You’re out of free articles.
This Halloween, get 20% off using code ADVANCED
Log in
To continue reading, log in to your account.
Create a Free Account
To unlock more free articles, please create a free account.
Sign In or Create an Account.
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Welcome to Heatmap
Thank you for registering with Heatmap. Climate change is one of the greatest challenges of our lives, a force reshaping our economy, our politics, and our culture. We hope to be your trusted, friendly, and insightful guide to that transformation. Please enjoy your free articles. You can check your profile here .
subscribe to get Unlimited access
Offer for a Heatmap News Unlimited Access subscription; please note that your subscription will renew automatically unless you cancel prior to renewal. Cancellation takes effect at the end of your current billing period. We will let you know in advance of any price changes. Taxes may apply. Offer terms are subject to change.
Subscribe to get unlimited Access
Hey, you are out of free articles but you are only a few clicks away from full access. Subscribe below and take advantage of our introductory offer.
subscribe to get Unlimited access
Offer for a Heatmap News Unlimited Access subscription; please note that your subscription will renew automatically unless you cancel prior to renewal. Cancellation takes effect at the end of your current billing period. We will let you know in advance of any price changes. Taxes may apply. Offer terms are subject to change.
Create Your Account
Please Enter Your Password
Forgot your password?
Please enter the email address you use for your account so we can send you a link to reset your password:
Investor and philanthropist John Doerr shares a refresh to his Speed & Scale climate action tracker.

John Doerr thinks it’s time to refresh his grand plan for decarbonization. The Kleiner Perkins chairman and climate-focused philanthropist published his book Speed & Scale: An Action Plan for Solving Our Climate Crisis Now five years ago; then a year later, he introduced an online tracker to measure global progress across the book’s core objectives, which includes sectoral targets such as electrifying transport as well as execution-related goals that cut across all sectors such as winning on politics and policy and increasing investment investing.
But in the time since, both the world and the climate outlook have shifted significantly. So Doerr, alongside his co-author and advisor Ryan Panchadsaram, concluded that both the action plan and the metrics used to assess progress were due for a major revamp.
Heatmap got an exclusive look at the updated Speed & Scale tracker ahead of San Francisco Climate Week, where Doerr and Panchadsaram will unveil the new data and analytical framework underpinning this iteration. Designed to give budding entrepreneurs, business leaders, and policymakers a comprehensive view of where the world stands and how far it has to go in its fight against climate change, the tracker aims to help these stakeholders decide where to deploy their attention and capital.
Doerr told me the original plan has been a success in this regard. “We became convinced by the number of entrepreneurs, founders, technology experts and policy people who said, you know, that Speed & Scale plan influenced my decision about what to do — not how to do it, but what ought to really be done,” he said.
But Doerr is also well aware that we’re living in a different world now. “We had AI arrive and change the demand for electrical power, we have geopolitical forces that we’re trying to understand and cope with,” he told me. “And finally, there’s just the indomitable power of markets and price. All of which is to say, we can’t stick with a plan that’s five years old. It’s time to revise it.”
The updated plan preserves the six main objectives — electrify transportation, decarbonize the grid, fix food, protect nature, clean up industry, and remove carbon from the atmosphere — while including interim 2035 targets as well as 2050 targets aligned with a global net zero pathway. It also retains four other objectives on how to accelerate progress — that is, through politics and policy, turning movements into action, innovation, and investment. The team then breaks these 10 overarching priorities into subtargets called “key results,” in accordance with the goal-setting framework that Doerr famously introduced to Google in the late 1990s that has since become widely adopted across the tech industry.
While the key results in the original plan framed targets in percentage terms — for example, “increase EV sales to 50% of all new car sales by 2030” — the updated version uses absolute figures instead, such as “Increase the number of electric cars to over 600 million by 2035.” The idea, Panchadsaram told me, is to make the targets more tangible and thus easier to understand and act upon.
