Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Podcast

The Peril of Talking About Electricity Affordability

Rob sits down with Jane Flegal, an expert on all things emissions policy, to dissect the new electricity price agenda.

•
Power lines.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

As electricity affordability has risen in the public consciousness, so too has it gone up the priority list for climate groups — although many of their proposals are merely repackaged talking points from past political cycles. But are there risks of talking about affordability so much, and could it distract us from the real issues with the power system?

Rob is joined by Jane Flegal, a senior fellow at the Searchlight Institute and the States Forum. Flegal was the former senior director for industrial emissions at the White House Office of Domestic Climate Policy, and she has worked on climate policy at Stripe. She was recently executive director of the Blue Horizons Foundation.

Shift Key is hosted by Robinson Meyer, the founding executive editor of Heatmap News.

Subscribe to “Shift Key” and find this episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon, or wherever you get your podcasts.

You can also add the show’s RSS feed to your podcast app to follow us directly.

Here is an excerpt from their conversation:

Robinson Meyer: What’s interesting is the scarcity model is driven by the fact that ultimately rate payers that is utility customers are where the buck stops, and so state regulators don’t want utilities to overbuild for a given moment because ultimately it is utility customers — it’s people who pay their power bills — who will bear the burden of a utility overbuilding. In some ways, the entire restructured electricity market system, the entire shift to electricity markets in the 90s and aughts, was because of this belief that utilities were overbuilding.

And what’s been funny is that, what, we started restructuring markets around the year 2000. For about five or six or seven years. Wall Street was willing to finance new electricity. I mean, I hear two stories here — basically it’s another place where I hear two stories, and I think where there’s a lot of disagreement about the path forward on electricity policy, in that I’ve heard a story that, basically, electricity restructuring starts in the late 90s you know year 2000, and for five years, Wall Street is willing to finance new power investment based entirely on price risk based entirely on the idea that market prices for electricity will go up. Then three things happen: The Great Recession, number one, wipes out investment, wipes out some future demand.

Number two, fracking. Power prices tumble, and a bunch of plays that people had invested in, including then advanced nuclear, are totally out of the money suddenly. Number three, we get electricity demand growth plateaus, right? So for 15 years, electricity demand plateaus. We don’t need to finance investments into the power grid anymore. This whole question of, can you do it on the back of price risk? goes away because electricity demand is basically flat, and different kinds of generation are competing over shares and gas is so cheap that it’s just whittling away.

Jane Flegal: But this is why that paradigm needs to change yet again. Like ,we need to pivot to like a growth model where, and I’m not, again —

Meyer: I think what’s interesting, though, is that Texas is the other counterexample here. Because Texas has had robust load growth for years, and a lot of investment in power production in Texas is financed off price risk, is financed off the assumption that prices will go up. Now, it’s also financed off the back of the fact that in Texas, there are a lot of rules and it’s a very clear structure around finding firm offtake for your powers. You can find a customer who’s going to buy 50% of your power, and that means that you feel confident in your investment. And then the other 50% of your generation capacity feeds into ERCOT. But in some ways, the transition that feels disruptive right now is not only a transition like market structure, but also like the assumptions of market participants about what electricity prices will be in the future.

Flegal: Yeah, and we may need some like backstop. I hear the concerns about the risks of laying early capital risks basically on rate payers in the frame of growth rather than scarcity. But I guess my argument is just there’s ways to deal with that. Like we could come up with creative ways to think about dealing with that. And I’m not seeing enough ideation in that space, which — I would like, again, a call for papers, I guess — that I would really like to get a better handle on.

The other thing that we haven’t talked about, but that I do think, you know, the States Forum, where I’m now a senior fellow, I wrote a piece for them on electricity affordability several months ago now. But one of the things that doesn’t get that much attention is just like getting BS off of bills, basically. So there’s like the rate question, but then there’s the like, what’s in a bill? And like, what, what should or should not be in a bill? And in truth, you know, we’ve got a lot of social programs basically that are being funded by the rate base and not the tax base. And I think there are just like open questions about this — whether it’s, you know, wildfire in California, which I think everyone recognizes is a big challenge, or it’s efficiency or electrification or renewable mandates in blue states. There are a bunch of these things and it’s sort of like there are so few things you can do in the very near term to constrain rate increases for the reasons we’ve discussed.

