You’re out of free articles.
This Halloween, get 20% off using code ADVANCED
Log in
To continue reading, log in to your account.
Create a Free Account
To unlock more free articles, please create a free account.
Sign In or Create an Account.
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Welcome to Heatmap
Thank you for registering with Heatmap. Climate change is one of the greatest challenges of our lives, a force reshaping our economy, our politics, and our culture. We hope to be your trusted, friendly, and insightful guide to that transformation. Please enjoy your free articles. You can check your profile here .
subscribe to get Unlimited access
Offer for a Heatmap News Unlimited Access subscription; please note that your subscription will renew automatically unless you cancel prior to renewal. Cancellation takes effect at the end of your current billing period. We will let you know in advance of any price changes. Taxes may apply. Offer terms are subject to change.
Subscribe to get unlimited Access
Hey, you are out of free articles but you are only a few clicks away from full access. Subscribe below and take advantage of our introductory offer.
subscribe to get Unlimited access
Offer for a Heatmap News Unlimited Access subscription; please note that your subscription will renew automatically unless you cancel prior to renewal. Cancellation takes effect at the end of your current billing period. We will let you know in advance of any price changes. Taxes may apply. Offer terms are subject to change.
Create Your Account
Please Enter Your Password
Forgot your password?
Please enter the email address you use for your account so we can send you a link to reset your password:
Heatmap’s inaugural survey finds broad support for climate action.

Americans are increasingly feeling the effects of climate change and overwhelmingly believe the United States needs to do more to address the issue, the inaugural Heatmap Climate Poll found.
Conducted in late February by Benenson Strategy Group, the poll arrives during a moment of heightened media attention to climate change. Earlier this week, the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) released its synthesis report, which emphasizes the dangers posed by global warming as well as the need for governments to act swiftly and decisively. In the U.S., the implementation of President Biden's landmark climate law, the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act, is well underway.
Overall, nearly three-quarters of all Americans say it is important for the United States to mitigate the effects of climate change, including 89% of Democrats and 61% of Republicans.
A plurality of Americans (47%) said they are feeling increasingly pessimistic about climate change, versus 28% who said they were increasingly optimistic and 24% who said it had no effect on them.
Half of Americans also attest to having been personally impacted by climate change, with 35% saying an immediate family member has experienced a serious climate-related event like a hurricane, tornado, blizzard, or flash flood that resulted in either personal harm or property damage.
“In more than two decades of polling Americans’ attitudes on a wide range of issues, including climate change, I have rarely seen such unequivocal support for action now by the U.S. government, to lead on mitigating the harmful effects of climate change on our planet,” says Joel Benenson, founder and CEO of Benenson Strategy Group. “Our survey shows that Americans want their politicians to do more, but fear they lack the will that is so urgently needed as people here at home and all over the world are increasingly impacted by extreme climate events.”
Indeed, Americans seem to have given up on government’s ability to make a difference. A plurality believes that individuals will have a greater positive effect on climate change in the near future than companies or the federal government.
Americans want corporations to do more but are skeptical of their motivations. Sixty-seven percent feel it is important for large corporations to mitigate the effects of climate change, but almost as many (64%) think their pledges to do so are just for appearances. Many also identify the sway that big corporations, lobbyists, and special interest groups have in Washington to be among the most significant obstacles to achieving renewable and sustainable solutions.
Americans were also largely in the dark about the details of the Inflation Reduction Act. Sixty-three percent reported knowing not much or nothing about the bill.
Americans reported varying degrees of interest in sustainability. Eighty percent acknowledged that sustainable consumer choices often involve some level of personal sacrifice; a surprisingly significant 27% of Americans either eat no meat (10%) or would like to stop eating meat in the future (17%). Almost half of Americans say they want to one day power their homes with solar panels (46%).
Interest in electric vehicles was also high. Nearly half of the respondents either currently drive an electric vehicle (8%) or would like to do so in the future (39%). Despite high levels of general interest, though, close to one in two Americans (45%) were unaware that the Inflation Reduction Act includes a provision to give up to $7,500 in consumer credit for the purchase of qualified vehicles.
The debate over how to proceed with Russia is dividing Americans. About half (52%) believe sanctions should remain in place as an effective way of punishing Moscow and limiting its ability to wage war in Ukraine, even if it means families ultimately pay more for energy in the U.S. The remaining respondents (48%) said sanctions should be lifted to reduce energy costs for American families. Separately, a plurality of respondents described the rising cost of living for families year after year as “an extremely serious problem" for climate change mitigation.
In the coming days and weeks, Heatmap will offer further analysis of the survey's results, including closer looks at the challenges of decarbonization, interest in electric vehicles, the hopes for individual action, and the toll of climate change on mental health.
The Heatmap Climate Poll of 1,000 American adults was conducted by Benenson Strategy Group via online panels from Feb. 15 to 20, 2023. The survey included interviews with Americans in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. The margin of sampling error is plus or minus 3.02 percentage points. You can download the topline results below:
This Halloween, get 20% off using code ADVANCED
Log in
To continue reading, log in to your account.
Create a Free Account
To unlock more free articles, please create a free account.
Rob welcomes back Julian Brave NoiseCat to talk about the National Historic Preservation Act and why it’s so central to these negotiations.
One big sticking point that’s emerged in negotiations over the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act are the changes it would make to the National Historic Preservation Act. The bill would rewrite Section 106 of that law, which requires the federal government to consult with tribal nations before it permits a major project on or adjacent to land of Native cultural value. Crucially, the protections in Section 106 of the NHPA don’t end at the borders of a reservation. They extend to public and private property, as well.
The initial version of the legislation would have shrunk the scope and shortened the deadlines of reviews under the NHPA, and imposed punitive new rules on the officials in charge of overseeing those processes. It would have also allowed the federal government to step in and take over a local official’s office if officials thought they weren’t moving quickly enough. A subsequent amendment would soften many of those revisions, but not all of them.
Tribes have emerged as one of the most important players in the permitting bill negotiations. Joining us today to talk about these dynamics is Julian Brave NoiseCat. He’s the author of the excellent memoir, We Survived the Night, and a director of the Oscar-nominated documentary, Sugarcane. He has worked at the climate activist group 350.org, the progressive polling firm Data for Progress, and helped lead the effort to get Deb Haaland appointed and confirmed as the first Native American Secretary of the Interior. He’s also an enrolled member of the Canim Lake Band Tsqʼéscen̓ of the Secwépemc nation up in British Columbia. We talk about the changes the bill would make to the NHPA, how the tribes have handled those changes, and what could come next for both tribal and environmental politics.