Another major change is the data that Speed & Scale uses to measure progress, which has altered the emissions picture significantly. Previously, the tracker relied on emissions estimates from the United Nations Environment Programme, but it’s since switched to data from the independent organization Climate TRACE, which combines satellite imagery, remote-sensing, and artificial intelligence to produce a more granular, point-source view of global emissions. The new data illuminated sources that have historically been undercounted, such as wildfire activity and methane leaks. This updated methodology indicates that annual emissions are about 74 gigatons a year, not the 59 gigatons that the old tracker had estimated using the UN’s numbers.
It was a shock for the team to see how drastically the topline figure changed with this new data, Panchadsaram told me, though it reinforced their notion that key results should usually represent gigaton-level opportunities for emissions abatement. But given that the world is still lagging across so many of these metrics, the Speed & Scale team no longer thinks it’s possible to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius, although they say staying under 2 degrees remains viable with increased ambition.
But it’s not all bad news. The updated tracker highlights six key results — out of 52 total — that the world is on track to meet. These include electric vehicle adoption and achieving cost parity with combustion cars, continued scaling of solar and wind generation, cost reductions for zero-emissions firm and variable power, and reducing operational emissions among Fortune Global 500 companies. There’s even one milestone that has already been reached — clean energy jobs now outnumber fossil fuel jobs, according to data from the International Energy Agency.
When I asked the duo whether they were surprised at where we’d managed to eke out climate wins, Panchadsaram told me, “I think we were right directionally on the technologies. Who ended up scaling them was probably the radical change.” For instance, Speed & Scale spent a lot of words on the electric bus manufacturer Proterra, a Kleiner Perkins-backed startup that filed for bankruptcy in 2023. At the same time, the book devoted just a few paragraphs to the Chinese automaker BYD, which surpassed Tesla in global sales last year.
Yet unfortunately and predictably, there is a lot of bad news to be found in this latest update, too. Seven key results are labeled “code red,” indicating focus areas individually responsible for over 3 gigatons of annual emissions where there’s been little to no progress. These include methane leaks, heating and cooling of buildings, livestock management, and the manufacture of steel and other industrial materials. Beyond this, the tracker is filled with categories where we’re making either “insufficient” progress or “failing,” with the latter indicating stagnation in areas where the impact is less than 3 gigatons per year.
Many of the “code red” results represent hard-to-abate sectors where decarbonization technologies don’t exist at scale, command a high green premium, or frequently both. This is a reality that Doerr and Panchadsaram are well aware of. “Our friend Al Gore always says, ‘We have all the technologies we need to get to where we need to go. All we need is more political will,’” Doerr told me. He thinks Gore is correct — to an extent. “We’ve got all the technologies we need to get us to 2030 or 2035. We don’t have all the innovation we need to get us to 2050.”
To get even more granular on the innovation imperatives most critical to the energy transition, the Speed & Scale team partnered with organizations including Breakthrough Energy, McKinsey, Stanford University’s Doerr School of Sustainability, and Elemental Impact to develop the Climate Tech Map, which I covered last year. In combination with the updated Speed & Scale plan, the map is designed to direct innovators toward key technological frontiers while also giving them a foundational grounding in the structure and challenges of these sectors.
Other updates to the tracker also reflect our changing political and market realities, with certain targets now recalibrated to align with current conditions. For instance, while the old tracker aimed to make climate a top-three voter issue, “we failed in achieving that objective,” Doerr told me. Climate messaging hasn’t proven to be a particularly salient issue for voters on either side of the aisle, and the updated tracker now sets what the team thinks is a more attainable benchmark — making climate a top-five issue.
Of course, even that is still quite a bold goal, as are most of the key results that Speed & Scale hope to achieve. But that’s the way it should be, Doerr said. “What was an opportunity has become an imperative, and so we have really got to step up our game and do it fast.”
This Halloween, get 20% off using code ADVANCED
Log in
To continue reading, log in to your account.
Create a Free Account
To unlock more free articles, please create a free account.
The company is attempting to commercialize a novel processing method, with the help of a former NRC commissioner.
If you were born the year the United States gave up on finding a place to store its spent nuclear fuel, you’d almost be eligible to vote. Since 2009, when the Obama administration halted work on Yucca Mountain, the Nevada site designated under federal law as the nation’s first nuclear waste repository, the country has had no formal plan in place.
