Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Economy

The Climate Tech Startup Betting Against Greenwashing

Isometric is trying to become the most trusted name in the scandal-plagued carbon market.

•
A $100 bill.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Regulations are probably coming for the scandal-plagued voluntary carbon market. After years of mounting skepticism and reports of greenwashing, governments are now attempting to rein in the historically unchecked web of platforms, registries, protocols, and verification bodies offering ways to offset a company’s emissions that vary tremendously in price and quality. Europe has developed its own rules, the Carbon Removal Certification Framework, while the Biden administration earlier this year announced a less comprehensive set of general principles. Plus, there are already mandatory carbon credit schemes around the world, such as California’s cap-and-trade program and the E.U. Emissions Trading System.

“The idea that a voluntary credit should be a different thing than a compliance credit, obviously doesn’t make sense, right?” Ryan Orbuch, Lowercarbon Capital’s carbon removal lead, told me. “You want it to be as likely as possible that the thing you’re buying today is going to count in a compliance regime.”

That’s where the carbon credit certification platform Isometric comes into play. Founded in 2022, the startup raised $25 million in its seed round last year, co-led by Lowercarbon and Plural, a European venture capital firm. It has created a rigorous, scientifically-driven standard for carbon removal credits, with the intention of becoming the benchmark that buyers, sellers, and other stakeholders can coalesce around. So whenever federal standards or compliance regimes do kick in, there will be no doubt whether Isometric-verified credits are up to snuff.

“Isometric was basically founded to say, look, the long-term solution here is obviously government and regulation, but in the meantime, this is too important to let the market just keep doing it like this,” Lukas May, chief commercial officer at Isometric, told me. He believes that the government’s role in the carbon market should mirror the financial sector, but instead of preventing insider trading or predatory lending, federal regulators would make high-level determinations on things like what types of credits count and how long carbon must be locked away to count as “permanent removal.” Platforms like Isometric (often referred to as registries) could then focus on setting more granular, scientifically specific requirements for particular methods of carbon removal.

The startup aims to separate itself from existing registries, which include Puro.earth, Verra, and the Gold Standard, in two big ways.

First is just a focus on science. May said that 15 of Isometric’s first 25 hires were scientists. Today, the company’s chief scientist is Jennifer Wilcox, who recently left her position on the leadership team at the Office of Fossil Energy and Carbon Management, housed within the U.S. Department of Energy. Other registries, he told me, are “filled with NGO types” and “policy people” who lack the technical background to, say, evaluate what types rock formations are best for the geological sequestration of bio-oil or how CO2 fluxes in the soil impact enhanced rock weathering. These types of in-the-weeds analyses are integral to establishing stringent protocols to validate the amount of carbon that’s actually been removed.

Additionally, May, Orbuch, and Khaled Helioui, a partner at Plural who led the firm’s investment in Isometric, all said the company fixes a key flaw in the voluntary carbon market —- alignment of financial incentives. Traditionally, carbon removal suppliers pay registries to certify their credits, which creates an incentive for registries to overlook lax standards. But Isometric is instead paid a flat fee by the buyers for performing verification work on a per-ton basis.

This year, Isometric verified its first credits ever, from the carbon removal companies Vaulted Deep, which collects sludgy, organic waste and deposits it underground, and Charm Industrial, which injects processed biomass into abandoned oil and gas wells. Credits from these two suppliers were sold to Frontier, the carbon-removal initiative led by the payments firm Stripe. Just last week, Frontier identified Isometric as its first and only leading credit issuer.

“What makes Isometric stand out is they’re explicitly focused on durable CDR [carbon dioxide removal],” Joanna Klitzke, Frontier’s procurement and ecosystem strategy lead, told me. “Durable” refers to the fact that Isometric’s projects must sequester CO2 for 1,000 years or more. “They’re building tech products that make data and reporting particularly easy for suppliers and for credit management,” she added.

Everyone is essentially trying to avoid another scandal like the one that engulfed rainforest carbon offsets, which were found to be largely worthless. The industry has thus been shifting away from more nebulous carbon offsets, which seek to avoid future emissions by preventing deforestation or funding renewables development, and towards more concrete, but often more expensive, forms of carbon removal — think direct air capture, enhanced rock weathering, or biomass carbon removal and storage, all of which have seen a boom in investment.

“As carbon removal was emerging as a new and potentially very exciting way to do this stuff, potentially more measurable and more rigorous, we couldn’t just sit and watch the same registries do the same thing,” May told me, saying doing so would “destroy trust in the carbon removal industry before it’s even off the ground.”

In a past life, Isometric’s founder and CEO, Eamon Jubbawy, founded a digital identity verification company for the financial services industry. This gave investors confidence that he could bring his expertise in trust-building and verification services to the carbon removal space.