You can find a full transcript of the episode here.

Mentioned:

Cheap and Abundant Electricity Is Good, by Jane Flegal

From Heatmap: Will Virtual Power Plants Ever Really Be a Thing?

Previously on Shift Key: How California Broke Its Electricity Bills and How Texas Could Destroy Its Electricity Market

This episode of Shift Key is sponsored by …

Accelerate your clean energy career with Yale’s online certificate programs. Explore the 10-month Financing and Deploying Clean Energy program or the 5-month Clean and Equitable Energy Development program. Use referral code HeatMap26 and get your application in by the priority deadline for $500 off tuition to one of Yale’s online certificate programs in clean energy. Learn more at cbey.yale.edu/online-learning-opportunities.

Music for Shift Key is by Adam Kromelow.

Yellow

You’re out of free articles.

Subscribe to access Heatmap's exclusive climate and energy polling, award-winning journalism, and subscriber-only events. Save $57 on an annual subscription, just $156 $99/year.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Daily Briefing

What GTA and the IEA Teach Us About the Future of Energy

The long-awaited video game Grand Theft Auto VI and the International Energy Agency’s voluminous annual report came out today. Here’s what they say about oil, gas, and the dawning age of electricity.

Fatih Birol in GTA 6.
Heatmap Illustration/Rockstar Games, Getty Images

Some people spend their whole lives dreaming about days like today.

A globally respected organization, headquartered in western Europe, has finally released its magnum opus — a vast interactive compendium representing the world in all its joy, violence, and money-grubbing craziness.

Keep reading...Show less
Blue
Climate Tech

Meta Joins the Clean Materials Race

It’s following Microsoft into deals with Fortera, Sublime, and Stegra.

The Meta logo.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Meta’s climate reputation, to put it mildly, leaves something to be desired. When Heatmap surveyed a group of our sharpest energy insiders late last year about their views on the politics, investments, predictions, and broader sentiment shaping the climate and energy world, we asked which hyperscaler they thought was doing the best on climate. Google and Microsoft emerged as clear frontrunners, while Meta narrowly beat out Amazon in the race to the bottom.

At the time, that seemed well-founded. Google pioneered the concept of 24/7 energy matching, and made early bets on advanced geothermal and small modular reactors. Microsoft built the carbon removal market practically singlehandedly while making deals with low-carbon materials suppliers like steelmaker Stegra and clean cement startup Sublime Systems. Meta, meanwhile, was making headlines for its gigantic new data center campus in Louisiana, which it aims to power with 7.5 gigawatts of new natural gas plants.

Keep reading...Show less
Blue
AM Briefing

Anthropic’s Moment

On Philippine nuclear, Ford’s new battery bet, and congestion pricing

The Anthropic logo.
Samuel Boivin/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Current conditions: Thai authorities placed 14 of the country’s 15 southern provinces on high alert from flooding due to monsoon rains • The Australian town of Weipa, in Far North Queensland, broke a record with 41 consecutive days of temperatures above 96.8 degrees Fahrenheit • A series of storms is set to hammer California over the next week with heavy rain and snow in the Sierra Nevada mountains.


THE TOP FIVE

1. Anthropic makes history as the first AI lab to go public

Anthropic is set to begin trading on the Nasdaq under the ticker ANT later today, becoming the first frontier artificial intelligence lab to become a publicly traded entity. The Claude maker is expected to price its shares somewhere north of $80 — CNBC reported $83, while Bloomberg pegged the number at $85. The initial public offering marks a turning point in the maturation of AI as an industry and offers a clear metric by which the rest of the world will be able to assess the technology’s lofty claims of progress. As a primer, I recommend reading some of my colleagues’ past coverage of the company:

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow