Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Economy

Inflation Is Killing Long-Term Climate Bets

It’s hard to make assumptions about cost more than a decade out. Just ask the nuclear startup NuScale.

•
NuScale projects.
Heatmap Illustration/Screenshot-YouTube, Getty Images

Every company is, in a certain light, a kind of time machine, and every new product is a missive from the past. When a group of people get together to launch a startup, they’re making a bet that in a few months or years, people are going to want what they’re selling.

In the software industry, the past isn’t too long ago. Because it is possible to code and distribute an app somewhat quickly, a new software product might have only been conceived earlier that year or a year or two earlier.

In a mature consumer-product field — like, say, the car industry — the timeline is longer. A model year 2024 car might have first been conceived of in 2022, and it probably relies on a deeper engineering structure — a “platform” — that might date back to 2018 or earlier. Every new car contains, in essence, two-year-old technology.

But in the “hard tech” industry, the delay can be even longer. It can take more than a decade to get a new type of airplane or power plant to market. These types of technology are the biggest bet of all — because by the time the missive reaches its destination, the world may have changed.

So it was with NuScale, an Oregon-based company developing a small, modular nuclear reactor. Last week, NuScale announced that it was pulling out of a Department of Energy-backed, first-of-a-kind project in Utah.

The company had once planned to build six small, modular nuclear reactors in Utah in conjunction with the Idaho National Laboratory. But despite receiving more than $1 billion in Department of Energy subsidies, NuScale could not make the economics of its project work.

The main problem was that NuScale’s electricity was too expensive. Over the past two years, the estimated price of its project surged, rising by more than 75%. Because electricity projects have to recoup their costs from selling power, those high construction costs helped increase the estimated cost of the project’s electricity by 53%.

By the end, NuScale estimated that power from the project would cost $89 per megawatt-hour. (The average cost of residential electricity in Utah is about $20 per megawatt hour.) Of course, nuclear energy can provide benefits beyond what is captured by price — it is one of the few energy sources that can provide 24/7, zero-carbon electricity — but some costs are too high. NuScale struggled to sell its electrons to nearby towns: It simply could not compete with cheaper electricity from natural gas, solar, or other fuels.

It wasn’t supposed to be like this: NuScale’s smaller size and modular design were supposed to result in lower costs. In essence, NuScale hoped that cost savings would emerge from learning-by-doing and economies of scale — as it got better at making small, modular reactors, it would figure out how to bring down their costs.

That wasn’t a ludicrous idea. Economies of scale have brought down the cost of solar, wind, batteries, and electric vehicles over the past decade. And that idea — that as people do something more, they figure out how to do it more cheaply and efficiently — underpins American and Chinese climate policy.

But the Utah project was the first project of its kind, so NuScale hadn’t yet had the opportunity to take advantage of those economies of scale.

NuScale “shows how much customer matters for a first-of-a-kind deployment. NuScale went down a road that would have proven to be a really interesting model if successful, but it was a lot of legwork,” Ryan Norman, a nuclear analyst at the think tank Third Way, told me. Other advanced nuclear startups have more reliable customer relationships, he added.

Even worse for NuScale, the company found itself building the project amid the worst inflation in a generation. What might have once seemed like a “boring” part of a reactor’s design could create new and spiraling costs.

For instance, NuScale’s design required a lot of concrete, Farah Benahmed, a nuclear policy analyst at Breakthrough Energy, a set of climate investment and advocacy organizations founded by Bill Gates, told me. But concrete costs have risen dramatically, increasing by more than 9% over the past two years and helping to drive the company’s spiraling costs. Other advanced reactor designs don’t rely on concrete to the same degree as NuScale, Benahmed said. (Gates has invested in Terrapower, an advanced nuclear company that competes with NuScale.)

Other key inputs into NuScale’s reactors have also surged in price. From 2021 to 2023, the cost of carbon steel piping more than doubled, according to producer price index data. The cost of fabricated steel plates rose by more than 50%, and the cost of copper wiring rose by 30%.

More broadly, NuScale was founded in 2007 — which means, almost inevitably, that the company was responding to a very different energy moment than the one we have now. At the time, the world was undergoing the first wave of widespread public concern about climate change, driven by Hurricane Katrina, An Inconvenient Truth, and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s fourth assessment report. It seemed plausible that Congress might pass a bipartisan cap-and-trade law, which would benefit zero-carbon nuclear power.

Most importantly, U.S. electricity costs were rising, and experts feared they would continue to increase in the 2010s. America’s natural gas supplies seemed to be running out, and the country was preparing to import liquified natural gas in large quantities.

Then came the fracking boom. Cheap natural gas flooded the market, reshaping the domestic energy system and moderating the rise in power prices. The United States never passed a carbon price or a cap-and-trade law. And the economics of building lots of NuScale reactors to provide zero-carbon, 24/7 electricity now look seriously different.

NuScale is not the only clean energy company to run into inflation-driven problems. The offshore-wind company Orsted recently canceled two projects on the Jersey shore due to cost and supply-chain problems. Other offshore projects are also at risk.

Nuclear advocates said that despite its issues, NuScale has accomplished something that no other nuclear startup has. It is the sole nuclear startup to receive approval from the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, the federal agency that must approve nuclear reactors before they can be used. “NuScale has paved the way for how to move through the NRC process. They’re a great example and paved the way for the industry,” Benahmed, the Breakthrough analyst, said.

That approval process took more than four years. It shows another way that it can take years or even decades for “hard tech” companies to get to market — to send their missive from the past to the present.