“It’s not a like for like, but there’s a lot of overlap in terms of actually introducing efficiency, effectiveness, and having technology really open a market,” Plural’s Helioui told me. “This is not an endeavor or an opportunity where I would have been necessarily that keen to back a first-time founder, just because of the complexity of what you need to manage,” he said. “We’re really talking about market creation.”

But May doesn’t expect Isometric to totally dominate other registries. Just like there are many private banks, May envisions an “ecosystem of high quality registries,” eventually unified around a set of federal guardrails. Until then, he believes Isometric’s role is to “set a bar that is so high that the expectation and norm in the market shifts,” thus avoiding a race to the bottom where companies are able to greenwash their image with cheap, low-quality credits.

Now, not every company can afford the highest quality credits. And because of Isometric’s 1,000-year storage requirement, many cheaper, nature-based projects, such as reforestation, are excluded from its registry, even though there’s still demand for them. Orbuch told me that Isometric will continue adding guidelines for different carbon removal pathways, as it recently did for biochar, a charcoal-like brick that locks up carbon contained within biomass.

It’s still early days, and there’s plenty of room for Isometric to grow alongside the market. After all, it’s only issued 5,350 carbon removal credits to date, while nearly two billion credits have been issued in the voluntary carbon market overall.

“The whole industry needs to be scaling up,” May told me. “So we need to, in 10 years time, be, you know, issuing and verifying hundreds of millions, if not billions, of credits annually.”

Green

You’re out of free articles.

Subscribe to access Heatmap's exclusive climate and energy polling, award-winning journalism, and subscriber-only events. Save $57 on an annual subscription, just $156 $99/year.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Climate Tech

Meta Joins the Clean Materials Race

It’s following Microsoft into deals with Fortera, Sublime, and Stegra.

The Meta logo.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Meta’s climate reputation, to put it mildly, leaves something to be desired. When Heatmap surveyed a group of our sharpest energy insiders late last year about their views on the politics, investments, predictions, and broader sentiment shaping the climate and energy world, we asked which hyperscaler they thought was doing the best on climate. Google and Microsoft emerged as clear frontrunners, while Meta narrowly beat out Amazon in the race to the bottom.

At the time, that seemed well-founded. Google pioneered the concept of 24/7 energy matching, and made early bets on advanced geothermal and small modular reactors. Microsoft built the carbon removal market practically singlehandedly while making deals with low-carbon materials suppliers like steelmaker Stegra and clean cement startup Sublime Systems. Meta, meanwhile, was making headlines for its gigantic new data center campus in Louisiana, which it aims to power with 7.5 gigawatts of new natural gas plants.

Keep reading...Show less
Blue
AM Briefing

Anthropic’s Moment

On Philippine nuclear, Ford’s new battery bet, and congestion pricing

The Anthropic logo.
Samuel Boivin/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Current conditions: Thai authorities placed 14 of the country’s 15 southern provinces on high alert from flooding due to monsoon rains • The Australian town of Weipa, in Far North Queensland, broke a record with 41 consecutive days of temperatures above 96.8 degrees Fahrenheit • A series of storms is set to hammer California over the next week with heavy rain and snow in the Sierra Nevada mountains.


THE TOP FIVE

1. Anthropic makes history as the first AI lab to go public

Anthropic is set to begin trading on the Nasdaq under the ticker ANT later today, becoming the first frontier artificial intelligence lab to become a publicly traded entity. The Claude maker is expected to price its shares somewhere north of $80 — CNBC reported $83, while Bloomberg pegged the number at $85. The initial public offering marks a turning point in the maturation of AI as an industry and offers a clear metric by which the rest of the world will be able to assess the technology’s lofty claims of progress. As a primer, I recommend reading some of my colleagues’ past coverage of the company:

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow
Podcast

What Happens to U.S. Climate Policy After the Midterms?

Rob digests the election results with Heatmap’s Emily Pontecorvo and Alexander C. Kaufman during a live Shift Key taping at Yale.

The Capitol.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

A few weeks ago, some colleagues and I had the chance to go to New Haven, Connecticut, for what’s become an annual live Shift Key taping at the Yale Clean Energy Conference, hosted by the Yale Center for Business and the Environment. This year, we did it three days after the midterm elections.

I was joined in this conversation by Heatmap founding staff writer Emily Pontecorvo and Heatmap’s newest correspondent, Alexander C. Kaufman. Obviously, this was a live show, and we recorded it before a number of things had happened, including the recent revisions to — or maybe even, by the time you read this, the potential passage of — the bipartisan permitting reform bill and potentially, by the time you listen to it, the passage in the Senate. But there are still plenty of questions that remain for the next Congress.

Keep reading...Show less
Blue