You’re out of free articles.
This Halloween, get 20% off using code ADVANCED
Log in
To continue reading, log in to your account.
Create a Free Account
To unlock more free articles, please create a free account.
Sign In or Create an Account.
By continuing, you agree to the Terms of Service and acknowledge our Privacy Policy
Welcome to Heatmap
Thank you for registering with Heatmap. Climate change is one of the greatest challenges of our lives, a force reshaping our economy, our politics, and our culture. We hope to be your trusted, friendly, and insightful guide to that transformation. Please enjoy your free articles. You can check your profile here .
subscribe to get Unlimited access
Offer for a Heatmap News Unlimited Access subscription; please note that your subscription will renew automatically unless you cancel prior to renewal. Cancellation takes effect at the end of your current billing period. We will let you know in advance of any price changes. Taxes may apply. Offer terms are subject to change.
Subscribe to get unlimited Access
Hey, you are out of free articles but you are only a few clicks away from full access. Subscribe below and take advantage of our introductory offer.
subscribe to get Unlimited access
Offer for a Heatmap News Unlimited Access subscription; please note that your subscription will renew automatically unless you cancel prior to renewal. Cancellation takes effect at the end of your current billing period. We will let you know in advance of any price changes. Taxes may apply. Offer terms are subject to change.
Create Your Account
Please Enter Your Password
Forgot your password?
Please enter the email address you use for your account so we can send you a link to reset your password:
Let’s play out what could happen as the House Ways and Means Committee does its work.

One of the most important fights over the Inflation Reduction Act’s survival has finally arrived. But it’s not playing out in the open. It’s happening behind the closed doors of a powerful House committee in charge of tax policy.
The House Ways and Means Committee is writing its version of Republicans’ budget reconciliation bill, the centerpiece of President Donald Trump’s legislative agenda. The committee could release that text as soon as mid-May. And other than a few broad outlines — the text will extend Trump’s tax cuts for the wealthy, and it will increase the deficit by no more than $2.8 trillion — nobody has any idea what it will say.
Whatever the final text, though, will give us the first real sense of how likely the Inflation Reduction Act’s tax credits are to survive in the Trump tax bill. After months of speculation and tea leaf-reading, the House Ways and Means Committee’s draft will represent an opening position of sorts for Republican leadership — and illustrate just how close to repeal the majority is willing to get.
The committee could take a scorched-earth approach, cutting essentially every IRA tax credit in order to force members to fight to get policies back into the final bill. Or it could reform some tax credits so significantly that it effectively repeals the IRA, even if many policies remain on the books.
It could also reform some credits — such as the electric vehicle and clean electricity tax credits — while leaving most others untouched.
The most important suggestion of what will be in the final version came on Thursday in a new letter addressed to Jason Smith, the Ways and Means Committee chairman, and signed by 38 House Republicans. The letter demands the IRA’s full repeal — essentially heralding a potential new “anti-IRA” caucus within the GOP.
“We are deeply concerned that President Trump’s commitment to restoring American energy dominance and ending what he calls the ’‘green new scam’ is being undermined by parochial interests and short-sighted political calculations,” the letter says.
The letter writers focus their ire on subsidies for “wind and biofuel[s] … carbon capture and hydrogen … [and] solar and electric vehicles” that they say form the backbone of the bill.
So far, House Republicans have largely written letters about the IRA to call for its preservation. Last summer, 18 House Republicans wrote to Speaker of the House Mike Johnson to ask him to move gingerly around any “repeal or reform” of the tax credits should Republicans win the November election.
“We must reverse the policies which refine American families while protecting and refining those that are making our country more energy independent and America more energy secure,” the letter said.
Since then, the number of pro-IRA voices in the GOP has risen. Last month, 21 House Republicans wrote to Johnson again in support of the law. But their language was slightly changed, advising that any reforms proceed in a “targeted and pragmatic fashion.” They did, however, oppose “premature credit phase outs” or restrictions on transferability.