Shift Key is hosted by Robinson Meyer, the founding executive editor of Heatmap News.
Subscribe to “Shift Key” and find this episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can also add the show’s RSS feed to your podcast app to follow us directly.
Here is an excerpt from their conversation:
Robinson Meyer: I think what’s interesting is that then when the bill came out, it was way more punitive than I think people had anticipated. And there was some sense that NHPA might be involved in a permanent reform, but it was way more punitive, I think, especially to the [Tribal Historic Preservation Offices], the THPOs, than had been necessarily anticipated. It said they could be defunded, as you said. It basically said if they didn’t make decisions in time, then their leadership couldn’t leave the 25-mile radius of the office.
Julian Brave NoiseCat: Oh, I didn’t catch that part. That’s crazy. Yeah, I think there’s a couple things to bring up here. The first is that this is a live debate beyond, as we’ve kind of been getting at, just the permitting reform bill. So we should also say that this bill is happening in the context of, over the summer, the ACHP — the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, the agency created by NHPA — had actually voted on new rules about how it was going to implement the Section 106 process, which was going to impact tribes. My understanding is that they were going to fold in tribal consultation into one sort of big kind of process.
So this is a moving area of policy, both within the context of the permitting reform debate and beyond the context of this legislation. And I suspect that no matter what happens with this bill, it will remain that way for future administrations, for future Congresses. This is just going to continue to be an issue because of course, the tribal nation-to-nation relationship with the federal government is one that is just continuous. And tribes are always going to want to have a greater say over what happens in their historic home.
Meyer: When the agency made that change, was it popular? With tribes?
NoiseCat: No. No. No, they opposed it. The reality for tribes right now is that they are ... it’s a kind of complicated situation, in a certain way. On the one hand, tribes have never been more powerful from a certain vantage point. In the big picture, you have the first Native American woman governor elected to New Mexico. You have two Native women who have been elected to the Senate. Tribes operate gaming operations across the country that generate like $45 billion in revenue or something like that. They’re almost half of all brick and mortar gaming operations in the country. And tribal concerns, because they tend to exist in a geography that is actually more rural and more conservative, are actually kind of pretty close to the bellwether of American politics. There are politicians who Democrats would be shocked to learn are actually generally pretty good on tribal concerns, like Senator Lisa Murkowski.
There are others, however, who come from those types of jurisdictions who take a slightly different approach, where they tend to take on the tribes in their jurisdictions a little bit more. So a big part of the dynamic I would say around this bill is that Senator Mike Lee is a Republican from Utah, and there is a distinct Utah Republican tradition of taking on tribal sovereignty that goes all the way back to — and here real ball knowers are going to know what I’m talking about. But there was an era of federal Indian policy called termination in the 1950s that extended into the 1960s, wherein the stated goal of the federal government to Native nations was to terminate them legally. And it was spearheaded by a Utah Republican named Arthur V. Watkins. And if you have been paying attention to Mike Lee’s statements over the years, going all the way back to like Bears Ears, all the way back to Deb Haaland’s confirmation, he has always had a little bit more of an oppositional approach to tribal interests.
You can find a full transcript of the episode here.
Mentioned:
Previously on Shift Key: How Julian Brave NoiseCat Changed His Mind About Climate Politics
What was in the original bill
The Last-Minute Changes to the Senate Permitting Deal, Explained
More on the cultural politics of the permitting bill
This episode of Shift Key is sponsored by ...
Formed through a joint venture between Wärtsilä and RCT Solutions, Valo helps utilities, independent power producers, and developers navigate market and grid complexity without sacrificing system performance. Learn more at valoenergy.com.
Every year Giving Green researches the top climate nonprofits and sends 100% of every dollar donated to its Giving Green Fund straight to them. Make your first gift before the new year, and it will be matched up to $1,000. Go to GivingGreen.earth/Shift.
Music for Shift Key is by Adam Kromelow.
This transcript has been automatically generated.
Subscribe to “Shift Key” and find this episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can also add the show’s RSS feed to your podcast app to follow us directly.
Robinson Meyer:
Hello, it’s Tuesday, November 17, and the Senate is expected to debate and potentially take substantive votes this week on the Bipartisan Permitting Bill, or the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. One big sticking point that’s emerged in negotiations and the initial procedural votes over the bill are the changes that it would make to the National Historic Preservation Act, or the NHPA. The bill would change Section 106 of that law, which requires the federal government to consult with tribal nations before it approves a major project or permits a major project, on land that’s near or adjacent to or directly of cultural value to that tribe. Crucially, Section 106’s protections, as you’ll hear, don’t just touch land on reservations. That is actually fully under the control of the tribal government. They touch public property as well as private property where there’s a project passing through with some kind of federal nexus.
Robinson Meyer:
The initial version of the permitting bill would have shrank the scope and deadline of those NHPA reviews, and it would have imposed punitive new rules on the officials in charge of overseeing those processes. It would have also allowed the federal government to step in and take over a local official’s office if they thought they weren’t moving fast enough on a project. Recently, a new amendment of the bill has come out and it softens many of those revisions. It doesn’t allow for a federal takeover in the same way. But other changes have stayed and senators and politicians will now need to balance between the changes that tribal interests still want to see to the bill and those that environmentalists want to see. More broadly, tribes have emerged as one of the most important power players on this bill and they’ve shown far more ability to change it so far than some environmental litigants have.
I’ve wanted to talk about the changes that the bill would make to NHPA for some time, and I’ve been looking for the right guest, and then finally it hit me. Joining us today to talk about those changes is Julian Brave NoiseCat. As you’ll remember as we’ve had him on the show before, he’s the author of the excellent memoir, We Survived the Night, but he’s also the director of the Oscar-nominated documentary, Sugarcane. He’s also an enrolled member of the Canim Lake Band Tsqʼéscen̓ of the Secwépemc nation up in British Columbia, and as you might remember from his last appearance on the show, he is a veteran of progressive policy and politics. He used to work at the climate activism group 350.org. After that, he went to Data for Progress, the progressive polling firm. He helped lead the effort to get Deb Haaland appointed and confirmed as the first Native American Secretary of the Interior. And he’s just broadly been an observer of both Washington politics, climate politics, and kind of progressive politics and policy for a long time. He also is an old friend from when we both lived in D.C. On this show, we talk about the changes that the bill would make to NHPA, kind of how the tribes have handled those changes, and what could come next for both tribal and environmental politics. It’s a fun discussion. It helped me think through this bill really well. I’m Robinson Meyer, the founding executive editor of Heatmap News, and it’s all coming up on Shift Key. Julian Brave NoiseCat, welcome back to Shift Key.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Great to be back with you, Rob.
