The Fight

Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Hotspots

The Solar Farm-to-Data Center Switcheroo Hits a Snag

Plus more of the week’s biggest development fights.

The United States.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

1. Clark County, Nevada – The first data center approved on federal lands has hit a legal brick wall.

  • On Monday, the Townsite 2 solar farm-to-data center environmental review swap I’ve previously covered received a stay from the Interior Department’s board of appeals. David Gunter, a Biden appointee, ruled that the Center for Biological Diversity’s appeal of the permit flip was likely to succeed on the merits because a solar farm … is not a data center. Seems logical!
  • As I covered at the time, the Bureau of Land Management approved the environmental review swap claiming that a solar farm and a data center have essentially the same characteristics. It was a bold claim. Both the agency and Townsite said the characteristics would have substantially the same environmental impacts. Gunter shrugged off the claim idea, however, stating that statute requires projects to be both substantially similar and have equally similar impacts under the National Environmental Policy Act.
  • Crucially, Gunter also noted that the federal agency had never done an environmental review of any data centers under NEPA, so there’s not even a proper frame of reference. “BLM has not studied the Townsite data center project, or indeed any other data center project, in any environmental document,” he wrote.

2. Jackson County, Missouri – We have yet another high-profile case of a city councilor losing their job over voting for a data center, and this one’s a doozy.

  • Voters in the city of Independence, Missouri on Wednesday ousted John Perkins, a city councilor, in a recall election focused on his vote to back tax breaks for a large Nebius data center. The vote was quite resounding, with almost 70% backing the recall. Two other city councilors who voted for the tax abatement were voted out in a separate election earlier this April.
  • The data center is still getting built. But this is clear backlash to those who voted for it. This is a great example of public backlash to restarting a gas and coal plant to power a data center, which was the plan for the Nebius facility. Reportedly it will operate at up to nine times the previous capacity of the plant. I cannot imagine how that must make some nearby residents feel.

3. Utah – What’s it take for the Bureau of Land Management to approve a big transmission line for zero-emission energy generation these days? Geothermal, baby.

  • This week BLM proposed a more than 300-mile transmission project connecting Millard County, Utah to Clark County, Nevada, where Las Vegas is located. The project would be built by a Pattern Energy subsidiary and connect to geothermal leasing areas in both states. According to the FAST-41 dashboard, the NEPA review process for the line will be approved before the end of Trump’s term.
  • All the while, we have seen little progress for transmission lines that would connect to solar energy. The last time BLM approved anything noteworthy for solar-related transmission was last March. Part of me wonders whether the renewables permitting freeze I reported would have the potential to hurt transmission truly has manifested itself, in spite of public rumors to the contrary.

4. Huntsville, Alabama – You can’t even build a tiny battery storage facility in the middle of Alabama anymore.

  • Residents in the city of Huntsville on Wednesday successfully got the city utility to relocate a 2-megawatt project in a suburban neighborhood. Fire fears, as always, were to blame.
  • Utility-scale battery storage is new to Alabama, in part because of a considerable investment from the Tennessee Valley Authority and Department of Energy. This is the first battery storage conflict I’ve ever seen in Alabama — we haven’t recorded any previous BESS battles there in Heatmap Pro.
  • This should not be a surprise, though. Alabama is fast transforming from chill vibes to full-on freakout over data centers and solar farms, so it only stands to reason that we’d see the BESS backlash manifest too.
Yellow

This article is exclusively
for Heatmap Plus subscribers.

Go deeper inside the politics, projects, and personalities
shaping the energy transition.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Q&A

How Building Transmission Could Lower Electricity Costs

Talking with National Grid’s Matthew Satterwhite about his new report with S&P Global.

The Q&A subject.
Heatmap Illustration

This week’s conversation is with Matthew Satterwhite, head of U.S. policy for National Grid. This week National Grid released a report in collaboration with S&P Global I found noteworthy amidst the data center backlash, asserting that building new transmission lines can potentially reduce consumer costs. I reached out asking if we could chat about how this argument leans into the fight over hyperscale infrastructure. I found our conversation illuminating and educational.

The following Q&A was lightly edited for clarity.

Keep reading... Show less
Yellow
Spotlight

These 5 States Are Primed for a Data Center Pause

Where temporary moratoria could happen next.

A data center protest.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Brace yourself for more statewide data center moratoria.

So far there are only two full state-wide blocks on data center permits, in New York and Texas. At least fifteen states have moratorium legislation in the pipeline, but few if any of those bills stand a chance of becoming law in the short term. Here are five states, however, where a broad development pause may gain momentum in the next year or two — and all of them are crucial to watch this November.

Keep reading... Show less
Yellow
Hotspots

People Who Hate Renewables Hate Data Centers, Too

And more thoughts on the week’s most notable fights around project development.

The United States.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

1. Pinal County, Arizona – If you can’t build a solar or a wind farm somewhere, it’s really hard to get a data center built there too.

  • That’s the lesson readers should take away from the situation in Pinal County, where historically speaking at least 5 solar projects have been withdrawn over the years after facing local opposition, according to Heatmap Pro data. You should expect some data centers to potentially wind up in the same graveyard.
  • On Wednesday, the Pinal County Board of Supervisors rejected the La Osa Energy Center, a large proposed data center and gas-fired power complex. The board in this deep red rural desert community is rock-ribbed Republican. Only one supervisor on the board dissented, citing private property rights concerns.
  • The county currently has a restrictive ordinance against data center development unless they are in industrial areas, but has not yet approved a project since the ordinance was crafted, making this now a de facto no-go zone for developers. This went against the requests of the county zoning board, which recommended making the project site as industrial. If that pattern sounds familiar to you, that’s because you recognize it from the many cases we’ve seen in solar and wind development where political officials similarly override zoning staff.

2. St. Joseph County, Indiana – Thousands of miles away from Arizona, a similar division is dominating the fight over whether to enact a 2-year moratorium on data centers in the county home of South Bend.

Keep reading... Show less
Yellow