Russia, France, China, and Japan all reprocess highly radioactive spent fuel that comes out of reactors to extract usable materials and recycle them into more fuel. The process still leaves behind some nasty, dangerous radioisotopes that form during fission, but there remains a lot less that needs to be stored for centuries. The U.S. attempted to set up a commercial nuclear recycling industry in the 1970s, before President Jimmy Carter pulled the plug as a sop to the nonproliferation movement. No one has really attempted to invest in the industry since.
Over the past decade, a new slate of startups has promised to revive the dream — or, to some, nightmare — of recycling spent fuel. The Biden administration put up funding. The Trump administration proposed “nuclear lifecycle campuses” where recycling would be just one part of future complexes that process, enrich, and reprocess reactor fuel, and dozens of states stepped up to serve as hosts. In a sign of growing momentum, one such company formed last year in Washington, D.C., with former Nuclear Regulatory Commission Chairman Chris Hanson as its head of implementation.
Now that company, Project Omega, has taken a big step toward actually commercializing its technology, Heatmap can exclusively report. The company submitted its “letter of intent” to the NRC, giving the agency a formal heads up that it plans to submit a full application within the next few years.
“Waste is the biggest challenge in the nuclear industry,” Staff Sheehan, Project Omega’s chief executive, told me. “We exist to take the amount of nuclear waste and the hazard of that nuclear waste and drastically decrease it.”
The NRC has, over the past year, ramped up efforts to streamline and modernize its regulatory process, and has greenlit permits for new reactors in record time. But the most successful applications have largely come from companies that carried out a lot of legwork with the NRC before submitting paperwork, so that the formal documents provide answers to questions the regulators expect to ask.
Since the NRC has never permitted or licensed a commercial nuclear reprocessing facility, companies are lining up to engage with the agency early. Oklo, the Silicon Valley startup seeking to deploy its own small modular reactors and reprocess the fuel its future power stations will run on, held a “pre-application meeting” with the NRC just last month. Curio, another Washington-based company specializing in nuclear waste reprocessing, submitted its letter of intent to the NRC in May.
Reprocessing, as a concept, draws fierce opposition from nonproliferation advocates who say the technology lays the groundwork for greater production of materials for bombs. Plutonium, which is used in some of the most powerful nuclear weapons, does not occur in nature, but forms during fission. The world’s only commercial nuclear recycling facilities, such as La Hague in France or the Mayak Production Association in Russia’s Ural Mountains, rely on a technology called aqueous reprocessing, which involves dissolving spent nuclear fuel in acid, then using a solvent to separate reusable uranium and plutonium from the other waste products. What little remains is then typically put into glass through a process called vitrification, which keeps the radiation from emanating, and stored long term. But the issue for policymakers and advocates seeking to thwart the growth of the world’s nuclear arsenal is that plutonium is among the key extracted materials.
Project Omega, by contrast, is pursuing an approach called pyroprocessing. Under that technology, developed in U.S. national laboratories and pursued by Oklo as well, spent fuel is chopped up and dunked in a bath of molten salt, often heated to temperatures around 930 degrees Fahrenheit. An electrical current then separates out useful materials, such as uranium and various isotopes that can be used for medical purposes.
“You can’t separate out pure plutonium, so you don’t get any streams that are usable for weapons,” Sheehan said. “That’s a big regulatory advantage, I would say.”
The biggest disadvantage, he admitted, is that nobody has tried to do pyroprocessing at scale. La Hague in France “has been operational for 50 years or something like that.”
“The disadvantage going in with a new technology is you have to educate regulators, and you have to get them comfortable with some of the novelties about it. It hasn’t been done before,” Sheehan said. “But the advantage of using a new technology is you can do things way more efficiently, way more safely, and way more economically.
Project Omega emerged from stealth back in February. Sheehan founded the company after leaving his previous startup, Air Company, where he had invented a novel process to convert carbon dioxide into hydrocarbons and alcohols that could be used for sustainable aviation fuel. Among the early hires to the new company was Hanson, whom President Donald Trump fired from the NRC last year in a dramatic show of control over an independent federal agency.