But despite that long timeline, advocates remain upbeat about the larger industry. “The investor base will do its due diligence to assess what business decisions went wrong with NuScale, but ultimately I think this development is less detrimental to the wave of support we've seen for advanced nuclear from that group,” Norman, the Third Way analyst, said. Because NuScale uses a small version of a light-water reactor — a conventional reactor technology that other advanced-nuclear startups have eschewed — investors probably won’t lose faith in the sector itself.

But they agreed that the make-or-break moment for nuclear is coming up. “The key decision point we need to wrestle with as we continue along the innovation path is: Who is going to lead?” Norma said. “Our allies are waiting. Our competitors are watching. Like it or not, now is the time for the U.S. and industry to prove itself. We've gotta have moxy.”

Editor's note: The original version of this article misidentified one of NuScale’s investors. We regret the error.

Green
Black Friday Sale

You’ve read your free article. Keep reading with a Heatmap membership

Take 25% off any plan with code THANKS.
Standard Plan
Member

Everything Heatmap publishes, plus a seat in the room.

$129
$97 /year
  • Unlimited access. Every story and newsletter, with no paywall.
  • Virtual briefings. Live sessions with our reporters.
  • Happy hours and events. Member gatherings throughout the year.
Premium Plan
Supporter

For readers who want to keep the journalism going

$349
$262 /year
  • Everything in Member, plus:
  • Exclusive polling access. Heatmap's climate comms polling.
  • VIP at Heatmap House. A reception ticket, plus a membership to gift.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
AM Briefing

The Senate Permits

On the clean subsidy race, a deep-sea mining auction, and Canada’s carbon removal push

The Capitol.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Current conditions: A “rain bomb” just deluged parts of southeastern Florida, with as much as 15 inches pouring on suburbs west of Fort Lauderdale • As Pacific storms drench California, downtown San Francisco recorded more than 2.6 inches of rain on Wednesday alone, exceeding the 2.2-inch record set in 1918 • Indian authorities have upgraded Cyclone Akvan to a “severe cyclonic storm” as it makes landfall today in Andhra Pradesh.


THE TOP FIVE

1. The Senate passes permitting reform

The Senate passed the bipartisan permitting reform bill Thursday night on a 62-33 vote. Every Republican except Missouri’s Josh Hawley and South Dakota’s Mike Rounds, critics of the legislation’s provisions for transmission lines, joined more than a dozen Democrats to pass the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. The bill passed without an 11th-hour amendment designed to address the concerns of some tribal groups, which was blocked by Oregon Senator Jeff Merkley, who objected that the body was not voting on his separate amendment to ban data centers on federal lands. “Tribes are being screwed by a last ditch environmental Hail Mary to make the bill as bad as possible before it gets to the House,” Julian Brave NoiseCat, a Native writer and filmmaker, wrote in a post on X. Earlier this week, NoiseCat explained to my colleague Robinson Meyer how tribal groups became power players in the negotiations over the legislation on an episode of our Shift Key podcast. Senator Lisa Murkowski, the Alaska Republican who had coauthored the tribal amendment with the Hawaii’s Democratic Senator Brian Schatz, told Punchbowl News’ Josh Siegel before the vote that it would be “short sighted” to pass BAAJA without the amendment, and said she would “find another way” to write the protections into law. “Not only is it significant from the tribal protections but there were issues in other parts of the country worried on the transmission side. So there was a good reason we worked so hard on this,” Murkowski said, according Siegel’s tweet. Renewable energy trade associations lauded the vote, even without the last-minute changes. “The Senate has cleared a path to enable the construction of hundreds of additional clean energy projects and strengthen rural communities,” Jason Grumet, the CEO of American Clean Power, said in a statement.

Keep reading...Show less
Blue
Daily Briefing

What GTA and the IEA Teach Us About the Future of Energy

The long-awaited video game Grand Theft Auto VI and the International Energy Agency’s voluminous annual report came out today. Here’s what they say about oil, gas, and the dawning age of electricity.

Fatih Birol in GTA 6.
Heatmap Illustration/Rockstar Games, Getty Images

Some people spend their whole lives dreaming about days like today.

A globally respected organization, headquartered in western Europe, has finally released its magnum opus — a vast interactive compendium representing the world in all its joy, violence, and money-grubbing craziness.

Keep reading...Show less
Blue
Climate Tech

Meta Joins the Clean Materials Race

It’s following Microsoft into deals with Fortera, Sublime, and Stegra.

The Meta logo.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Meta is reconsidering its biggest climate promise. In its 2026 sustainability report, released Thursday afternoon, the company said it is “re-evaluating” its goal of reaching net-zero by 2030, amidst a 45% year-over-year increase in its emissions. That tracks with the broader skepticism toward Meta’s climate bonafides. When Heatmap asked a group of our sharpest energy insiders late last year which hyperscaler they thought was doing the best on climate, Google and Microsoft emerged as clear frontrunners, while Meta narrowly beat out Amazon in the race to the bottom.

It was not surprising. After all, Google pioneered the concept of 24/7 energy matching, and made early bets on advanced geothermal and small modular reactors. Microsoft built the carbon removal market practically singlehandedly while making deals with low-carbon materials suppliers like steelmaker Stegra and clean cement startup Sublime Systems. Meta, meanwhile, was making headlines for its gigantic new data center campus in Louisiana, which it aims to power with 7.5 gigawatts of new natural gas plants.

Keep reading...Show less
Blue