Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Politics

America’s Climate Future Will Be Decided in Arizona

From the national to the state to the local level, the state is about to hold some of the country’s most crucial elections.

•
The Arizona flag and clean energy.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

In 2022, the Arizona Republic published a sentence many Democrats had dreamed of reading for decades: “Arizona,” the paper announced, “is a blue state.”

At the time, it felt true. In 2020, Joe Biden won the Grand Canyon State — only the second time a Democrat had done so since Arizona broke for Harry Truman in 1952 — and Democrat Mark Kelly defeated Republican Sen. Martha McSally in a special election to fill the late John McCain’s Senate seat, a victory that helped the Inflation Reduction Act get over the finish line. The 2022 midterm elections confirmed that the Democrats’ wins in the state hadn’t just been a one-time occurrence: Kelly successfully defended his seat, securing a full term; Katie Hobbs won the governorship; and Adrian Fontes beat a January 6 participant to become the secretary of state, Democrats all.

With the 2024 election still a little more than a week away, it’s too soon to tell whether the blue state proclamations of 2022 were premature. But Arizona hasn’t been looking terribly cerulean. In 2023, the Republican-held state legislature passed eight of 16 anti-environment bills introduced and stranded 22 pro-environment bills without committee hearings. Republican voter registration in the state has also swelled since 2016 as Democratic rolls stayed relatively stagnant, giving the GOP an edge in a place where 10,457 votes can make all the difference.

Arizona is just one state out of 50 (or 11 electoral votes out of 538, if you prefer), but it represents a curious microcosm of the high-stakes climate and energy elections happening all over the country this November. Or perhaps it is not so curious: Arizona is on the front lines of the climate-related impacts of droughts, longer and nastier heat waves, ozone pollution, and wildfires, while also being in a position to weigh the trade-offs of crucial clean energy developments like building new energy transmission, critical mineral mining, and utility-scale solar. “It’s like an incubator. There’s just so much happening here, it’s ready to burst,” Jane Conlin, a co-leader of the Tucson chapter of the Citizens' Climate Lobby, which has been engaging in get-out-the-vote efforts with the Environmental Voter Project, told me.

Aside from its electoral college allocations, the most consequential race in Arizona this cycle will be for outgoing Independent Senator Kyrsten Sinema’s seat. The state is currently leaning slightly toward Democratic Representative Ruben Gallego, who could help stem a total hemorrhaging of blue seats from the Senate — which, in turn, would have implications for the passage of any decarbonization legislation in the next administration.

Two U.S. House elections in Arizona could similarly help determine the balance of power on Capitol Hill come January. AZ-01 is the wealthiest congressional district in the state, in the northeastern corner of Phoenix’s Maricopa County, where a former E.R. doctor is trying to unseat a seven-term Republican incumbent in a battle that has centered on abortion access. (The district is also home to the Rio Verde Foothills, which made national headlines in 2022 when Scottsdale cut off its water supply due to drought-related shortages.)

But it’s the other race, in the sixth congressional district spanning the suburbs of Tucson, that looks more like a proxy battle between different climate ideologies. Kirsten Engel — who previously worked for the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and serves as the co-director of the Environmental Law Program at the University of Arizona — is challenging Juan Ciscomani, a Trump-endorsed moderate conservative who has backed residential solar projects, promoted himself as an advocate for a “secure water future,”and, earlier this year, co-sponsored a bill seen as a first step toward a carbon border tax. (As his opponents quickly point out, he also voted against the IRA; Ciscomani has also been tied to a groundwater scandal involving a Saudi Arabian-owned alfalfa farm.)

Engel previously lost a tight election against Ciscomani in 2022, and has made abortion a centerpiece of her campaign, too. But she has also gone aggressively after the Republican for his alignment with the mining industry, including his support for a proposed open-pit copper mine that opponents say will pollute Tucson’s air and waterways; supporters, meanwhile, say it’s critical to create a domestic supply chain for the energy transition. The League of Conservation Voters, which identified the sixth congressional district election as one of its priority races, is running ads in the state playing up this pollution angle.