Speaking earlier this week at a Semafor event, the Illinois Republican and Ways and Means member Darin LaHood imagined phasing out some of the energy tax credits earlier.
“The approach we’'re looking at now is how you have an appropriate ramp-down [of IRA tax credits] that allows for businesses and companies to continue to be active in this space, but also saves money," LaHood said.
He added that there is a “bullseye” on the clean energy law, and said that “we’ll see” whether any of its provisions are preserved.
Whatever form the final law takes, this legislative vehicle will likely determine the fate of the IRA’s energy tax credits and other climate spending. Trump has lambasted the IRA, and some Republicans believe that its tax credits should be repealed to pay for their tax cuts for wealthy earners.
Ways and Means will not automatically control the final product. Ultimately, they will have to reconcile their version of the text with what’s written by their counterpart, the Senate Finance Committee. Other committees will oversee the IRA’s environmental grants and loans. (My colleague Emily Pontecorvo wrote about the first markup — from the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee — on Tuesday.) But the Senate has a more forgiving budget target than the House does, which means the Ways and Means Committee is where the IRA could go to die. That’s because it oversees tax policy — and therefore manages the IRA’s all-important tax credits.
The committee also has a spending problem. The legislative process Republicans have chosen to pass their budget bill, known as reconciliation, begins with establishing binding spending limits for committees in both the House and the Senate. That process wrapped up last month.
Under the guidelines passed by the House earlier this year, the Ways and Means Committee can expand the deficit by as much as $4.5 trillion. But simply extending the 2017 tax cuts’ expiring provisions will cost $4.4 trillion — and the committee wants to do more besides, including expanding the deductions that people can claim for their local and state taxes. The committee will struggle to pay for everything it wants to do — and it could look to repealing parts of the IRA to fix it.
It doesn’t help that Representative Jason Smith of Missouri, the Ways and Means chairman, has called the IRA “welfare for the wealthy and well-connected.”
The committee’s conservative bent — and the fact that GOP lawmakers broadly want to stay on track to pass a bill by the end of the summer — mean that the IRA tax cuts are especially vulnerable during this period.
Most of the IRA’s tax credits are due to sunset in 2032. But one measure — a technology-neutral credit to support new clean electricity generation — could run for much longer than that.
Under the law as it stands today, that credit is supposed to last until the United States eliminates much of the greenhouse gas emissions produced by its power grid as compared to 2022 levels. Even if the credit remains in place, that could take another 30 or 40 years to happen, by one estimate — making the tech-neutral tax credit one of the most important climate policies in the law. The IRA’s power sector policies are responsible for more than 80% of the law’s emissions-reducing impact.
That also makes it among the most expensive policies in the law. When Republicans talk about ending tax credits early, the tech-neutral tax credit is an obvious target. Two lawmakers from North Dakota — Representative Julie Fedorchak and Senator Kevin Cramer — are working on language to phase out some tax credits in five years, Axios Pro has reported.
That would shut down the credit by 2030. But ending the credit by then could reshape what kind of energy technologies the law supports. Republicans tend not to see all zero-carbon electricity equally — while they often champion nuclear and advanced geothermal generation, many look less favorably on wind and solar power.
But by terminating the tech-neutral tax credit at the end of the decade, Republicans could help essentially the very technologies they don’t want. There are no new nuclear or geothermal projects in the development pipeline across the country, and new ones are unlikely to crop up until the late 2020s at the earliest. Under the law, energy projects must be “placed in service” by the time a tax credit expires, meaning that virtually no new nuclear or geothermal projects could qualify.
New nuclear projects will face especially serious trouble if the Trump administration guts the Department of Energy’s in-house bank, the Loan Programs Office, as now seems likely.
At the same time, there are plenty of new solar and battery projects planned across the country. Developers of these projects could rush to get them into service before a potential 2029 sunset date. The industry even has experience hurrying projects to completion: It often had to do so during the 2010s, when the solar investment tax credit faced repeated expirations.
