: How many Republicans will show up to vote? What will Hakeem Jeffries do? And if it lands on Trump’s desk, what amendments will come with it?
The current Speaker of the House, Republican Mike Johnson of Louisiana, said earlier this week that he would try to pass BAAJA under suspension, a process that would send it straight to the floor for a vote the week after Thanksgiving. But a successful suspension vote would require a two-thirds majority of however many lawmakers actually show up, and since the midterms, many Republicans who lost their seats have checked out. House leadership canceled several votes this week after too few showed up to hold the party line.
If all House Republicans were present and voted in favor of the bill, it would still need some 71 Democrats to support it — and the amount of Democratic support, as we’ll discuss, is unclear. Johnson is trying to rally his party to show up, but if he can’t get them to come back, the bill would need even higher numbers on the Democrat side.
House Democrats, meanwhile, are split. Some, like Representative Scott Peters of California, argue that while BAAJA isn’t perfect, it’s a good deal that’s “very responsive to what the country needs right now,” as he told me on Thursday. “The transmission provisions are as good as we could ever imagine,” he said. “The notion that you don’t have to give anything up for that is just unrealistic.” Peters is part of the New Democrat Coalition, a group of 114 center-left members, whose leadership tentatively endorsed BAAJA last week.
On the other side, Representative Jared Huffman, also of California, has been pushing colleagues to oppose the deal in hopes of getting a better one with fewer compromises in the next Congress, when Democrats will control both chambers. He argues the bill guts environmental protections and blocks communities from being able to “challenge, change, and sometimes stop huge polluting projects that threaten permanent damage.” Huffman is a member of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, made up of nearly 100 Democrats, which officially opposed the bill.
Most Democrats in the House have remained quiet on the bill. It’s not yet clear whether House Minority Leader Hakeem Jefferies will try to swing them one way or the other. Earlier this month, Jeffries told Politico that BAAJA “falls short,” but that was before the Senate made key changes to the legislation. A few days later, at the Democrats’ What’s Next conference in Denver, he asserted that “we’re committed to getting [permitting reform] done,” although he did not specify whether he meant this year. His office did not respond to a request for comment.
If Johnson decides not to go the suspension route, or if the suspension vote fails, he would have to send the bill to the House Rules Committee, which likely has the numbers to tee it up for a two-step process: House members would need to pass a “rule” for the final vote, then vote on the bill itself. Both votes would require a simple majority. Again, the question will be how many Republicans show up, and whether enough Democrats are willing to jump in to salvage the vote if the numbers are too thin.
The other wrinkle in all of this is that the bill’s authors in the Senate are eager to pass an amendment to the legislation they were unable to bring to a vote last night. That would, among other things, improve the outcome somewhat for tribes, ensuring that all federally funded projects that might affect tribal resources require tribal consultation, not just those that require federal permits. It also increased the annual funding authorization for state and tribal historic preservation offices by $100 million, to $300 million.
Two senators from Oregon, Democrats Jeff Merkley and Ron Wyden, blocked a motion to bring this amendment to a vote after Republicans blocked a separate amendment the two Democrats had introduced to ban data centers on federal land.
Both Republican Senator Shelley Moore Capito and Democratic Senator Sheldon Whitehouse, who worked together on the legislation, have said they still want to get the amendment through. Capito told Punchbowl News that the House could try to pass it separately from the main bill by attaching it to must-pass legislation, such as a government spending bill. Current federal funding expires December 11, so that would give the House just two weeks to pass BAAJA as-is, then pass a spending bill with the amendment tacked-on.
The House could also choose to attach all of BAAJA to a must-pass bill. This wouldn’t be the first time the House pushed major energy policy through on the coattails of a spending package. The Energy Policy Act of 2020, which created a slew of new research and development programs for early-stage clean energy technologies, passed as part of an omnibus spending bill that funded the government and provided COVID-19 relief. That move took months of negotiations between the House and the Senate, however — time that the current Congress does not have. It would also require a sign-off from House minority leadership, which could open it up to even more amendments — something Johnson is unlikely to want to do.
One other possibility is that the House Rules Committee could add the amendment to BAAJA before sending it to the floor. The issue there is that the bill would then have to return to the Senate again for a final vote, and there just aren’t that many days left in the year for all of that back and forth.
In sum, the bill has a strong chance of landing on Trump’s desk before the end of the year, but it’s not yet a done deal.