Robinson Meyer:
One of the biggest sticking points in the bipartisan permitting bill, and something that I think a lot of people, myself included, who were kind of prepared to cover this bill, were maybe not as prepared to cover as part of this story, is that the initial draft of the bipartisan permitting bill, Asia or bay-jah or bah-hah, whatever you call it, really reformed a number of different processes that the federal government is supposed to use to consult with tribal governments, which previously has been a very big deal for Western environmental projects in the U.S., has exploded into being or taken on a new prominence, I think, during this policy fight. And has really, I think, become the biggest sticking point or the most salient issue or political issue in the politics of this bill. As much as the focus has been on data centers or as much as the focus has been on will this bill expand or help fossil fuels, the actual political fights have been about, and the actual political stakes have been about the tribal content in this bill. And so Julian, you’ve been posting about it online. You kind of come from an interesting background.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
As one does.
Robinson Meyer:
Exactly. As one does, as we all do now. You have this interesting background of having worked in progressive policy development. And so I was hoping that we could just start this conversation.
Robinson Meyer:
Can you just put in context, like, what is the full scope of processes or consults that are supposed to be happening between the federal government and tribes in the U.S. right now.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Let’s start from the biggest picture. There are 575 federally recognized tribes across the United States. That means tribes that are recognized as sovereign entities by the federal government. There are more if you include state recognized tribes, but that’s a whole other conversation. And they have a nation-to-nation, government-to-government relationship with the federal government. And if you’re confused by me describing tribes as sovereign, well, just think about for a moment, tribes went to war in some instances with the federal government. In many instances, they signed treaties with the United States. It doesn’t really get more sovereign than that. On top of that, you have this idea that is kind of central to federal Indian law that the federal government has a trust responsibility towards those tribes, which basically means that the federal government has a responsibility in the way that you might to like, I’m going to kind of use colorful language here to make the point that you might to like an orphan that you’ve adopted to like do your best to make sure that bad things don’t happen to the adoptee. And the federal government does have a sort of legal responsibility to have that kind of a relationship to the 575 federally recognized tribes
Robinson Meyer:
Is that like a case law thing is that like under court decisions or is that like there are laws passed by.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Congress that goes all the way back to Cherokee Nation v. Georgia — Oh, sorry, Cherokee Nation … yeah, I think it’s Cherokee Nation v. Georgia. It’s a 1831 case under the Marshall court. Basically a lot of federal indian law stretches back to to a couple of cases back then there’s another one called Worcester v. Georgia. There’s another one called Johnson v. McIntosh that’s not of the same sort of marshall trilogy I believe it’s called you’re testing my limits of federal indian law knowledge now but basically the important things to remember here are that it’s a nation-to-nation government-to-government relationship between tribes and federal government and that the federal government has a responsibility to try to like mitigate harm
Robinson Meyer:
Under that nation-to-nation relationship there’s a number of different conversations, or consultations that are supposed to be happening between the federal government and tribal nations, sovereign tribal nations. One of them is this consultation under the National Historic Preservation Act, which is at the heart of the politics of this bill. But it’s not the only one. And so as we just continue to zoom in, can you give us a sense of what tribes in the United States are supposed to be talking about on a regular basis? And like, do they actually do it?
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
I mean, it’s important to say that tribes did not, to the extent that we know this, did not love the status quo. That rings true with my own sort of, I don’t know, interpersonal anecdotal evidence. There was also a government accountability office survey in 2020 of about 100 tribal historic preservation offices where 60 something percent of them said that they did not like the consultation process as it existed. And so it’s safe to say that just like most people are not super happy with the status quo in this country, tribes are not super happy with the status quo vis-a-vis tribal consultation. It is an essential part of the government-to-government relationship, and it is much bigger, we should also be very clear, than what is being debated in BAAJA. Just to give people a sense of the rest of the universe. There’s an executive order that dates back to the year 2000 that has some numbers that Indian law experts would remember. I don’t remember them, but basically it says that you are supposed to, if you’re an agency, consult with tribes on any sort of decision that might impact tribes. There’s also NEPA, which has tribal components, and then there’s NAGPRA, the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act, which also engages in tribal consultation.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
The part of this bill that is sort of, as you said, kind of central to the negotiations
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Has to do with the National Historic Preservation Act and specifically Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, which
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Involves how the ACHP, the Advisory Council on Historic Places, an agency created by the NHPA, is supposed to consult with tribes on the impacts of developments to cultural sites that tribes care about that are off their reservation.
Robinson Meyer:
How does this process like normally work right now to the extent that this is something you can describe?
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Yeah. So here again, like you’d be better off getting the exact details of this from an Indian law attorney. My understanding is basically that the process is instigated by the ACHP.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
They are supposed to, within a certain amount of time, notify tribes about a review being conducted and to kind of consult with them about whether the development is going to impact any cultural sites that the tribe might know of that the ACHP has not maybe covered in its own review. It’s worth saying that I did a little quick search on the numbers about all this last night. There’s like 100 to 120,000 of these that are instigated every year. Only about 2,000 of them end up in sort of a more detailed back and forth between tribes and the ACHP. And then it’s an incredibly small number that end up becoming major controversies where like a tribe really doesn’t want a project to go forward. And the federal government and the developer may have a different opinion. The thing is, is that those instances, of course, end up in the news. So one of them was actually a story that I actually was covering. It’s been going on so long that I started covering it when I was a cub reporter at the HuffPost. This is the Oak Flat controversy, resolution copper mine that has been proposed to be built adjacent to or under, depending on how you
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Sort of define and describe it, a site that is a ceremonial grounds and considered sacred by some of the San Carlos Apache tribe. And more recently, there’s also a big controversy around the Thacker Pass mine in Nevada, which has sort of tribes on both sides of the issue. There are some tribes that oppose it, and then there are others that are actually have signed sort of benefits agreements with the development.