Other Republicans have suggested terminating the law’s transferability clause. Under the IRA as it stands today, companies can sell their tax credits to other firms that can better use the subsidy. Depending on how it’s implemented, that reform could hurt the IRA by reducing the value of its tax credits, because companies will have to adopt more complicated financial structures in order to claim a given subsidy. Historically, solar and wind developers have more experience adopting these arcane structures than the nuclear or geothermal industries, which have fewer projects under their belt.
Speaking at a Heatmap event on Thursday, Republican Senator John Curtis of Utah said he was still hopeful that the IRA would survive without significant cuts.
“I don’t think that makes it through the House,” he said when asked if the Ways and Means Committee could slash the IRA tax credits outright. “There’s a lot of insecurities in the Republican Party about not cutting and about where the boundaries are.”
We’ll have a much better sense of where those boundaries are soon.
Editor’s note: Updates to reflect Ways and Means delaying its markup.
This Halloween, get 20% off using code ADVANCED
Log in
To continue reading, log in to your account.
Create a Free Account
To unlock more free articles, please create a free account.
The startup says its “new physics” will make America’s critical minerals processing cheaper, cleaner, and — most importantly — more competitive with China.
If General Flash has it right, America may have a new way to refine nearly every critical metal it now buys from China.
The Cambridge, Massachusetts-based startup emerged from stealth Tuesday with $128 million in combined seed and Series A funding from Lux Capital, Lowercarbon Capital, Overmatch Ventures, Construct Capital, and others. The MIT spinout is pioneering “new physics,” its founder and CEO, Ric Fulop, told me, which allows it to refine metal oxides into high-purity metals using an electrolytic process that produces no direct emissions. The company has already broken ground on its first commercial facility, a 1,000-metric-ton per year plant in Massachusetts that Fulop said will begin production next summer.
If the technology delivers on its promise, it could greatly reduce U.S. dependence on China for metals such as tungsten, titanium, tantalum, zirconium, and rare earths — materials used throughout semiconductor, defense, aerospace and advanced manufacturing supply chains. Although many of these minerals are mined around the world, China controls more than 80% of global refining capacity for some of them.
“Usually metals refining is not a very clean industry,” Fulop told me. “Maybe that’s one of the reasons that we looked the other way when China started taking a lot of market share in the space in the last 20 years.”
General Flash’s process, which the company calls “solid-state flash electrolysis,” works by subjecting heated metal oxide powders to intense electrical fields. This pushes the material into what Fulop described as “a metastable state,” between a solid and a liquid. In this unusual state, oxygen atoms diffuse out of the powder much faster than they would under normal conditions, aided by applied heat and electricity, leaving behind pure metal.
The underlying insight behind this approach came from Fulop’s earlier work as a research scientist at MIT’s Center for Bits and Atoms, where he studied the physics of flash sintering, an oxide densification technique. This involves heating metal or oxide powders under extreme electric fields to accelerate the movement of atoms within the solid. He and his team realized that the same technique that made these atoms move so quickly could similarly accelerate the removal of oxygen from metal oxide powders.
This breakthrough could offer an alternative to molten salt electrolysis, China’s dominant method for refining some of the metals General Flash wants to work with, including rare earths. While this is an established technique, it only works for a limited range of materials as molten salts are corrosive and the process often introduces contaminants and triggers unwanted side reactions. By contrast, Fulop said solid state flash electrolysis “allows us to, in a continuous process, achieve much better throughput and economics than the molten process, and with much lower capex and a higher purity product on the other side of that.”
Still, General Flash only tackles one link in a supply chain that, in many instances, still largely runs through China. Rare earths and tungsten, for example, are still mainly mined and processed into purified metal oxides in China. And many of these metals’ end products, like the rare earth magnets used in motors or missiles, are also made in China.
But the opportunity to bring refining back to the U.S. is still substantial, and any number of climate tech entrepreneurs are trying to lasso it. For his part, General Flash is hardly Fulop’s first rodeo. According to a MIT Technology Review profile, the Venezuela-born entrepreneur got his start at the tender age of 16, selling imported computer hardware and software to retailers in his home country. He later dropped out of college and went on to found a string of companies. These include lithium-ion battery maker A123 Systems, which he co-founded with MIT professor Yet-Ming Chiang in 2001, and metal 3D-printing company Desktop Metal, which he started alongside a group of MIT professors in 2015.