That doesn’t mean the company has faced the Trump administration’s wrath. Since then, Project Omega has won funding from the Department of Energy to carry out work at the Idaho National Laboratory and the U.S. military to conduct research with the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory. Last week, Project Omega raised $80 million in a Series A, pitching its reprocessing facilities as “nuclear refineries for the next industrial revolution.”
“I believe Project Omega is addressing one of the most critical gaps in our nuclear industrial base,” Tommy Hendrix, general partner at the venture firm Decisive Point, which invested in the Series A, told me over email. “Omega is taking a fundamentally different approach by transforming used nuclear fuel into valuable resources for advanced reactors and long-duration power systems.”
Asked whether he would pitch his company differently to Democrats, who traditionally opposed nuclear reprocessing and will command sizable majorities in Congress next year, Sheehan swiftly answered, “Not at all.”
“They call me the climate guy in all the circles I have walked in. Whether it was the White House under the Trump administration or D or R offices in Congress,” Sheehan said. “And I have a reputation for sticking to my guns.”
Current conditions: Tropical Cyclone Xavier has strengthened into a Category 5 storm after battering the Cook Islands with winds of up to 184 miles per hour • In the Bay of Bengal, Cyclone Akvan is barreling toward India’s Andhra Pradesh just weeks after the state suffered another deadly cyclone • Today is the last day of any sunlight in Utqiaġvik, Alaska, which enters polar night until January 23.
On Tuesday afternoon, Jensen Huang, Nvidia’s disgraced founder who stepped down from his chief executive role last week amid a ballooning scandal over his extramarital affairs with multiple employees and a Chinese spy, began mounting his comeback. “Nvidia is a once-in-a-generation company,” he wrote in a post on X. “If the Board of Directors decides that my return is in the best interest of our shareholders, our employees, the company, and America, I would be honored to answer these calls and return as CEO.” A new website launched late last week, purportedly built by some of the investors and supporters who have been blowing up Huang’s phone with encouragement in recent days, calls on the board to “stand with Jensen.” When the market closed yesterday evening, Huang’s camp got yet more ammunition to bring to the battle: The company doubled its earnings in the third quarter of this year compared to the same time last year, it reported Tuesday. The chip designer reported revenue of $116 billion for the three months that ended in October, a year-over-year increase of 103%, besting Wall Street’s estimates of $109 billion. The earnings may help quell concerns over the soaring debt hyperscalers are incurring to build out data centers, which, as I wrote last month, investors worry may not pay for itself.
The company also projected that its revenue would reach $130 billion for the fourth quarter, ahead of analysts’ bets, which seemingly puts the company — which the Financial Times described as “a bellwether for the health of the AI industry” — on a solid trajectory.
If the Senate voting overwhelmingly to advance the bipartisan permitting reform bill was supposed to help put an end to the Trump administration’s targeting of the offshore wind industry, it hasn’t yet. On Tuesday, Bloomberg reported that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has started to reassess a permit for EDF REnewables North America’s Atlantic Shores South project, which would total as many as 200 wind turbines sited roughly 9 miles off the coast of Atlantic City. The move fits a pattern. Despite the Trump administration’s promise to ease its blockade on renewables as part of negotiations over the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, my colleagues Jael Holzman and Emily Pontecorvo reported last month that the only projects advancing were upgrades to existing wind farms.
Speaking of Trump, on a trip to China for a trilateral summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, the president waved off the national anxiety piqued by a string of major network outages across the U.S., one of which being the National Security Agency’s highly classified communications channels, according to CNN. “It’s life,” he said. “When you're big and powerful and have all the money, things like that happen — it’s fine.”

General Motors made history in December 2013 when it named Mary Barra, previously the company’s executive in charge of supply chains and human resources, as the first woman to lead one of the automotive industry’s big manufacturers. Now GM has begun the search to succeed its longest-serving leader in modern times. While the company is “eyeing a crop of internal candidates,” The Wall Street Journal reported Tuesday, it’s working with a headhunting firm to identify outside contenders. Barra herself, whose tenure is about twice that of an average chief executive at a S&P 500 company, kicked off the process months ago. Among the internal contenders, named by the Journal are “finance chief Paul Jacobson; Sterling Anderson, a high-profile Silicon Valley hire who serves as Chief Product Officer; and Mark Reuss, a 40-year GM veteran and Barra’s No. 2.”