Robinson Meyer:
There’s like three different buckets of land here. There’s like tribal land, reservation land. There’s federal land, public land that’s owned by the federal government that’s, you know, one would imagine the government has kind of greater responsibilities to the tribe and trust. And then there’s private property. Does the NHPA process encompass both? We already said it. You already mentioned that it encompasses land off the reservation, but does it encompass both federal land and private property? Or is it just something that applies to federal land?
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
I’m actually not entirely sure about how exactly that works, but it’s actually a great question. The reason the off-reservation land thing is really important to understand, though, is that because there are so many tribes in the U.S. And they have vastly different types of land bases, the concern about off-reservation cultural sites is going to be a greater concern for smaller tribes and tribes with smaller land bases, which is actually one of the splits that you’ve been seeing around the negotiations with bay-jah or bah-hah. Whatever you want to call it. The coalition of large tribes has been a little bit more favorable towards legislation, which makes intuitive sense if you’re thinking about who would care more about Section 106 of the NHPA, whereas tribes in places like California, who’ve been working with Senator Alex Padilla on an amendment and other places where you have smaller tribes with smaller land bases, but who are going to have cultural sites off their reservations that they care about, are going to be a little bit more concerned with this legislation.
Robinson Meyer:
I want to get to what the legislation does, but the Thacker Pass example is a good one. What happens when tribes have conflicting opinions about, whether a particular land or a particular area is sacred or has kind of cultural value such that one tribe says, go ahead and do the project, or we actually want you to do the project because we would benefit from it. And another says, no, actually, you can’t do this because it impinges on a cultural resource for us.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Yeah, I mean, in the Thacker Pass case, it has mostly gone forward, is my understanding. And it’s also worth just pointing out, and other people have pointed this out on Twitter and elsewhere, but there was obviously significant tribal opposition to like the Dakota Access Pipeline, and
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
No combination of NHPA, NEPA, other forms of tribal consultation, treaty rights, etc. Stopped that project from moving forward. So the interesting thing about this whole debacle is that there is general sort of dissatisfaction with the current way that tribal consultation is conducted. Most people already feel as though it’s a bit of a sort of box checking exercise. And in fact, in prior democratic conventions, there have been efforts to move towards what is kind of considered the international standard now of free prior and informed consent, which some jurisdictions around the world have actually attempted to adopt, like British Columbia, Canada, for example, has the Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act. It’s just that now we are in a moment in time where there’s a real desire to speed up these permitting processes and because in part of the way that I think the debate about BAAJA was kind of instigated around environmental concerns which kind of subsumed the tribal consultation question I would say that the tribal consultation issue was a bit sort of grouped in with a bunch of other processes that, in retrospect, I imagine tribes do not wish they were grouped in with.
Robinson Meyer:
We’re kind of backing into this, but before we get into it, what would BAAJA do to the NHPA process as it stands right now? What would it have done before the manager’s amendment and what does it do under this new version that came out last week at the time we’re recording this?
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Yeah. So we got to be careful because this stuff is changing very quickly. So we’re recording this on Friday. It is, I think, around 1225 my time, which is Vancouver time, which is 2.30 your time.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
There are amendments, as I understand, being floated and drafted right now on this subject. So I’ll do my best to sort of summarize the prior iterations. What came first was a sort of expediting of the Section 106 tribal consultation process in a way that matched the expedited timelines expected of state historic preservation offices and other entities. It also included language that said may consult, which sort of upset tribes because it suggested that the tribal consultation piece was now sort of like an optional box to check. The initial legislation included sort of language that extended sort of geographic, how to describe this, like a mountain range or something like that could not be considered a cultural site. It had to be a specific geographic feature that had a documented history of significance to a people. And I believe, and this is still language that is being debated, I had to look up what the hell this meant when it first came out, but vacatur is basically the idea that you can go sue later, and it basically took away the ability for tribes to intervene via the courts in this permitting process.
Robinson Meyer:
In the Nipah context, it means you can sue later. The judge basically can be like, go back and study this again. What they can’t be like is, you did such a bad job on this that we’re pulling the entire study. I understand it more in the NEPA context than in the NHPA context.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
I think that sounds about right to my understanding as well. But I, again, like I’m not a lawyer and at a certain point, you just need a lot of degree to understand all this stuff. The other pieces of it that are relevant here, the sort of entities that are usually tasked with these reviews on the tribal side are called THBOs, Tribal Historic Preservation Offices. If they failed to meet the timelines after a certain amount of time in the initial drafting the bill they could be taken over for a period of time by the interior department part of that fiduciary responsibility we were talking about before and there was a fund that was set up to create additional capacity I believe it was 20 million additional dollars per year was what was originally floated for tribal historic preservation offices to meet these new expedited review timelines as well as I believe it was a $20 million fund for a database for tribes to be able to put all their important cultural sites up on the cloud.
Robinson Meyer:
To get at the politics briefly, back when I talked to Daniel Palkin from the Arnold Foundation back in the summer, who I think it’s no secret that Daniel was involved in permitting reform for a long time, was following the negotiations as an Insider back when he came on the show in the summer, he did talk about NHPA changes, but I would say they were relatively limited in scope compared to what came out in the bill. They were about things like view sheds. If you’re thinking about this from kind of the, transmission perspective, one aspect of NHPA that’s kind of developed over time is that it’s much easier to build a pipeline under the law than it is to build a transmission line because a transmission line, like a wind turbine is tall, and so you can see it from more places, while a pipeline is not tall, and so it.
Robinson Meyer:
Is much easier to either bury or route around things. And it doesn’t kind of interfere with the cultural value of that resource in the same way. And when it came on the show, I mean, one of the discussed policies was like, could you say, okay, a transmission line’s kind of NHPA boundary is only within a certain amount of area around that line. I think what’s interesting is that then when the bill came out, it was way more punitive than I think people had anticipated. And there was some sense that like NHPA might be involved in a permanent reform, but it was way more punitive, I think, especially to the THPOs, the TIPOs, than had been necessarily anticipated. It said they could be defunded. As you said, it basically said if they didn’t make decisions in time, then their leadership couldn’t leave the 25 mile radius of the office.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Oh, I didn’t catch that part. That’s crazy. Yeah, I think there’s a couple things to bring up here.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
The first is that this is a live debate beyond as we’ve kind of been getting at just the permitting reform bill. So we should also say that this bill is happening in the context of over the summer, the ACHP, the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, the agency created by NHPA had actually voted on new rules about how it was going to implement the Section 106 process, which was going to impact tribes. My understanding is that they were going to fold in tribal consultation into one sort of big kind of process. So this is a... Moving area of policy, both within the context of the permitting reform debate and beyond the context of this legislation. And I suspect that no matter what happens with this bill, it will remain that way for future administrations, for future Congress. This is just going to continue to be an issue because of course, the tribal nation to nation relationship with the federal government is one that is just continuous. And tribes are always going to want to have a greater say over what happens in their historic home.