Both companies reached $1 billion-plus valuations before eventually filing for bankruptcy. But their spectacular rises and subsequent falls don’t appear to have soured Fulop on entrepreneurship — or MIT on Fulop. He now sits on the visiting committee of MIT’s Department of Materials Science and Engineering, with General Flash as his latest effort to turn MIT-born technology into a commercial venture. Fulop told me the startup’s growing team is, at the moment, “pretty much all physics people from Harvard, MIT, and Princeton.”
The company currently operates a 20-metric-ton per year pilot facility near MIT, and is “supporting the Department of War in what they need,” Fulop told me. China tightened export controls on rare earth metals last year in response to Trump’s tariff policies, disrupting supplies to U.S. defense contractors that once sourced these materials on the open market. Fulop declined to elaborate, however, on the company’s specific military tie-ups, potential contracts, or other prospective customers.
It doesn’t seem as if there will be any shortage of demand. Because General Flash’s end product is simply a high purity metal, it could sell into any established commodity market, such as the London Metal Exchange. Initially, though, it’s targeting customers that put a premium on domestically refined materials — particularly those facing supply-chain risks tied to China.
Fulop sees it as a straightforward proposition. As it stands, “we are making things that are used that we have to import from people that don’t like us,” he told me. General Flash’s whole goal, he said, is to “make it so that we are self dependent.”
Current conditions: A storm is brewing over the Pacific Ocean that could dump 2 to 3 feet of snow on California’s Donner Pass later this week • Cyclone Akvan is intensifying in the Bay of Bengal, putting the storm on track to make landfall over India’s Andhra Pradesh by Friday • The Northern Cook Islands, one of the two chains of atolls that comprise the eponymous South Pacific nation, are bracing for Tropical Cyclone Xavier to hit this week as a Category 2 storm with damaging winds.
The Department of Energy has issued its seventh emergency order to keep the coal-fired J.H. Campbell plant in West Olive, Michigan, running past its planned retirement. Late on Friday, the agency reupped its directive under Section 202 of the Federal Power Act mandating that the facility, owned primarily by the utility Consumers Energy, stay open to prevent blackouts on the Midcontinent Independent System Operator, the nation’s largest grid. The move, Utility Dive noted Monday, follows a September federal appeals court decision vacating a previous emergency order to keep Campbell running, which it said cut against state authority over what kinds of resources generate electricity within their borders.
Last week, Ontario Power Generation admitted that North America’s first small modular reactor, the GE Vernova Hitachi Nuclear Energy BWRX-300 the state-owned utility is building at its Darlington plant, is already behind schedule and over budget. We’ll have to wait until the middle of next year to find out just how badly the delays will sting. In a post last week on LinkedIn, which NucNet surfaced Monday, OPG President Nicolle Butcher said the company was evaluating just how much time and money the project would take. “This updated budget and schedule will be informed by a comprehensive assessment that is now underway; an assessment that will take time, because it is important we get it right,” she wrote. “We expect it to be substantially complete by mid-2027 and will share further updates as additional information becomes available.”

“Do we call it BAH-zhuh or BAY-zhuh?” you ask. “So we’re not just going with BAH-hah?” your colleague chimes in. “Aren’t we having a BAAJA Blast?” Yet while you (ahem, I) joke about how to refer to the federal legislation that has taken on an all-encompassing role in some Americans’ politics of late, normal people are saying things more like “What the hell are you talking about” and “What do you mean by permitting reform” and “Sir, does that mean you want the specialty Mountain Dew with your Wendy’s order or … ?” That is the sobering takeaway from the latest polling released by Data for Progress. At least 65% of all U.S. voters reported hearing “nothing at all” about the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, the legislation to overhaul federal permitting on energy infrastructure. Among the minority of voters who say they know what the bill is, just 18% correctly identified that it would “make it easier to approve energy and infrastructure projects.” By contrast, 37% said it would “expand job training and apprenticeship programs for American workers” and 21% said it would “cut taxes for American households and small businesses.”