Engel herself has slammed the proposed mine, which would be built on public lands, as a “giveaway” to a foreign mining company, and touted the need to protect the region’s “spectacular scenic vistas and the tourism economy.” She has also sought to go toe-to-toe with Ciscomani on water conservation, though as Grist has reported, drought and water rights can be tricky for Arizona politicians to run on because voters don’t have a firm grasp of how the complicated policies work.

The future of climate policy at the regional and municipal levels in Arizona is also in play. Democrats could potentially flip the balance of power in the state House and Senate, each branch currently having just a one-seat Republican advantage, and restart movement on the slate of stalled pro-environmental bills. (The Democratic governor’s term runs through 2026.) “The state legislature in Arizona is so critical,” John Qua, the campaign manager of Lead Locally, told me. “Not only does building a democratic trifecta get the state closer to passing policy that tackles climate change in some of the ways we might more typically understand it — like moving towards clean energy — but it also makes it much likelier that the state legislature will pass water conservation policy.”

The 11 races are “all at a razor-thin margin,” Qua told me, though climate is unlikely to be the issue that tips the balance in any of them. That goes for just about any race in Arizona — except the state’s Corporation Commission, which Heatmap’s Emily Pontecorvo covered earlier this week. Currently, the ACC is operating with a four-to-one Republican majority, but with three Democrats, two Green party candidates, and three Republicans (including an incumbent) running to fill three seats, there’s a wide-open chance that candidates sympathetic to clean energy policy, including the state’s massive solar opportunity, could take control.

“Arizona could lead the world in solar power if politicians would only let it,” Nathaniel Stinnett, the founder and executive director of the Environmental Voter Project, told me. “But that isn’t going to happen unless the climate movement starts showing up in unstoppable numbers whenever there’s an election.”

Conlin, who co-leads the Tucson chapter of the Citizens’ Climate Lobby, has been working on the ground to reach the 230,000 potential first-time environmental voters that Stinnett and his team have identified in the state. (EVP numbers released earlier this week showed that those who vote based on climate issues were about 20% more likely to have submitted an early vote than the average voter.) During a recent folklife festival CCL volunteers attended, “I think about only 25% of people [we engaged with] were really aware of the Arizona Corporation Commission,” Conlin told me. But she’s excited nevertheless: This year, the ACC poll is on the front of Arizonans’ ballots, rather than the back, making it harder for even low-information voters to overlook.

The state is also a case study of how an elected body as small and seemingly insignificant as a school board can make a difference in the progress toward decarbonization. The Tucson Unified School District board of governors will vote next week on a climate action plan that would set a goal of reaching net-zero emissions by 2045. If successful, TUSD would be one of the first school districts in the nation to have implemented such a plan.

Arizona is not the only state in the country that, as Colin put it, feels “on this cusp of being able to reach out — not only to see a 50% cut in emissions but 100%. It’s doable, it’s within reach.” Pennsylvania and Michigan voters will also have opportunities to elect politicians who will advance climate legislation, and voters in Washington, California, and New York can defend their states’ progress. But it’s Arizona where the stakes seem especially immediate — and high. “It’s supposed to be 96 [degrees Fahrenheit] here today,” Conlin marveled when we spoke this week, at the end of October.

I could hear the weariness in the voices of the organizers I spoke to after a long, hard-fought season; candidates are set to make their final pitches to voters next week. Early-voting ballots are already in the mail or in hand. The CCL has just one final day of canvassing planned, on November 2. The polls will close three days later, at 7 p.m. local time, and then the count will begin.

Black Friday Sale

You’ve read your free article. Keep reading with a Heatmap membership

Take 25% off any plan with code THANKS.
Standard Plan
Member

Everything Heatmap publishes, plus a seat in the room.