Robinson Meyer:
When the agency made that change, was it popular? With tribes? Yeah.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
No. No. No, they opposed it. Yes.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
The reality for tribes right now is that they are, it’s a kind of complicated situation in a certain way. On the one hand, tribes have never been more powerful from a certain vantage point. In the big picture, you have the first Native American woman governor elected to New Mexico. You have two Native women who have been elected to the Senate. Tribes operate gaming operations across the country that generate like $45 billion in revenue or something like that. They’re almost half of all brick and mortar gaming operations in the country. And tribal concerns, because they tend to exist in a geography that is actually more rural and more conservative are actually kind of pretty close to the bellwether of American politics. Like there are politicians who Democrats would be shocked to learn are actually generally pretty good on tribal concerns like Senator Lisa Murkowski.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
There are others, however, who come from those types of jurisdictions who take a slightly different approach where they tend to take on the tribes in their jurisdictions a little bit more. So a big part of the dynamic I would say around this bill is that Senator Mike Lee is a Republican from Utah and there is a distinct Utah Republican tradition of taking on tribal sovereignty that goes all the way back to – and here real ball knowers are going to know what I’m talking about. But there was an era of federal Indian policy called termination in the 1950s that extended into the 60s, wherein the stated goal of the federal government to Native nations was to terminate them legally. And it was spearheaded by a Utah Republican named Arthur V. Watkins. And if you have been paying attention to Mike Lee’s statements over the years, going all the way back to like Bear’s ears, all the way back to Deb Haaland’s confirmation, he has always had a little bit more of an oppositional approach to tribal interests.
Robinson Meyer:
So we talked about what the initial version of the bill does. There’s now been this manager’s amendment, which softened some of this language and seems to have been turned some, but not all and not, I think, most tribes around on the bill. What did the manager’s amendment do?
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
So the manager’s amendment struck down or sort of redacted, took out whatever you want to say, some of the parts of the initial BAAJA deal that tribes found most distasteful. So that language that described a sort of geographic, a broader geographic feature could not be considered a cultural site unless it had documented history that was taken out of the bill. The ability for the interior department to take over typos that were in violation of their consultation that was taken out of out of the bill the language around may consult was was changed into firmer language around like the need for consultation was there I believe there was stuff around that funding that we were talking about that was changed slightly to make it more clear that it was like I don’t think the dollar amounts changed but I think it was that the 20 million was an additional amount. And there was also a provision added about what would be called tribal data sovereignty. I’ll explain that in a second. So basically, if you’re a tribe and you’re including important cultural sites in your consultation with the federal government, you don’t want that information to be FOIA’d by a well-intentioned or ill-intentioned person, because that is none of the public’s business. That is your sovereign information. And there was language added that that could not be FOIAed in these consultations.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
There’s, I’m sure, other things that I’ve missed here, but that is, I think, a good summary of the broad strokes.
Robinson Meyer:
It seems like one of the big changes you just hinted at this is that this, NHPA process, which has previously only existed under executive orders, and which, as we also were talking about, the Trump administration was, trying to get rid of, was going to become statutory, was going to be enshrined in law, though, in weaker form than it currently exists. Is that a fair summary?
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Yeah, here, I think there’s slightly different readings of the legal history. My understanding, and at the end of the day, there’s probably going to be a law review article that sorts this all out for us, but that’ll be a post facto. My understanding is that there was an amendment to the National Historic Preservation Act in 92 that did include tribal consultation. And so I don’t know if that talking point that I did see a lot of people saying and a lot of like actual lawyers saying it I don’t know if that is true I would like that one to be a little bit more fact-checked all that said though that’s actually kind of a little bit of a moot point the more pressing reality if you’re a tribal leader if you’re a typo is this rewriting of the rules by the ACHP, the reality that the Trump administration could step in with some sort of executive action or the way that the rules are administered and just kind of pull the rug out from under you. So there is a broader truth, regardless of whether there was that amendment to the NHPA that I mentioned, that the kind of choice facing tribes right now appears to be take Take this deal that you don’t love or potentially gamble even more and try to stop the deal from happening at all, in which case you could get an even worse deal.
Robinson Meyer:
Last night, as we were saying, this amendment came out from Senator Padilla and a number of different Western Democrats, including Ruben Gallego, that would have made further changes to NHPA. We really don’t know what the fate of it will be. I think by the time we release this episode, senators won’t have voted on the amendments yet. Senator Whitehouse and Senator Heinrich have, asserted is that there’s substantive amendments to the bill. The bill is such a delicate compromise that substantive amendments wouldn’t allow it to move forward. But what would this amendment do? Because it does have the support of a number of Democrats who voted to advance the permitting bill and some who said they wanted to vote to advance except but for these NHPA changes. So it’s significant that they’re all putting it out together.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Yeah. So there’s a Padilla amendment. I’ve also heard that there might be a Murkowski-Shatz amendment. We’re recording this on Friday. Maybe that becomes true over the weekend and we got a scoop here.
Robinson Meyer:
Yeah, exactly.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
And what’s interesting to me about Murkowski-Shatz is that they’re both on the Senate Committee on Indian Affairs. Murkowski would not have her seat if it were not for Alaska natives. She’s pretty no nonsense on this stuff and is generally pretty reliable for tribes. Also Republican, that’s important. The Padilla Amendment, as I understand it, again, like very quickly in all this sort of conversations, you need to have a lawyer. And I’m sure every time I open my mouth on exactly the legal language about this stuff, the lawyers probably all go, the kid is not a lawyer. Nonetheless, my understanding is basically that the Padilla Amendment makes it possible for tribes to still go to court to try to stop a development that That might be in the form of revoking the permits or something of that nature. That part I don’t fully understand. And the basic point here is that unless there is an opportunity for tribes to go to court and stop something, then tribal consultation just becomes a rubber stamp. And that is not in keeping with the nation to nation relationship. That is not in keeping with the federal government’s trust responsibility to tribes.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
I think here it’s useful to bring in a comparative context. So I am a First Nations person whose people are from Canada. I was born and raised in the U.S.. I now live in Canada. It’s a very interesting moment in time for issues related to Indigenous rights and development because both the United States and Canada. Really want to build the us has the need to build for the energy transition for the ai boom canada has a national interest in
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Building for its own ability to pivot away from the united states to open up markets with asia and the eu and ultimately what does that mean that building all has to happen somewhere and that means that the relationship between the federal government and the states and provinces and the corporations and the nations, the indigenous peoples on the other side of that, is kind of right in the heat of renewed negotiations. So here in British Columbia, there was a piece of legislation called the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act. It was probably the strongest such piece of legislation in the world. It was an attempt by the province of British Columbia to adopt the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of indigenous peoples into actual provincial legislation. It gave indigenous peoples a lot of leverage over resource development and any development really in their traditional homelands, not necessarily a veto power, but something kind of close to it. And something like that was, I would say, the aspiration of a lot of tribal leaders in the U.S.. Interestingly, there was just an election here in British Columbia where it was actually the conservatives who won a super … And so now that piece of legislation is, they promise to repeal it. So it’s probably going to be repealed in the spring at the same time, Canada is doing all this development and wants to deal with indigenous rights as little as possible, as soon as they’re doing it, but how has Canada gotten around that particular issue?
