Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Daily Briefing

The Rise of ‘None-of-the-Above’ Local Energy Laws

A small but growing share of counties are targeting data centers, solar farms, and battery storage systems at the same time.

•
A data center protester.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

I’ve got an update for you on the data center backlash — and what it could mean for the governor’s race in Wisconsin, one of the country’s most important state-level battles in the upcoming midterms.

Last week, I wrote about how the Republican congressman and Wisconsin gubernatorial candidate Tom Tiffany was trying to turn the data center issue into a kind of trojan horse for slowing down renewables. Tiffany claimed to be anti-data-center, but he was really looking to apply new and stricter rules to clean energy development, as well.

Over the weekend, Tiffany said the quiet part loud. “David Crowley wants to cover our farmland with industrial-scale wind, solar, and data centers,” he posted on X. (He also started calling his opponent “Data Center David Crowley.”) Tiffany vowed to “protect Wisconsin farmland,” picking up on the idea — already used by the Trump administration to stymie solar development — that renewables threaten the integrity of agricultural land.

Now Crowley isn’t nearly as pro-data-center as Tiffany claims, although he has said the computing facilities should run on 100% clean energy. Yet Tiffany's accusation made me curious: How many local governments now see data centers and renewables as a package deal — and a farmland-threatening incursion that should be blocked? Back in March, my colleague Jael Holzman has covered how data centers are turning Americans against renewables. Are we seeing that on the ground?

Our market intelligence service Heatmap Pro tracks local laws affecting clean energy, batteries, and data centers. I asked the Pro team to look at how many local governments have now banned all three types of infrastructure — communities with what you might call a “none of the above” policy.

There’s mostly good news in the results for renewables advocates. The number of towns and counties that have blocked data centers, solar, and batteries remains small. As of late last week, 21 counties across the country have an active restriction or moratorium on solar, batteries, and data centers combined.

Another 10 counties have banned either data centers and solar, or data centers and batteries, but not all three. Six cities or municipalities have placed combined restrictions on the technologies nationwide.

The bad news: The number is growing fast. Most of these “none-of-the-above” restrictions were passed in 2026, and the overwhelming majority are in the rural Midwest and Great Plains. Kansas, Iowa, and Indiana account for most of the moratoriums or restrictive laws.

Not all of the restrictions are new. Although most of these multi-technology restrictions get passed at the same time, a handful of counties blocked solar and batteries first, then tacked on data centers later. Dickinson County, Kansas, for instance, has long blocked solar and batteries. But this spring, as the data center boom came along, the county’s leaders extended that moratorium to apply to data centers and all forms of energy development — including natural gas.

Overall, the scale of the trend remains small. Less than 10% of data center restrictions nationwide also target clean energy. That’s good news for renewable developers because the number of data center ordinances is surging. More than 530 data center restrictions are now on the books nationwide, and most restrictions have come in the past 12 months.

And what about the Wisconsin election? As of right now, only one county in America’s Dairyland has restricted data centers and batteries together. None have restricted solar, wind, and batteries. But Tiffany does seem to be tapping into a much larger zeitgeist. When you look at the stated reasons why communities nationwide are adopting these policies, farmland protection ranks high on the list. When it comes to permitting politics, in other words, farmland looks like the next frontier.

Blue

You’re out of free articles.

Subscribe to access Heatmap's exclusive climate and energy polling, award-winning journalism, and subscriber-only events. Save $57 on an annual subscription, just $156 $99/year.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Climate Tech

General Flash Emerges From Stealth With $128 Million for Domestic Refining

The startup says its “new physics” will make America’s critical minerals processing cheaper, cleaner, and — most importantly — more competitive with China.

MIT and the periodic table.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

If General Flash has it right, America may have a new way to refine nearly every critical metal it now buys from China.

The Cambridge, Massachusetts-based startup emerged from stealth Tuesday with $128 million in combined seed and Series A funding from Lux Capital, Lowercarbon Capital, Overmatch Ventures, Construct Capital, and others. The MIT spinout is pioneering “new physics,” its founder and CEO, Ric Fulop, told me, which allows it to refine metal oxides into high-purity metals using an electrolytic process that produces no direct emissions. The company has already broken ground on its first commercial facility, a 1,000-metric-ton per year plant in Massachusetts that Fulop said will begin production next summer.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow
AM Briefing

Seventh Heaven

On a Darlington update, BAAJA myopia, and a shale megadeal

The J.H. Campbell power plant.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Current conditions: A storm is brewing over the Pacific Ocean that could dump 2 to 3 feet of snow on California’s Donner Pass later this week • Cyclone Akvan is intensifying in the Bay of Bengal, putting the storm on track to make landfall over India’s Andhra Pradesh by Friday • The Northern Cook Islands, one of the two chains of atolls that comprise the eponymous South Pacific nation, are bracing for Tropical Cyclone Xavier to hit this week as a Category 2 storm with damaging winds.


THE TOP FIVE

1. Trump issues seventh order to keep Michigan coal plant operating

The Department of Energy has issued its seventh emergency order to keep the coal-fired J.H. Campbell plant in West Olive, Michigan, running past its planned retirement. Late on Friday, the agency reupped its directive under Section 202 of the Federal Power Act mandating that the facility, owned primarily by the utility Consumers Energy, stay open to prevent blackouts on the Midcontinent Independent System Operator, the nation’s largest grid. The move, Utility Dive noted Monday, follows a September federal appeals court decision vacating a previous emergency order to keep Campbell running, which it said cut against state authority over what kinds of resources generate electricity within their borders.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow
Podcast

How Tribes Became Power Players on Permitting Reform

Rob welcomes back Julian Brave NoiseCat to talk about the National Historic Preservation Act and why it’s so central to these negotiations.

Julian Brave NoiseCat.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

One big sticking point that’s emerged in negotiations over the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act are the changes it would make to the National Historic Preservation Act. The bill would rewrite Section 106 of that law, which requires the federal government to consult with tribal nations before it permits a major project on or adjacent to land of Native cultural value. Crucially, the protections in Section 106 of the NHPA don’t end at the borders of a reservation. They extend to public and private property, as well.

The initial version of the legislation would have shrunk the scope and shortened the deadlines of reviews under the NHPA, and imposed punitive new rules on the officials in charge of overseeing those processes. It would have also allowed the federal government to step in and take over a local official’s office if officials thought they weren’t moving quickly enough. A subsequent amendment would soften many of those revisions, but not all of them.

Keep reading...Show less
Green