“For all the hand-wringing and hot takes from every direction about BAAJA, most voters haven’t heard a thing about the bill,” Catherine Fraser, the climate program manager at Data for Progress, told me in a text message last night. “A useful reminder that Twitter/X is not real life.”

Sign up to receive Heatmap AM in your inbox every morning:
Shale giant Diamondback Energy has struck a deal to buy Double Eagle’s portfolio of drilling sites across the Permian Basin for roughly $5 billion. The deal, news of which the Financial Times broke Monday, is the latest move by Diamondback to tighten its grip over America’s most productive drilling region. The company spent $26 billion in a cash-and-stock merger with Endeavor Energy Resources in 2024, turning the producer from a “middling player to the largest independent oil and gas producer in the basin,” the newspaper reported.
In Canada’s most productive drilling region, the Alberta oil sands, consolidation is also underway. The latest example came Monday when Canadian Natural Resources announced a nearly $1.8 billion deal to buy Advantage Energy.
One of the more challenging name issues in clean energy resides in the fact that geothermal heating systems, which maintain steady temperatures in homes and buildings, bear the same name as the technology that fracks into hot rocks to establish large-scale baseload power stations. Given the recent breakthroughs in the latter, you’d be forgiven for sort of forgetting about the former. But Darcy Geothermal, a startup seeking to produce more geothermal heating and cooling for large buildings and district heating systems, just raised $15 million in a Series B round, I can exclusively report for this newsletter. The financing, co-led by the venture firms Aligned Climate Capital and Büetigen, is meant to help the company expand its U.S. operations and lay the groundwork for a Canadian and European Union expansion.
“Geothermal has tremendous potential to help building owners lower their energy costs, but the complexity of developing and financing these projects has kept many from moving forward,” Darcy CEO Andrew Steiner said in a statement. “We’ve spent years building the technical expertise and project delivery capabilities to address those challenges. This investment will allow us to bring that experience to more markets and give customers a simpler way to move from evaluating geothermal to putting a system in the ground.”
An electric vehicle boom is underway in India. From January to October of this year, India’s sales of passenger and light-duty electric vehicles surpassed 300,000 units, roughly double the 150,000 sold over the same period in 2025, according to data from the consultancy Benchmark Mineral Intelligence. October alone saw 41,274 deliveries, the second consecutive month above 40,000. Battery-electric vehicles accounted for the large majority of the sales. Still, EVs only made up around 6% of the total market in October.
Rob welcomes back Julian Brave NoiseCat to talk about the National Historic Preservation Act and why it’s so central to these negotiations.
One big sticking point that’s emerged in negotiations over the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act are the changes it would make to the National Historic Preservation Act. The bill would rewrite Section 106 of that law, which requires the federal government to consult with tribal nations before it permits a major project on or adjacent to land of Native cultural value. Crucially, the protections in Section 106 of the NHPA don’t end at the borders of a reservation. They extend to public and private property, as well.
The initial version of the legislation would have shrunk the scope and shortened the deadlines of reviews under the NHPA, and imposed punitive new rules on the officials in charge of overseeing those processes. It would have also allowed the federal government to step in and take over a local official’s office if officials thought they weren’t moving quickly enough. A subsequent amendment would soften many of those revisions, but not all of them.
Tribes have emerged as one of the most important players in the permitting bill negotiations. Joining us today to talk about these dynamics is Julian Brave NoiseCat. He’s the author of the excellent memoir, We Survived the Night, and a director of the Oscar-nominated documentary, Sugarcane. He has worked at the climate activist group 350.org, the progressive polling firm Data for Progress, and helped lead the effort to get Deb Haaland appointed and confirmed as the first Native American Secretary of the Interior. He’s also an enrolled member of the Canim Lake Band Tsqʼéscen̓ of the Secwépemc nation up in British Columbia. We talk about the changes the bill would make to the NHPA, how the tribes have handled those changes, and what could come next for both tribal and environmental politics.