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Very interestingly, the way that they have gotten more and more consent for development has been by giving indigenous peoples more revenue and jobs from these kinds of projects. Basically, I have a close friend, Chief Willie Sellars of Williams Lake First Nation. He appears in the documentary I made, Sugarcane. Basically, one of the things he does now is he goes around the province and he tells indigenous leaders that they would be a sucker to take anything less than 20% in terms of revenue and jobs from development in their region. And of course, just like in the U.S., Native people in Canada could really use that revenue. They could really use the jobs. We are overrepresented in all of the sort of statistics of misery. And I think one of the ways that Canada, which tends to be ahead on these issues, has gotten around this is by including indigenous peoples in the resource economy, in the economy of tomorrow, which is all to say that like, I don’t know if you saw Eddington, the Ari Aster film, where it’s a tribe that actually owns the data center that’s being developed. But I actually don’t think that that’s too far off the mark from where the future likely lies. It’s pretty clear that if tribes can only become junior partners in an environmental coalition, that does not appear to have been a winning strategy anymore. But a version of a federal system wherein tribes are consulted and then also potentially use that position of power to become increasing parts of the economy in their region,
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
That I think is a real potential path forward.
Robinson Meyer:
Well, it’s interesting because that has seemed to be another fault line running through this, here in the U.S., this permanent bill discussion too, which is that there’s a broad and kind of racializing assumption that Indigenous people will always be on the side of not developing.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
On the receiving end, yeah.
Robinson Meyer:
On the receiving end of development, exactly, and therefore will oppose any development. But in fact... There are lots of indigenous communities that would love to develop. And there’s actually a lot of indigenous communities that would love to develop slash are already developing fossil fuels. And so the fossil fuel trade-offs in this bill are trade-offs they would accept because they want to be doing development too.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
That is correct. I think it’s important here to point out that there are tribes who are developing energy like the Crow Nation who have explicitly come out in favor of the bill. We mentioned the coalition of large tribes. There in general, I would say, are benefits to this bill. If you are interested in developing energy on your homelands and your tribe, there’s actually a lot of red tape involved with that from the interior department. And this bill makes it easier to do that development if you’re a tribe. I think that there’s this kind of… tribes are kind of like the first environmentalists or that they’re kind of like the indigenous face of the environmental movement in Washington. I think that this been the overwhelming way in which the left of center part of the conversation has engaged with tribes. And in reality, for many of these issues that have often been classed as like native environmental concerns, there are actually even in many of them tribes on the opposite side of the issue. So like the Wilderness Society approached me with some money to be part of their native influencer campaign. It’s worth knowing that the Wilderness Society was also leading the advocacy campaigns to protect the Alaska Native Wildlife Refuge, which had native people, very few Democrats would know this. It had native people on both sides of it, actually. There was the Gwich’in Steering Committee who wanted to protect the caribou herds that use the Alaskan National Wildlife Refuge. And then on the other side, you had the Inupiaq, who are very involved in fossil fuel development. And I would say that my over- The Inupiaq,
Robinson Meyer:
I believe, are trying to develop data centers now on the North Slope. I could be wrong.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
I’m sure. So, you know, I think my broad point here is that it’s very interesting that tribal concerns remain central to this bill, despite the fact that that’s being undercovered because very few newspapers, magazines cover tribal concerns. They are the kind of issue, interestingly, that when you move them out of this sort of environmental ownership, they are the kind of issue that both Republicans and Democrats actually... Can care about the senate committee on indian affairs people would be shocked to know is one of the most effective committees in the senate and is doing legislating all the time across the aisle and yet the way that the sort of framing of this bill both on the people in favor of it and on the opposition was overwhelmingly controlled by a sort of split environmental movement it seemed to me like you had greens who were in favor of this thing because they wanted the clean energy and And you had Greens who were opposed to this thing because they wanted to protect the environment. And tribes kind of got put under that umbrella, which did tribal issues and concerns and consultation a great disservice in this whole thing.
