Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Economy

A Green Steel Dust-Up Is a Warning

The CEO of Cleveland-Cliffs cast doubt on a new mill funded in part by $500 million in federal grants. What does that say about corporate commitments to decarbonization?

•
Steel pollution and nature.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

American steelmaker Cleveland-Cliffs cast doubt last week on the country’s most important green steel project. Chief executive Lourenco Goncalves suggested in an interview that the company was considering passing up $500 million of federal grants to build a new hydrogen-powered mill at its Middletown Works facility in Ohio, blaming fears that there won’t be buyers for the lower-carbon product, which he claimed could cost 40% more to produce than steel made by conventional methods. Cleveland-Cliffs later issued a short press release walking back Goncalves’s comments and reaffirming its commitment to the “transformational” project.

It’s, of course, possible that Goncalves was just expressing personal concerns that do not reflect the company’s official position. But either way, those doubts were not only real, but revealing about our prospects for decarbonization by mid-century.

First, the episode is a stark indictment of the many attempts to create demand for cleaner products by conjuring up corporate ambition on climate change. The entire rationale for cajoling corporations to quantify the emissions in their supply chains, known as Scope 3 emissions, has been to pressure them into sourcing greener inputs. The steel sector produces 7% to 9% of emissions globally: if it were a country, it would be the world’s third-biggest emitter after the United States and China. And steel represents the biggest single source of Scope 3 emissions for many companies in other industries — on the order of 40% to 45% for auto companies and as high as 85% for construction, for example. This makes steel a litmus test for whether Scope 3 footprinting and corporate commitments to green their supply chains are delivering as promised.

Worse, these types of steel buyers have ostensibly already been organized to show demand for green inputs. Before he stepped down as President Biden’s special envoy for climate, one of John Kerry’s cornerstone initiatives was the First Mover’s Coalition, an effort to secure advanced purchasing commitments from corporate buyers for green steel and other industrial materials. The fact that the coalition’s members – many of which are major steel buyers like Ford and General Motors – were not publically jumping all over the outputs of Cleveland-Cliffs’s heavily subsidized project is itself troubling. After all, while the green premium on steel may be significant, the material is typically a relatively cheap input into much more expensive, high value-added products.

Goncalves’s comments also underscore how uncomfortable incumbent industries perceive the jump to new, low-carbon products to be. Assume that the new Cleveland-Cliffs mill does in fact pencil out at the cost originally expected and that it has a reasonable prospect of finding offtakers. The company still says it has to invest $1.1 billion to complete the project. It is not really enough, in the logic of the market, for that investment to be profitable: It has to compete against the opportunity cost of alternative investments, including manufacturing conventional steel. Even if both outputs would find buyers, conventional steel may still be more profitable.

Now imagine the company is looking at the larger direction of the industry. If they don’t do this project, they may well forestall a shift to cleaner steel and be able to keep the sector chugging along more profitably for a little longer. Complete the project, and they may bring about changes that, while maybe inevitable, are uncomfortable for the industry. After all, Cleveland-Cliffs and U.S. Steel produce the vast majority of American primary steel; they are steel production in the United States – and so they get to shape its transformation.

This behavior is similar to that of the American car industry. U.S. automakers have largely conceded that electric vehicles will eventually overtake their combustion-engine counterparts, but they are still clinging to the better margins that gas-powered SUVs provide. The short-term profits are hard to pass up, even if it means getting farther behind EV first-movers like Tesla, BYD, and Hyundai. Once the technology pathway to a sector’s transition becomes clear — even when it feels inevitable — incumbents may still have an extremely hard time ripping off the bandaid.

It’s as if decarbonization is a massive marshmallow test for corporate America, and it’s failing.

There are essentially two ways out of this dilemma.

The first is that society will need to rely on new entrants to each sector to disrupt the status quo. Companies developing entirely novel steelmaking technologies like Boston Metals become more important to the steel transition than Cleveland-Cliffs, just as Tesla has been to the American EV market. Sublime Systems may be vital for green cement, just as Fervo Energy may be for enhanced geothermal. The problem with this approach is that it is extremely expensive to build projects in heavy industries like steel, so most pathways assume that even technology developed outside of the incumbents will get deployed by them (Sublime just this week announced a tie-up with cement giant Holcim).

This leads to option two: comprehensive industrial policy. Cleveland-Cliffs may want to see not only that one green project pencils out, but that strategic opportunities and risks favor going green. This might means measures like implementing a U.S. carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM) to prevent foreign competitors from dumping dirty steel, the government guaranteeing offtake using public procurement programs like Buy Clean and Contracts for Difference, and ultimately policy sticks like carbon pricing that send a long-term signal favoring clean products over polluting ones, instead of relying on corporate social responsibility for a demand signal.

To decarbonize the economy, we will probably have to rely both on more robust industrial policy and the sector disruption from new entrants. While the story of this Cleveland-Cliffs project is far from over, the company’s apparent hesitancy, like that of U.S. automakers, may be teaching us a lesson that we have to learn quickly if we want to see decarbonization any time soon.

Green

You’re out of free articles.

Subscribe to access Heatmap's exclusive climate and energy polling, award-winning journalism, and subscriber-only events. Save $57 on an annual subscription, just $156 $99/year.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Politics

How Social Media Became a Permitting Reform Battleground

Influencers are getting paid thousands of dollars to post about one of the wonkiest policy debates in Washington.

Instagram money.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

If you occupy the same corner of the internet as I do (hello over there), you may have noticed a lot of posts about the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act — not just from Hill-watchers and energy wonks, but by creators and influencers on Instagram.

“I’ve watched the same anti-BAAJA video at least 16 times,” Kaitlyn Hennessy, a creator who tracks influence campaigns, posted on Instagram on Wednesday, referring to a wave of substantially similar videos attacking the bill. These videos typically include a detailed critical description of one or several of the bill’s provisions followed by a “call to action,” such as contacting a congressional representative.

Keep reading...Show less
AM Briefing

Lake Need

On Fermi’s lifeline, Turkish CANDUs, and China’s electric plane

A dry Lake Mead.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Current conditions: The Pacific’s highly active hurricane season just came to an end with a record 25 named storms and 11 major hurricanes • Following a wet, wintry weekend, the U.S. Northeast is poised for a dry, sunny rest of the week • Hong Kong is under a severe fire warning.


THE TOP FIVE

1. Hydropower is drying up in the American West

Evaporating. Chart: EIA Evaporating. Chart: EIA

Keep reading...Show less
Blue
Climate Tech

Bedrock Energy Raises $24 Million to Mainstream Small-Scale Geothermal

The startup’s technology drills deeper, cheaper wells for ground source geothermal temperature control.

Bedrock technology and money.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images, Bedrock Energy

Geothermal energy has been one of the clearest bipartisan winners of the second Trump administration’s energy policy. But the attention has largely centered on companies like Fervo Energy and Sage Geosystems, which aim to generate electricity from hot rocks often miles beneath the surface. Now, a less-heralded corner of the geothermal industry is attracting notice: ground source heat pumps, which use the stable underground temperature of the Earth to heat and cool buildings.

Texas-based startup Bedrock Energy is trying to modernize geothermal HVAC, a technology that dates back to the 1940s but still only serves about 1% of single-family homes and roughly 0.3% to 0.5% of large commercial buildings. High upfront drilling costs and space constraints have hampered adoption, as conventional systems typically require dozens or even hundreds of shallow wells spread across a sizable footprint. Bedrock just raised $24 million to scale a different approach, using AI and an array of sensors to drill fewer, deeper, and cheaper wells more quickly than ever before.

Keep reading...Show less
Green