GM’s next top dog will grapple with the company’s evolving battery business. As Heatmap contributor Andrew Moseman wrote last year, Trump’s elimination of the electric vehicle tax credit cost GM $1.6 billion. But it also gave rise to a new standalone battery business that Kurt Kelty, the former Panasonic executive and current GM battery guru, told my colleague Robinson Meyer on our Shift Key podcast, might just turn GM into an “American battery juggernaut.”
Sign up to receive Heatmap AM in your inbox every morning:
Researchers at Harvard University on Monday released a landmark study breaking down carbon emissions linked to U.S. data center operations, concluding that grid-connected data center operations were linked to more greenhouse gas pollution from May 2024 to April 2025 than the entire country of Denmark. That would be interesting on its own, and yet it’s also likely that number is a serious lowball. Gianluca Guidi, lead author of the study, told Heatmap that the research only accounted for data centers attached to the power grid, meaning it doesn’t take into account diesel generators or behind-the-meter power plants. “It does show how incomplete our understanding remains because the numbers are quite sizable and policy is quite lagging behind,” Guidi said. “We’re still struggling to imagine the environmental consequences of the infrastructure that’s already been built.” — Jael Holzman
Quaise Energy has locked down the first customer for its futuristic approach to vaporizing stone and drilling deep into hot rocks for geothermal power. Conveniently, it is also one of the deepest-pocketed and most sophisticated energy buyers on the market today. On Tuesday, The Wall Street Journal broke the news that Google has signed a power purchase agreement for 50 megawatts of electricity from Quaise’s Project Obsidian, its flagship first plant in Central Oregon and the world’s first superhot geothermal plant, operating with rocks at temperatures greater than 572 degrees Fahrenheit. The project, expected to come online as early as 2030, is on track to cost about $350 million. “Google is officially our first customer at Quaise Energy,” Kathryn Hite de Sousa, Quaise’s chief operating officer, wrote in a post on LinkedIn. “With our millimeter wave drilling technology, we are bringing superhot geothermal to commercial scale, so we can deliver always-on, zero-carbon power to the grid from anywhere on Earth.”
The market is clearly down with VPPs — in a good way. The capacity of North America’s virtual power plants grew by nearly 26% this year compared to 2025, reaching 47.2 gigawatts of behind-the-meter flexible capacity, according to a new analysis by Wood Mackenzie. “Escalating turbine costs, affordability concerns, and slow supply response to large loads are driving more interest in VPPs,” Elham Akhavan, principal analyst at the consultancy, said in a statement. Residential VPPs alone more than doubled.
Proposed changes to the National Historic Preservation Act risk disturbing the fragile relationship between the U.S. and Native governments.
In spite of some loud voices both for and against it, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act has so far cruised through the Senate. That could change as soon as today as lawmakers begin to consider amendments ahead of a final vote.
One of the main outstanding issues is how the bill’s changes to the National Historic Preservation Act would affect tribal sovereignty. Nevada Senator Catherine Cortez Masto, a Democrat, warned before the initial motion to proceed on the proposed legislation last week that she would not vote for the final bill unless lawmakers struck that section entirely. Since then, nearly 30 Democrats have signed onto an amendment proposed by California Senator Adam Schiff that would do just that.
One of the lead authors of BAAJA, Democrat Martin Heinrich of New Mexico, has dismissed this approach, arguing it would forfeit Republican support. On Tuesday, Punchbowl News reported that Senate Indian Affairs Committee Chair Lisa Murkowski, a Republican, was working on a more targeted amendment with Democrat Brian Schatz. Republican senator Alan Armstrong of Oklahoma has also reportedly sought changes to the bill that would clarify some of the language without stripping it.
The debate over the NHPA primarily concerns a process known as a Section 106 review. Under current statute and regulations, federal agencies are required to consult with state and tribal historic preservation offices before funding or approving projects that stand to affect cultural resources such as sacred spaces, burial grounds, and ceremonial sites. Altering this process is emotionally charged because it is one of few federal mechanisms through which the U.S. government recognizes and gives shape to tribes’ sovereign status.