Robinson Meyer:
What do you wish was different about the coverage here slash the whole discussion? Because I think one aspect that I would observe is that the degree to which, these tribal issues were initially covered as, I realize I’m repeating something you just said, but the degree to which tribal issues were basically initially covered as a subset of green issues. And over time, it has become clear that, number one, senators on both sides of the aisle had substantive issues with these concerns. And to the degree that this bill ultimately does become law, it’s because senators on both sides of the aisle intervened and made this a non-democratic or non-Republican issue, to repair in the bill, even if now Democrats are on one side of this particular proposed amendment. It does seem like we could even get a bipartisan amendment soon. People always try to fit these things into narratives. And it began as a kind of abundance versus conservationist story of the bill. And it is. Tribal interests here are almost like an entirely different axis on which to understand the bill. And they’ve become the far more important axis.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
I would say that tribal interests exist on a sort of like... Federalism access of the bill. That might be the best way for people to understand it. The relationship to tribes exists regardless of your view on pro-development, anti-development. It is simply something that the federal government has a responsibility built up through case law, built up through treaties, built up through a long history of governing in this kind of way to consult with tribes about development that might impact them in their homelands or that they might even be in favor of. And I think that the way in which this has unfortunately
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Showed up in the advocacy space, and it was definitely this way when I was working in the progressive and environmental movement, is that tribal interests have basically become compelling narrative, a sort of mediagenic narrative that is brought to Washington by these green groups. I mean, it’s right there in The Wilderness Society reaching out to me to be part of a native influencer campaign against BAAJA. The money flows to the green groups who then are able to redistribute it to native activists and organizations. As a new dad, that would have been nice money for me to take. You know what I mean? I feel a need to remain neutral to retain means some amount of like truth to my sort of journalistic roots and also frankly, I myself also feel a bit cross pressured on this. I don’t love this bill, I don’t hate this bill. I understand its value for clean energy and transition and affordability I also for obvious reasons care a lot about tribal consultation and tribal issues and they’re in the crosshairs in this too my only thing here would be the environmental movement got in my view
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Kind of steamrolled in this thing. And yet, the most compelling case that happened to be walking alongside the environmental movement, all this was the tribal case, which might not have been predictable to anybody else. But like, if you pay close attention to these issues, I actually don’t think that that would have been surprising. And so like, why in the future should it continue to be a situation wherein the tribes kind of get brought along to Washington by the green groups like the tribe. Maybe it should be the opposite way around. Maybe the green groups should get brought along to Washington when they’re useful to tribes. Like I do think coming out of this, I don’t think that that BAAJA is going to be the end of this conversation. I think it’s going to carry on into the next administration. I think it might carry on into future Congresses. I think it might very well end up in the courts. I just wonder why when you have this concern that is so central to how the entire system of American governance is supposed to work. I mean, treaties are described in the constitution as the supreme law of the land. Like this has been something that the federal government has been doing relating to tribal nations for the entirety of its existence. Like, why does that become sort of an afterthought in a conversation about the environment? That makes no sense to me. And it especially does not make sense to me moving forward in the wake of this bill.
Robinson Meyer:
It’s because there’s environmental donors, right?
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
I think it’s because of the donors. I also think it’s because of a broader issue, which is like, it is very possible to become a political, cultural, economic elite in this country and know zero about tribal concerns. To me, that’s kind of outrageous. And it is a very big point of difference between the U.S. and Canada, who share so much history, who are on the same continent, who some of the same nations have been colonized by both Indigenous nations been colonized by both. And yet at this moment in time, it is very difficult to rise in Canadian media and Canadian politics if you don’t have some fluency in Indigenous issues. In the United States, in part because of the regional dynamics of the United States, where the Northeast gets to set so much of the political and cultural conversation, the economic conversation as well, it is very possible to rise up the ranks without knowing the first thing about the nation-to-nation relationship, about the trust responsibility, about all these different aspects of this that are kind of central to the deal-making right now. And it’s also very possible to be The New York Times and not have someone who’s there to cover this kind of a thing.
Robinson Meyer:
When you say this could wind up in front of the Supreme Court, what do you mean? Because it also feels like this is a forever issue. This is just something on which there will be politics indefinitely because of the nature of the United States and the nature of the relationship.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
I think that it will be indefinite. What I meant by that is if they get this really wrong, and I think if you get this really wrong, it’s pretty clear that the federal government, the Congress has run amok of its trust responsibility to tribes. If tribal consultation does become some sort of rubber stamp, I do think that that then breaks a kind of precedent built up through court cases, through the way that the government has tried to relate to tribes that I can’t imagine won’t eventually end up in the courts. And by the way, here, people might assume, well, it’s a conservative judiciary.
Robinson Meyer:
So I was going to say, Justice Gorsuch might very well have something to say about this.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Yes. And this is another part of why the tribal issues do not necessarily fit neatly into people’s understanding of this country. The most pro-treaty rights court case in a generation was decided by the current court with the opinion written by Neil Gorsuch, which found that a large fraction of Oklahoma was still reservation land. And if you think about it for a second, like, why would that be the case? Well, actually, a textualist approach to things like treaties, if you want to go back to the spirit of the letter of the law, like, that’s actually often a quite favorable reading for tribal nations. And again, the way in which tribes are geographically distributed in parts of this country that are actually quite rural and quite conservative means that the way in which they fit on the left-right axis is not the way that people who might have the assumption that just all non-white people are Democrats would assume.
Robinson Meyer:
You mentioned Murkowski and Schatz. In some ways, Alaska and Hawaii, similar states, both outside the lower 48, both have large indigenous populations, both have this colonial history. I mean, the entire country has a colonial history, but Alaska and Hawaii have a distinctly colonial history. What, which politicians, maybe it’s Murkowski and Schatz, but which politicians would you look to? And should listeners look to, to like get a sense of maybe where things are blowing on this or who have particularly interesting perspectives on this law?
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
I would say Murkowski and Schatz. I think I’d be very curious to see the reception to the Padilla amendment. People don’t often think about California as a native state. But actually, if you look at the biggest donors in various cycles in California, tribes are often quite diverse.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Right up there. And there’s a lot of them in California. The current president of the National Congress of American Indians, also Mark McCarrow, the chairman of the Pechanga tribe, is a California tribal leader. In the House, I think that interesting folks to watch here, other than obviously Jeffries, et cetera, would be Sharice Davids, a Democrat from Kansas, who’s a member of the Ho-Chunk Nation of Wisconsin, as well as Tom Cole of Oklahoma, who is Chickasaw, and who back in October, despite being Republican, expressed some skepticism about the tribal consultation elements of BAAJA. So I think if something’s going to happen here, I think that it’s some combination of these players who will likely be involved. I think that the big split on Badger that is interesting to me is actually the regional split because the states with greater environmental concerns and a lot more tribes are in the West. Here’s what I really care about. I hope that they can get this legislation as good as it can possibly be for tribes, whether that’s the Padilla Amendment or some other amendment that tribes can live with. I’m hopeful that something like that can happen. I’m hopeful that the politics can break in the right directions on that. I think that Mike Lee might be a little challenging.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
I also think that this is going to be a conversation that that goes beyond BAAJA and I do hope that people who’ve been paying attention whether you’re like kind of the abundance bros in Silicon Valley or environmentalists in Colorado or whatever I do hope that people who have been keenly following this are like oh wow like these tribal things like they really are actually kind of central to how this country runs. We should care about them. We should know about them more. And my hope is that that changes the dynamics of power, the dynamics of how money is spent, and continues to elevate tribal concerns in our national conversation.
