Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Politics

New York Governor Kathy Hochul Is Walking a Narrow Lane on Data Centers

Can she appease AI skeptics, economic development advocates, and renewables boosters?

•
New York state renewables.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

New York Governor Kathy Hochul tried to pick out a middle way with her data center moratorium, carefully charting a course between the demands of industry, advocacy groups, and voters who are increasingly suspicious of the data center and artificial intelligence industries. Did she succeed? Only time will tell.

Hochul’s first-in-the-nation permitting pause has been hailed by data center opponents who want to re-orient American politics around the artificial intelligence backlash and lamented by the technology sector and its allies, including several in the Trump administration. President Donald Trump himself wrote on Truth Social, “New York State has made a terrible decision.” adding that the “Radical Left Dumocrats must not be allowed to cause us to lose Data Centers, AI, and all of this incredible new Technology, to China.”

Before we discuss what Hochul did, we must first discuss what she didn’t do.

What Hochul’s moratorium is not is her signature on the Responsible Data Center Development Act, a data center moratorium that passed both houses of the state legislature in June. That moratorium had a lower energy use threshold for the moratorium: 20 megawatts, compared to Hochul’s 50 megawatts.

One of that bill’s sponsors, democratic socialist Kristen Gonzalez, appeared alongside Hochul when she signed the executive order Tuesday and hailed the governor for “protecting everyday New Yorkers with a first in the nation moratorium on new large data centers.” When asked about this discrepancy by reporters, Hochul said that “we want to make sure we didn’t touch the data centers that are powering hospitals and schools and research centers,” and specifically mentioned data centers used by “bank back-office operations.”

Protecting bank back-office operations is not typically top of mind for democratic socialists. Gonzalez’s office did not respond to a request for comment.

The goal of the moratorium, Hochul said, is to develop a process for data centers to pay their way in terms of grid costs and electricity rates.

“We expect this process, which we already launched, to be completed within the year,” she said. “Once this policy’s in place, the moratorium will be reviewed and lifted.”

What is still unclear is how this moratorium interacts with renewables development, especially upstate where there is enough open space for both wind and solar power as well as large data centers.

While the New York governor has pulled back on the state’s climate goals as renewable energy and transmission has come under the dual assault of the Trump administration and rising costs, Hochul has made a point of promoting clean power development across the state, especially nuclear and hydropower, which can be built and maintained close to her western New York home base.

A New York data center industry could — emphasis on could — be a major customer for renewable power in the state, especially as there’s little prospect of large-scale new natural gas development.

During her speech announcing the moratorium, Hochul emphasized that “we’ve invested so much in other forms of power to meet the current needs of New Yorkers and our businesses,” and that “New York will require data centers to either produce their own energy or pay a premium to tap into our grid.”

The executive order itself lays out a process whereby, once the moratorium is lifted, new data centers may be required “to fund new clean electric generation and/or battery storage dedicated to their operations, consistent with the State’s clean energy goals, including customer-sited distributed energy resources, to the greatest extent feasible.”

When discussing her energy and economic policies on Bloomberg’s “Odd Lots” podcast this week, Hochul connected her data center moratorium with economic development efforts, especially upstate, where large data centers are more likely to be sited.

Referring to Micron’s $100 billion Syracuse-area semiconductor manufacturing project, Hochul told hosts Joe Weisenthal and Tracy Alloway, “I’ll work with you to get the power you need.” (The state approved a transmission line for the project last year.)

“If I have to choose between powering a largely vacant data center with the same amount of power I can have with a Micron with 1,000 jobs, I can tell you right now where I’m going,” Hochul said. “They can come under the conditions we lay out.”

But it may be just as likely data center developers take the hint and avoid a state with expensive power and high costs of doing business in the best of times.

“I don’t think we know yet how this will impact what’s known as behind-the-meter or off-the-grid power solutions: natural gas, cogeneration, solar, wind, battery storage,” Jeffrey Moerdler, a partner at the law firm Haynes Boone who chairs the data center practice, told me. “I assume it will hold up data centers powered by alternative energy sources.”

As for whether Hochul can successfully keep the one-year moratorium a year (temporary policies have a tendency to become permanent), develop new rules to address her concerns about grid costs and local opposition, and then have data centers line up to get back into New York, Moerdler was skeptical.

“It’s going to take years to make up for that shift” against data center development, he told me, predicting that the moratorium could lead to “many years of new data centers not locating here because they already started during that one-year period somewhere else.”

Something else that must be noted in all of this: “New York is not a high priority location for data centers.” Whether the state’s governor wants it to be remains to be seen.

Blue

You’re out of free articles.

Subscribe to access Heatmap's exclusive climate and energy polling, award-winning journalism, and subscriber-only events. Save $57 on an annual subscription, just $156 $99/year.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Politics

How Social Media Became a Permitting Reform Battleground

Influencers are getting paid thousands of dollars to post about one of the wonkiest policy debates in Washington.

Instagram money.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

If you occupy the same corner of the internet as I do (hello over there), you may have noticed a lot of posts about the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act — not just from Hill-watchers and energy wonks, but by creators and influencers on Instagram.

“I’ve watched the same anti-BAAJA video at least 16 times,” Kaitlyn Hennessy, a creator who tracks influence campaigns, posted on Instagram on Wednesday, referring to a wave of substantially similar videos attacking the bill. These videos typically include a detailed critical description of one or several of the bill’s provisions followed by a “call to action,” such as contacting a congressional representative.

Keep reading...Show less
AM Briefing

Lake Need

On Fermi’s lifeline, Turkish CANDUs, and China’s electric plane

A dry Lake Mead.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Current conditions: The Pacific’s highly active hurricane season just came to an end with a record 25 named storms and 11 major hurricanes • Following a wet, wintry weekend, the U.S. Northeast is poised for a dry, sunny rest of the week • Hong Kong is under a severe fire warning.


THE TOP FIVE

1. Hydropower is drying up in the American West

Evaporating. Chart: EIA Evaporating. Chart: EIA

Keep reading...Show less
Blue
Climate Tech

Bedrock Energy Raises $24 Million to Mainstream Small-Scale Geothermal

The startup’s technology drills deeper, cheaper wells for ground source geothermal temperature control.

Bedrock technology and money.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images, Bedrock Energy

Geothermal energy has been one of the clearest bipartisan winners of the second Trump administration’s energy policy. But the attention has largely centered on companies like Fervo Energy and Sage Geosystems, which aim to generate electricity from hot rocks often miles beneath the surface. Now, a less-heralded corner of the geothermal industry is attracting notice: ground source heat pumps, which use the stable underground temperature of the Earth to heat and cool buildings.

Texas-based startup Bedrock Energy is trying to modernize geothermal HVAC, a technology that dates back to the 1940s but still only serves about 1% of single-family homes and roughly 0.3% to 0.5% of large commercial buildings. High upfront drilling costs and space constraints have hampered adoption, as conventional systems typically require dozens or even hundreds of shallow wells spread across a sizable footprint. Bedrock just raised $24 million to scale a different approach, using AI and an array of sensors to drill fewer, deeper, and cheaper wells more quickly than ever before.

Keep reading...Show less
Green