Proponents of permitting reform complain that the Section 106 process takes too long, however, as there are no deadlines built into either the law or the regulations designed to implement it, and the tribal offices involved often have limited financial and staff capacity. The process is especially lengthy for linear projects like power lines, pipelines, and highways, which typically cross multiple jurisdictions that each have their own preservation offices.
Consultation is not the same as the notice and comment periods that accompany most federal decisionmaking, in which the government gives the public a set amount of time to submit a response and often has a duty to explain why it did or did not incorporate the comments it received. Tribal consultation, by contrast, is “a meaningful dialogue that is intended to resolve differences,” according to Wesley Furlong, a senior staff attorney for the Native American Rights Fund, “It doesn't have to resolve them,” he said, “but the purpose of it is to try to resolve differences when possible.”
BAAJA lays out a new Section 106 review process with fewer opportunities for this dialogue and stricter time limits each step of the way. It also gives agencies broad discretion to determine that a project doesn’t have the potential to cause any effects to historic properties before conducting any public process at all, and thereby forgo NHPA review altogether.
If an agency decides a project does qualify for a review, it must put together a comprehensive report that defines the project’s “area of potential effects,” identifies historic properties within that area, and describes any adverse effects the project may have on those properties. Under the existing statute, those three activities are distinct processes that each require consultation. Under BAAJA, they would be lumped together, with a mandate for agencies to “solicit information” from tribes and tribal historic preservation offices in developing this report. Stakeholders would have just 30 days to respond.
To Furlong, this is equivalent to cutting tribes out of the process. “Generally, soliciting information from a tribe and then either incorporating it or not into a report is not consultation,” he told me.
The next step would require consultation, at least in theory. BAAJA gives agencies 60 days to complete their report, at which point they would have to “initiate consultation” with preservation offices. Tribes would then have 45 days to raise any objections to the report’s findings, but if they miss the deadline, the agency can proceed to make a determination without their participation. If there are objections, the agency would have 30 days to respond and explain how it considered them.
Alternatively, the federal government could forge an agreement with the relevant preservation offices that lays out how the project will avoid adverse effects to historic properties, but it is not required to do so. So long as the agency simply provides a response to objections, its consultation obligations “shall be considered fulfilled,” the bill says.
Even though the bill nominally requires consultation, Furlong argued, the deadlines and procedure it describes don’t support meaningful dialogue. “The idea that handing off a report in a final draft version and asking for comments on it, and then saying, ‘Well, we don't actually have to consider your comments’ — to say that that is consultation is a real affront to Indian country,” he said.
An earlier version of the bill contained a more extreme provision that would have given the Interior Department the authority to take over a tribal historic preservation office if it was out of compliance with the law — i.e. failing to meet deadlines or other required metrics. To some Native critics of the legislation, the provision echoed the termination era, a period in the 1950s and 1960s when the U.S. enacted a series of policies to roll back tribes’ rights to self-governance. The current version of the bill moves away from that, requiring the department instead to offer technical assistance and give time for tribes to come back into compliance. It does still allow the Department to take away the office’s funding, however.
To Ira Matt, the executive director of the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Offices, any changes made to the NHPA without tribe involvement are unacceptable. “What began as a termination-era approach of cutting tribal nations out has shifted to an assimilation-era tactic of telling us how and when we can participate, what matters to our cultures, and which harms we must accept,” he wrote in a memo to the association’s members.
Tribes generally support of permitting reform, Mayane Chavez Barudin, the executive director of the nonprofit Sovereign Energy, told me. But she told me this legislation misses the mark. “There is no doubt that tribes are understaffed, and there is a huge demand on them to be responsive to all of the different projects and different permits that need attention,” she said. “Rather than trying to work with tribes and meeting their needs, we see this as just completely sidestepping them in a very harmful way.”
The bill does authorize $200 million per year to be divided between state and tribal preservation offices, which is more than they have received in most recent years. But that is not the same as a commitment to actually appropriate that money, Furlong pointed out to me. Congress would still have to put the money into the Historic Preservation Fund every year in order for it to be made available.