Shift Key is hosted by Robinson Meyer, the founding executive editor of Heatmap News.
Subscribe to “Shift Key” and find this episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can also add the show’s RSS feed to your podcast app to follow us directly.
Here is an excerpt from their conversation:
Robinson Meyer: I think what’s interesting is that then when the bill came out, it was way more punitive than I think people had anticipated. And there was some sense that NHPA might be involved in a permanent reform, but it was way more punitive, I think, especially to the [Tribal Historic Preservation Offices], the THPOs, than had been necessarily anticipated. It said they could be defunded, as you said. It basically said if they didn’t make decisions in time, then their leadership couldn’t leave the 25-mile radius of the office.
Julian Brave NoiseCat: Oh, I didn’t catch that part. That’s crazy. Yeah, I think there’s a couple things to bring up here. The first is that this is a live debate beyond, as we’ve kind of been getting at, just the permitting reform bill. So we should also say that this bill is happening in the context of, over the summer, the ACHP — the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, the agency created by NHPA — had actually voted on new rules about how it was going to implement the Section 106 process, which was going to impact tribes. My understanding is that they were going to fold in tribal consultation into one sort of big kind of process.
So this is a moving area of policy, both within the context of the permitting reform debate and beyond the context of this legislation. And I suspect that no matter what happens with this bill, it will remain that way for future administrations, for future Congresses. This is just going to continue to be an issue because of course, the tribal nation-to-nation relationship with the federal government is one that is just continuous. And tribes are always going to want to have a greater say over what happens in their historic home.
Meyer: When the agency made that change, was it popular? With tribes?
NoiseCat: No. No. No, they opposed it. The reality for tribes right now is that they are ... it’s a kind of complicated situation, in a certain way. On the one hand, tribes have never been more powerful from a certain vantage point. In the big picture, you have the first Native American woman governor elected to New Mexico. You have two Native women who have been elected to the Senate. Tribes operate gaming operations across the country that generate like $45 billion in revenue or something like that. They’re almost half of all brick and mortar gaming operations in the country. And tribal concerns, because they tend to exist in a geography that is actually more rural and more conservative, are actually kind of pretty close to the bellwether of American politics. There are politicians who Democrats would be shocked to learn are actually generally pretty good on tribal concerns, like Senator Lisa Murkowski.
There are others, however, who come from those types of jurisdictions who take a slightly different approach, where they tend to take on the tribes in their jurisdictions a little bit more. So a big part of the dynamic I would say around this bill is that Senator Mike Lee is a Republican from Utah, and there is a distinct Utah Republican tradition of taking on tribal sovereignty that goes all the way back to — and here real ball knowers are going to know what I’m talking about. But there was an era of federal Indian policy called termination in the 1950s that extended into the 1960s, wherein the stated goal of the federal government to Native nations was to terminate them legally. And it was spearheaded by a Utah Republican named Arthur V. Watkins. And if you have been paying attention to Mike Lee’s statements over the years, going all the way back to like Bears Ears, all the way back to Deb Haaland’s confirmation, he has always had a little bit more of an oppositional approach to tribal interests.
You can find a full transcript of the episode here.
Mentioned:
Previously on Shift Key: How Julian Brave NoiseCat Changed His Mind About Climate Politics
What was in the original bill
The Last-Minute Changes to the Senate Permitting Deal, Explained
More on the cultural politics of the permitting bill
This episode of Shift Key is sponsored by ...
Formed through a joint venture between Wärtsilä and RCT Solutions, Valo helps utilities, independent power producers, and developers navigate market and grid complexity without sacrificing system performance. Learn more at valoenergy.com.
Every year Giving Green researches the top climate nonprofits and sends 100% of every dollar donated to its Giving Green Fund straight to them. Make your first gift before the new year, and it will be matched up to $1,000. Go to GivingGreen.earth/Shift.
Music for Shift Key is by Adam Kromelow.