Sign In or Create an Account.

By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy

Electric Vehicles

EVs Are About to Break the Way America Pays for Roads

The gas tax pays for America’s road repair. So what do we do when everyone drives EVs?

•
A hundred dollar bill as a gas pump.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Electric cars may help the United States fix its carbon problem, but they’re about to break the way America pays for its roads.

Every gallon of gas Americans buy is taxed to pay for highway improvements and other infrastructure projects. The federal government takes about 18 cents per gallon of gas (and 24 cents for diesel), while the states, on average, charge even more.

EVs escape this tax. As the Biden Administration pushes for the majority of American cars to go electric within a decade, the nation needs a new way to fund road repairs. That is why all of us, whether we drive gasoline, hybrid, or electric, soon could be taxed on the number of miles we drive.

A vehicle miles traveled (VMT) tax has become a hot idea for replacing the gas tax in the age of electric vehicles. Federal laws — including the Surface Transportation System Funding Alternatives (STSFA) program and the 2021 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (as known as the Bipartisan Infrastructure Bill) — have even included money for states to run VMT pilot programs.

Economists and policymakers love VMT for a variety of reasons. Most importantly, says Adam Hoffer, director of excise tax policy at the nonprofit Tax Foundation, this approach creates a “universal toll road” where people who use the roads the most also pay the most for their upkeep.

“Gas taxes have worked really well as the best proxy for this for almost a hundred years now,” Hoffer told me. “What we're seeing is that with electric vehicles growing in market share, we need a new tool. Vehicle miles traveled taxes seem to fit that bill really well.”

Clifford Winston, a senior fellow in economic studies at the Brookings Institution, says another key advantage is that a VMT is customizable. “It has economically desirable features that go beyond generating the revenue that would be lost as the vehicle fleet turns over from internal combustion engines to EVs,” he says.

The tax could simply charge every vehicle the same number of cents per mile. On the other hand, the government could also adjust the cost up or down to incentivize good behaviors. For example, it could charge people less per mile if they drive EVs (and more if they stick with a gas-guzzler). It could put in congestion surcharges to tempt people to avoid rush hour, or charge trucking companies based on how much weight they’re hauling down the highway.

Winston’s version of VMT is an economist’s dream where price drives every choice. He compares it to the experience of calling an Uber or Lyft, where users are presented with several options at different price points. Now, he says, imagine the same scenario when you slide into your own car and enter a destination. The vehicle’s display could show you several routes with not only different driving times, but also different charges based on distance, congestion fees, or other factors.

There are downsides to this plan, of course, and not just that people may hate its complexity. Lots of folks have no choice but to drive during rush hour, and many can’t afford to replace an older car to take advantage of lower taxes on a new EV.

Privacy is the big one, Hoffer says. If drivers are charged a flat fee per mile, they would need to report their odometer reading to the taxman. A dynamic pricing scheme could be even more intrusive, requiring a way to track us everywhere, all the time.

The simplest way to confront this issue, Winston says, is to set up a third party so the government doesn’t have all this tracking data at its fingerprints. “A private company collects all this [information], sends it to the vehicle owner monthly, and says, here's your bill. Pay it,” he says. According to Hoffer, drivers already hand over this data when they sign up for car insurance programs like Progressive’s “Snapshot” that charge people based on how they drive. However, he says, privacy law around these issues is far from clear.

“There have been court cases before where lawyers have used real-time tracking data from these kinds of apps in lawsuits against people,” he says. “I think there are real questions about whether this data could be accessible via a warrant.”

There are less intrusive ways to replace the gas tax. Some states have begun to charge higher annual registration fees for electric cars to make up for the fact that they don’t burn gasoline. But a flat fee is a blunt instrument that can’t account for how far people drive. It also discourages EV sales.

An obvious replacement for taxing gas by the gallon would be to tax electricity by the kilowatt-hour. But you can’t really replicate the old system. While it may sound simple to tax fast-charging stations, lots of EV drivers do most of their charging at home. The electricity specifically used to charge a car is mixed in with the juice they use to run the dishwasher or the AC, making it hard to differentiate (not to mention that residential electricity is already taxed).

VMT may be the most logical solution to the gas tax problem, Hoffer says, but there are still plenty of bugs to work out. States currently running pilot programs, led by California and Oregon, are experimenting with how to practically implement the fee and how much it should be. It’s possible, Hoffer says, that a VMT will exist alongside the gasoline tax, at least while the U.S. car fleet goes through its transformation from gas to electric.

“I don’t see rapid adoption nationwide of a vehicle mile travel system — but I do think it is on the inevitable side of things,” he says.


Get the best of Heatmap right in your inbox:

Green
Black Friday Sale

You’ve read your free article. Keep reading with a Heatmap membership

Take 25% off any plan with code THANKS.
Standard Plan
Member

Everything Heatmap publishes, plus a seat in the room.

$129
$97 /year
  • Unlimited access. Every story and newsletter, with no paywall.
  • Virtual briefings. Live sessions with our reporters.
  • Happy hours and events. Member gatherings throughout the year.
Premium Plan
Supporter

For readers who want to keep the journalism going

$349
$262 /year
  • Everything in Member, plus:
  • Exclusive polling access. Heatmap's climate comms polling.
  • VIP at Heatmap House. A reception ticket, plus a membership to gift.
To continue reading
Create a free account or sign in to unlock more free articles.
or
Please enter an email address
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Politics

The Permitting Bill’s Next Battleground

After passing the Senate, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act faces yet another test in the House.

The House of Representatives and power lines.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

On Thursday night, the Senate passed the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, a controversial bill that would revise federal environmental and energy laws to enable faster permitting of power lines, power plants, and other infrastructure.

Now the bill heads to the House, where three questions will determine its fate: How many Republicans will show up to vote? What will Hakeem Jeffries do? And if it lands on Trump’s desk, what amendments will come with it?

Keep reading...Show less
Spotlight

The Freakout Over the Data Center Loophole That Wasn’t

How a last minute proposal to amend the permitting bill set off panic in Washington

The Capitol.
Heatmap Illustration/Getty Images

Call it the data center loophole that wasn’t – and the beginning of a new kind of whiplash in energy and tech.

For roughly 48 hours, many souls in Washington D.C. were quietly panicking that the Senate permitting bill’s strongest policy against data centers was about to be weakened. On Tuesday, senators released new changes to the manager’s amendment to the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act addressing issues holdouts on the bill raised about tribal consultation. Included in those modifications however was another change: Senators added language to the bill’s landmark ratepayer protection provision we’ve written about exempting new classes of facilities providing “Internet access” or “information services” as defined under two of the few federal tech statutes on the books.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow
The Q&A subject.
Heatmap Illustration

This week’s conversation is with Natasha DeJarnett, an assistant professor at the University of Louisville in Kentucky who previously was deputy director for environmental justice data and evaluation in the Biden White House’s Council on Environmental Quality.

After the 2026 midterm elections it’s safe to say data centers are the new political punching bag – but an irony in this is how fights over these projects closely resemble the very same environmental justice conversations that were front and center under Biden. Like many of us in energy and environment professions, DeJarnett didn’t expect to be working on data centers, until she started being invited to communities fighting these projects to provide her perspective and public health expertise. She’s since become one of the go-to voices from the previous administration when it comes to data center conflicts and community relationships.

Keep reading...Show less
Yellow