The other major change the bill would make to the NHPA is that it would bar courts from issuing injunctions on projects or vacating permits if agencies do not follow the law. If a federal court found that an agency failed to consider an eligible historic site, for example, the court’s only available remedy would be to instruct the agency to correct the deficiencies on paper. It would not be able to order the agency to halt the project’s construction. BAAJA also makes the same change to the National Environmental Policy Act. Some legal scholars have argued that this change effectively renders both laws toothless, as it removes a powerful incentive to challenge agency decisions, and therefore weakens the incentive for agencies to conduct thorough reviews.
“If litigants know that courts can never grant them meaningful relief, there would be little incentive to ever bring another NEPA case,” David Tatel, a retired judge for the U.S. Court of Appeals for D.C. Circuit, wrote in a recent piece for Bloomberg Law. “And without the potential for litigation, there would be little constraint on agencies and project sponsors that would prefer not to consider environmental consequences and not to hear the public’s views.”
A group of western Democrats led by California Senator Alex Padilla have proposed an amendment to the bill that would exempt claims brought by tribal governments from this limit on judicial review under NHPA. Such a fix would be awkward, however, as it raises the question of why the same exemption shouldn’t apply to tribal NEPA claims.
BAAJA proponents argue that the Trump administration is already proposing sweeping changes to the federal regulations that govern how agencies implement the NHPA that would strip tribal consultation in more explicit ways than this bill does, and that BAAJA would protect consultation by enshrining it in law. When I put this to Furlong, he did not agree that the draft regulations were worse than what was in the bill, and noted that at least regulations could be challenged in court or changed by a future administration. “Even if this permitting reform bill was theoretically better, it will become law, and that is permanent, and the only way that can change is if Congress amends it,” he said.
To be clear, the NHPA is not the only section of the bill that critics say impinges on tribal sovereignty. “Many tribes retain off-reservation treaty-reserved rights, whether it's hunting, fishing, gathering,” Daniel Cordalis, a staff attorney at the Native America Rights Fund, told me. They rely on NEPA, the Endangered Species Act, and the Clean Water Act to assert those rights. The Clean Water Act’s Section 401 certification process, for example, enables tribes to protect their water from upstream polluters. BAAJA “significantly narrowed the way the tribes can engage in that now,” Cordalis said.
To some, the way BAAJA was negotiated violates the precarious trust between tribes and the U.S. government, regardless of what is actually in the bill. The four authors of the bill — Senators Martin Heinrich and Sheldon Whitehouse on the Democrat side, and Mike Lee and Shelley Moore Capito on the Republican side — brokered it behind closed doors, without any of the hearings, committee markups, or reports typical to the lawmaking process. An October 23 letter from dozens of indigenous-led nonprofits and their allies called the exclusion of tribes from the development of the legislation “unacceptable” and stated that “Congress should not rewrite the processes through which sovereign tribe governments defend their cultural survival without their meaningful involvement from the outset of legislative drafting.”
Despite all of this, not all indigenous-led groups are advocating for Congress to reject BAAJA. The National Tribal Energy Association and the Apsåalooke Nation/Crow Tribe both submitted letters of support for the bill. The Coalition of Large Tribes, an advocacy group representing 12 tribes with large land bases, submitted a “discussion paper” offering a series of redlines “necessary to protect tribal sovereignty.” The National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Offices is calling for the removal of the NHPA section of the bill “so Congress can start over with a process that includes tribe consultation.”
As of now, even the more targeted fixes submitted by the Coalition of Large Tribes look unlikely. The amendment filed by Senators Murkowski and Schatz on Tuesday would make one small change, ensuring that all projects that receive federal funding go through NHPA reviews instead of just those that also require some form of federal approval.
While Murkowski suggested that the text of their amendment was still in flux, NHPA-related concerns may not constitute a real threat to the bill’s passage in the Senate. The most recent procedural vote saw 70 senators agree to advance the bill, and many of the lawmakers advocating for NHPA-related changes — Cortez-Masto, Schiff, Padilla, Mark Kelly, and others — were not among them.