$129
$97 /year
  • Unlimited access. Every story and newsletter, with no paywall.
  • Virtual briefings. Live sessions with our reporters.
  • Happy hours and events. Member gatherings throughout the year.
Premium Plan
Supporter

For readers who want to keep the journalism going

$349
$262 /year
  • Everything in Member, plus:
  • Exclusive polling access. Heatmap's climate comms polling.
  • VIP at Heatmap House. A reception ticket, plus a membership to gift.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
AM Briefing

The Senate Permits

On the clean subsidy race, a deep-sea mining auction, and Canada’s carbon removal push

The Capitol.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Current conditions: A “rain bomb” just deluged parts of southeastern Florida, with as much as 15 inches pouring on suburbs west of Fort Lauderdale • As Pacific storms drench California, downtown San Francisco recorded more than 2.6 inches of rain on Wednesday alone, exceeding the 2.2-inch record set in 1918 • Indian authorities have upgraded Cyclone Akvan to a “severe cyclonic storm” as it makes landfall today in Andhra Pradesh.


THE TOP FIVE

1. The Senate passes permitting reform

The Senate passed the bipartisan permitting reform bill Thursday night on a 62-33 vote. Every Republican except Missouri’s Josh Hawley and South Dakota’s Mike Rounds, critics of the legislation’s provisions for transmission lines, joined more than a dozen Democrats to pass the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. The bill passed without an 11th-hour amendment designed to address the concerns of some tribal groups, which was blocked by Oregon Senator Jeff Merkley, who objected that the body was not voting on his separate amendment to ban data centers on federal lands. “Tribes are being screwed by a last ditch environmental Hail Mary to make the bill as bad as possible before it gets to the House,” Julian Brave NoiseCat, a Native writer and filmmaker, wrote in a post on X. Earlier this week, NoiseCat explained to my colleague Robinson Meyer how tribal groups became power players in the negotiations over the legislation on an episode of our Shift Key podcast. Senator Lisa Murkowski, the Alaska Republican who had coauthored the tribal amendment with the Hawaii’s Democratic Senator Brian Schatz, told Punchbowl News’ Josh Siegel before the vote that it would be “short sighted” to pass BAAJA without the amendment, and said she would “find another way” to write the protections into law. “Not only is it significant from the tribal protections but there were issues in other parts of the country worried on the transmission side. So there was a good reason we worked so hard on this,” Murkowski said, according Siegel’s tweet. Renewable energy trade associations lauded the vote, even without the last-minute changes. “The Senate has cleared a path to enable the construction of hundreds of additional clean energy projects and strengthen rural communities,” Jason Grumet, the CEO of American Clean Power, said in a statement.

Keep reading...Show less
Blue
Daily Briefing

What GTA and the IEA Teach Us About the Future of Energy

The long-awaited video game Grand Theft Auto VI and the International Energy Agency’s voluminous annual report came out today. Here’s what they say about oil, gas, and the dawning age of electricity.

Fatih Birol in GTA 6.
Heatmap Illustration/Rockstar Games, Getty Images

Some people spend their whole lives dreaming about days like today.

A globally respected organization, headquartered in western Europe, has finally released its magnum opus — a vast interactive compendium representing the world in all its joy, violence, and money-grubbing craziness.

Keep reading...Show less
Blue
Climate Tech

Meta Joins the Clean Materials Race

It’s following Microsoft into deals with Fortera, Sublime, and Stegra.

The Meta logo.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Meta is reconsidering its biggest climate promise. In its 2026 sustainability report, released Thursday afternoon, the company said it is “re-evaluating” its goal of reaching net-zero by 2030, amidst a 45% year-over-year increase in its emissions. That tracks with the broader skepticism toward Meta’s climate bonafides. When Heatmap asked a group of our sharpest energy insiders late last year which hyperscaler they thought was doing the best on climate, Google and Microsoft emerged as clear frontrunners, while Meta narrowly beat out Amazon in the race to the bottom.

It was not surprising. After all, Google pioneered the concept of 24/7 energy matching, and made early bets on advanced geothermal and small modular reactors. Microsoft built the carbon removal market practically singlehandedly while making deals with low-carbon materials suppliers like steelmaker Stegra and clean cement startup Sublime Systems. Meta, meanwhile, was making headlines for its gigantic new data center campus in Louisiana, which it aims to power with 7.5 gigawatts of new natural gas plants.

Keep reading...Show less
Blue