Robinson Meyer:
Back when we had you on the first time, when you were on the book tour for We Survived the Night, one of the takeaways from that conversation was how, Native concerns, tribal concerns are often seen as like an exception or somehow different from the rest of like normal politics in the U.S. Or in Canada or in anywhere, but are in fact like should be understood correctly as a powerful but normal form of politics. I’ve been thinking about that over the past week as... These more ideological concerns about the environment and this bill have evaporated. And these concerns about exactly which governments are consulting and under which processes they’re consulting and who has power over what have become kind of the forefront of the issue.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
In a certain way, part of what I’ve, I’ve, I’ve, I guess, appreciated about the BAAJA thing is that like, when you’re right, you’re kind of right. And it’s actually really important that advocacy strategies that arguments about legislation are rooted in, in the truth and like an actually accurate understanding of the lay of the land and things of that nature. And again, I think that there is no future of this country, particularly the Western part of it, but the whole country in general that does not involve Native people involved in
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
The policymaking, the culture, the politics of it every step of the way. And to turn this conversation a little bit to the thing that has been on the Democrats’ mind so much, which has been the midterms, like there is now talk of like a 50 state strategy of Democrats trying to be competitive in places like Oklahoma, like the Dakotas again. And if you want to be competitive in Oklahoma, if you want to be competitive in the Dakotas, there are very large minorities in those states that are Native people. And so the need to be fluent in these issues, I think, to me, it continues to grow. And the the part about this that again just kind of like incessantly kind of rubs me the wrong way is the reality that this stuff is important and that like there’s this kind of weird thing that happens where people don’t understand it or don’t understand how central it is because it’s possible to go through your life being an elite in this country not knowing it and I think that that needs to change I mean very clearly if you were in favor of stopping this legislation or making it happen, you would have been better served regardless of your side on this if you knew more about tribal concerns and tribal politics. We’ll leave it there. But fantastic discussion as always. Julian, the Brave NoiseCat, thanks so much for joining us.
Julian Brave NoiseCat:
Thanks for having me, Rob.
The chip designer generously financed energy, electricity, and climate tech companies. That money spigot may be turning off.
This is Heatmap Daily, a weekday digest written by our executive editor. Subscribe here.
When Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia’s CEO last week, it marked a new era in the artificial intelligence boom that has taken over the American economy and reshaped its energy sector.
That’s because, as retail investors are now discovering, Huang was more than just a tech CEO — he was a “one-person coordination function.”
Under Huang, Nvidia was a generous financier of what often gets called the broader AI “ecosystem.” Nvidia didn’t just design the chips that made the world go round. It lent money to the companies buying the chips, backed data center projects housing them, and invested in software companies that planned to use the data centers.
That money machine has been enormously profitable, propelling Nvidia to a more than $5 trillion market cap at its peak. But it may also be prone to jolts and sudden stops. If Nvidia’s new interim CEO, Colette Kress, or her permanent replacement are less risk-prone than Huang, then it could reshape the entire AI sector.
And it could also reshape the companies worked on energy, electricity, and carbon emissions that we cover here at Heatmap.
Over the past few years, Nvidia has become a major player in the world of energy and electricity-adjacent startups and industrial firms.
Its involvement with the company Atomic Canyon, for instance, is typical.
Atomic Canyon makes AI tools for nuclear power professionals, including a search tool called Neutron, a virtual assistant called Niva, and an AI model called FERMI. Nuclear energy has seen the beginnings of a hype cycle as AI drives up electricity demand nationwide; this August, Nvidia was part of a small round of three investors who backed Atomic Canyon.
But Nvidia and Atomic Canyon had worked together since at least late 2024, when Atomic Canyon deployed Nvidia’s chips and “full-stack AI platform” as part of its on-site installation at Diablo Canyon Power Plant, California’s last remaining nuclear plant.
A press release at the time clarified the extent of their partnership: “This deployment uses NVIDIA's full-stack AI computing platform, including NVIDIA AI Enterprise software, NVIDIA Triton Inference Server software and NVIDIA Hopper architecture GPUs, which accelerate Atomic's Neutron Enterprise solution.”
In other words, Nvidia is both an investor in — and a vendor to — Atomic Canyon. This relationship wasn’t out of the ordinary, either. The chip designer has made immense investments in other energy and climate-adjacent companies at the same time that it sold or lent them chips.
It is now famous for investing in so-called “neoclouds” — new data center companies focused on providing AI services that often also supply their own energy source. And it has. Nvidia invested up to $3 billion in Lancium, a self-described clean-energy-focused data center developer connected to the Trump administration’s Stargate project. It also backed Cloverleaf, which puts together power portfolios for data centers.
But NVentures, its venture capital arm, has become an even bigger player in energy and climate startups. Nventures joined last year’s more than $800 million investment round into Commonwealth Fusion. It was part of the $650 million round into TerraPower, the nuclear energy company backed by Bill Gates. It was a strategic investor in last year’s $325 million Series E into Redwood Materials, the battery recycling company led by the early Tesla executive JB Straubel.
Nvidia also invested in businesses facing utilities, the power sector, or power plants. Nventures has invested in Emerald AI, which makes software that allows data centers to flexibly shift their electricity use; Emerald AI, Google, and Nvidia jointly started the AI Energy Management Alliance, a trade group to push for wider use of the capability. NVentures backs the startup ThinkLabs, which creates AI for power grid modeling and operations. It invested in Verse, which helps data centers connect to the grid.
It also invested in companies with less obvious climate pitches, such as CuspAI, a company that uses AI to search for new materials (including, it says, those important for carbon capture), and Periodic Labs, which says AI will help it find new superconductors.
Even climate tech companies without an obvious Nvidia investment could still be affected if its situation gets hairier.
Nvidia, for instance, was closely connected — as an investor and a “deep strategic” partner — with the AI data center developer Crusoe. Crusoe heavily relies on natural gas, but earlier this year it signed up to buy 12 gigawatt-hours of iron-air batteries from the energy storage company Form. Those batteries are due for delivery some time next year.
To be clear, Form’s order book runs much longer than Crusoe — as of August, it had least 80 gigawatt-hours of backlogged demand. But its involvement shows that even companies that just sell electricity-related technologies are exposed to the AI boom in surprising ways.
We'll learn more about the fate of Nvidia’s financing network on Wednesday, when it releases quarterly earnings.
And in any event, these will be a busy few days — the AI lab Anthropic is slated to go public on Thursday, and at some point the Senate will likely vote on amendments to its bipartisan permitting reform legislation. Suffice it to say: At the end of this week, we could be looking at a very different American clean energy and electricity industry than we are today.